CBC Analysis
ANTHONY WESTELL:
Tories safe until Liberals, NDP get their act together
CBC News Viewpoint | January 24, 2006 | More from Anthony Westell


Anthony Westell - Retired Journalist Anthony Westell was Globe and Mail bureau chief in Ottawa, 1964-69, and later a national affairs columnist for the Toronto Star.


For years the Liberals coasted to victory in election after election because the centre-right vote was split between the Progressive Conservatives and the Reform, later Alliance, party. In yesterday's election the position was reversed. The right was unified in the new Conservative party while the centre left was split between the Liberals, the NDP and the Greens –not to mention the Bloc Québécois which claims to be social democratic.

It's really as simple as that. Final vote totals will show that the majority of Canadians remain center-left in their politics, and Liberal and NDP MPs will outnumber the Conservatives in the new House. However, government in Ottawa may well remain in Conservative hands until their opponents can get their act together.

On the right, it took years of civil war and election defeats before the Reform/Alliance could overcome and swallow the PCs. It will be no easier, probably harder, on the left as the Liberals and the NDP struggle for supremacy, unless of course Stephen Harper quickly proves a failure as prime minister and voters turn back to the Liberals in a reflex action.

That's not likely, but he is the least qualified person to become prime minister in at least half a century: educated to MA level in one university; never served in a government or held an executive position in business, seldom travelled outside North America. He has promised to govern from the centre and should have no trouble surviving for a year or two, if only because the opposition would not dare outrage the public by forcing yet another election before he has had a fair chance. In fact, his most serious opposition may come from true believers of his own – backbenchers, social conservatives, neo-conservative economists and libertarians who believe the best government is the smallest government. They have toiled for years to gain power to steer Canada away from the centre and toward the right. How much slack will they cut Harper?

In passing, it's impossible to imagine what the elder statesmen of the G8, in Washington and at the UN will make of this neophyte.

But we know at least that he's a good politician, with killer instincts behind the choirboy's shy smile. Just look what he did to Paul Martin. The Gomery report specifically cleared Martin of any responsibility for the sponsorship scandal a decade ago. But that did not deter Harper for a minute. He declared Martin, his government and the Liberal party to be corrupt and without the moral authority to govern. It was invention and a skeptical media would not have let him get away with it. Instead, the media cheered him on and actually helped him convince the country that Martin was not to be trusted.

Martin was pathetically unable to fight back, and just when that storm seemed to be passing, the RCMP put its spoke in his wheel by announcing, quite unnecessarily, that although it had no evidence a crime had been committed it was investigating a rumour of a leak from Finance Minister Ralph Goodale's office. Ah ha, cried the opposition, more Liberal corruption, and many observers have dated the decline and fall of the Liberal government from that event.

There was another event unnoticed by most Canadians that may have had a significant influence on the campaign. The Globe and Mail and CTV reported a poll showing the Conservatives with an enormous lead. The Conservatives gained momentum, the Liberals lost it. Other less publicized polls never found such a lead, and it probably never existed.

Of such campaign events is power won and lost.

Now onto the battle to see who will replace Martin as Liberal leader and begin to rebuild the party. Next may come a PQ government in Quebec, and perhaps a referendum on sovereignty. Who says Canadian politics is dull?


^TOP
CBC Ombudsman
MENU
ANALYSIS & VIEWPOINT MAIN PAGE » REPORTS FROM ABROAD
CBC CONTRIBUTORS: Editor's Notes
Mary Sheppard
Global View: Ghana
Colleen Ross
Health
Maureen Taylor
Minority Report
Natasha Fatah
The National
Rex Murphy
On the Money
Tom McFeat
Postcard from America
Rosa Hwang
Schlesinger's View
Joe Schlesinger
Army Reservist
Mike Vernon

FREELANCE CONTRIBUTORS: Cafe Chat
June Chua
Disability Matters
Living with a disability
Global View: Asia
Ashifa Kassam
Global View: China
Kirk Kenny
Global View: China
Trevor Metz
Global View: China
Sylvia Yu Chao
Global View: Denmark
Jessica Grant Jørgensen
Global View: India
Siva Swaminathan
Global View: Ireland
Clare Byrne
Global View:Japan
Dan Hilton
Global View: Middle East
Jim Reed
Global View: South Korea
Yoav Cerralbo
Global View: Uganda
Jonathan Woodward
Global View: Zambia
Mike Quinn
Inside Medicine
Sandra Donaldson
Inside Ottawa
Chris Waddell
Legal Affairs
Michelle Mann
Maritime Log
Vicki Robertson
Media Watch
Ira Basen
Modern Living
Georgie Binks
Observations
Martin O'Malley
On the other hand
Anthony Westell
Politics
Larry Zolf
Schooling
Mary-Ellen Lang
Science Decoded
Sumitra Rajagopalan
Science Friction
Stephen Strauss
A Soldier's Story
Sgt. Russell D. Storring
A Soldier's Diary from Afghanistan
Cpl. Brian Sanders
Stand on Guard
Heather Mallick
West Coast Living
Gloria Chang
Western View
Terilyn S. Paulgaard

» PAST CONTRIBUTORS

ABOUT VIEWPOINT:
Viewpoint is CBC.ca's place for informed opinion and commentary. Our goal is to provide a range of informed perspectives from around the world and here at home on issues of interest to Canadians. All material published in the Viewpoint section is subject to CBC’s journalistic policy, standards and practices.

Writing for Viewpoint
We accept queries from people with significant expertise in their field and previous writing experience. We are interested in domestic and international contributions. We do not accept unsolicited finished pieces.

If you want to contribute to Viewpoint, please send your query to letters@cbc.ca with VIEWPOINT in the subject line and please include three samples of your published work. Columns are typically 800 words in length and focus on timely issues, events or personal stories with wide appeal. Please familiarize yourself with our content before submitting your ideas. Only those accepted will be contacted.
FEEDBACK:
Questions or comments? Email us!
MORE:
Print this page