Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

RICHARD HANDLER: THE IDEAS GUY

More bowling alone in America

Aug. 22, 2007

The bowling alone guy has struck again.

I'm referring, naturally, to Robert Putnam, the Harvard political scientist whose Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community became an instant classic when it was published in 2000.

That wonderful, provocative title underscores his message that Americans are retreating from civic engagement, which is supposed to be at the core of what makes America such a lively and vibrant society.

Now Putnam has added to his thesis with a more provocative argument about multiculturalism. It may be something for us Canadians to take note of as well.

Putnam has discovered that people who live in racially and ethnically mixed communities are less happy and trusting and more isolated. And here's the really surprising point: those who live in these neighborhoods not only distrust people who look and act differently. They are even suspicious and wary of people who look like themselves.

Talk about bowling alone.

Putnam's classic takes it cues from the great French observer, Alexis de Tocqueville, whose Democracy in America appeared in two volumes in the mid-1800s.

De Tocqueville marvelled at the vigour of the democracy springing up on American soil. This democratic impulse was based on more than just occasional elections but on the willingness of its citizens to embrace "voluntary associations."

Rotary clubs and Shriners in funny hats driving go-karts may be the butt of jokes for modern day urban sophisticates. But their clubbiness is the glue that makes people stick — and care — for each other.

Groups like these aren't top-down organizations founded by the state. They're local and have a life of their own like so many grass-roots political clubs, volunteer fire departments and charities, with potluck suppers thrown in for good, hearty measure.

Turning turtle

It is no wonder, as social theorists like Hannah Arendt have pointed out, that totalitarian states try to stamp out voluntary associations wherever they can. They are trying to make their citizens totally reliant on the state and encouraging them to be suspicious of each other.

It is no wonder, too, that Bowling Alone caused such a flurry in 2000. By updating de Tocqueville, Putnam was making the point that Americans were withdrawing from the very thing that nourished their democracy.

Modern-day Americans did not join clubs as much as they used to, or take the same kind of interest in local affairs. Nor did they play together as they had in the past. Even Little League had become an intense, ultra-competitive sport, run like a corporate business. Parents wanted their children to be stars — pint-sized elite athletes. Community spirit became replaced by the solitary ego.

As for bowling, it had always been the quintessential group activity, with league shirts and group camaraderie. (Even Richard Nixon liked it, though he may well have bowled alone in the last, forlorn days of his presidency.)

Hence, Putnam's sad title — Bowling Alone — was the perfect, poignant symbol for the fate of an inward-looking America.

Attending the odd book club get-together isn't the answer to this unravelling of the collective thread. Humans are social beings. Too much isolation and they become apprehensive and glum. Many books have been written about this painful theme: America, and other industrialized societies, are essentially lonely places, full of anxiety and anomie where alcohol and drugs are used to help soothe the pain, though not successfully.

Putnam's new thesis picks up this theme of isolation and advances it. What he is saying is that people who live in multicultural communities are alienated not only from "the other" but also from those who they were once comfortable with.

They don't join local organizations to solve problems. In fact, there are only two activities they do more of today than before: they go on more protest marches (that's their politics) and they watch more TV (that's their entertainment).

Basically, they hunker down. In Putnam's multicultural America, people are becoming "turtles," he says, living under their shell, wary of each other and themselves.

Hail the hordes

Before you scream prejudice (or racist) let me tell you two things. First, Putnam's most recent work, which is published in an academic journal, is based on thorough research and detailed interviews with 30,000 Americans in large and small communities. So it's not just an exercise in political theory or polemics.

Second, Putnam is no conservative. In fact, he calls himself a "progressive," which is the term that liberals in America now use to describe themselves. It avoids the nasty L-word, which has been turned into a sneering obscenity on right-wing talk shows. Putnam wants his fellow progressives to wake up to a problem they would rather duck.

Another thing about Putnam is that, in spite of his findings, he is remarkably hopeful. He takes the long view, being a real scholar after all.

America (and Canada) is going through a time of intense immigration that is transforming the look and nature of the country. The last time this happened on this scale in the U.S. was from 1890 to 1920.

Back then, waves of Italians, Jews, Irish, Germans and others arrived in American harbours as your proverbial huddled masses. They often spoke no English. They wore odd clothing, ate strange foods and lived in tenements.

Those who were already living in these cities often felt threatened. They didn't think the new immigrants would assimilate. Riots and fights broke out. Just see Martin Scorsese's movie, The Gangs of New York.

Now similar waves of immigrants, both legal and illegal, are flooding into the U.S. and Canada. Putnam is less scared than some commentators, such as Pat Buchanan whose new book is called State of Emergency: The Third World Invasion and Conquest of America. Putnam thinks with time and the right measures these people can assimilate as did the so-called hordes of yesterday.

What is needed overall, he argues, is that these new immigrants become part of a new, encompassing "we." And that's a tough challenge. I will come back to this in a future column.

Go to the Top

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

Biography

Handler

Richard Handler is a producer with the CBC Radio program Ideas.


More From
Richard Handler »

More
Analysis & Viewpoint »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Sri Lankan parliament dissolved
Sri Lankan president Mahinda Rajapaksa has dissolved parliament, setting the stage for new elections a day after authorities arrested Gen. Sarath Fonseka, his chief rival and the leader of the opposition.
Avalanches near Afghan capital kill over 60
Avalanches in a mountain pass north of Kabul have killed at least 60 people, injured about 400 and left 1,500 stranded on blocked roads, Afghan officials say.
Haitian man pulled from rubble Video
A 28-year-old man has been pulled from rubble in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, claiming to have been trapped there since the massive earthquake on Jan. 12.
more »

Canada »

Health costs push Alberta budget deficit to $4.75B Video
Alberta's Progressive Conservative government is projecting a record $4.75-billion budget deficit and planning cuts in many departments while increasing health-care spending.
Trenton colonel's charges spur cold case review Video
The 2001 slaying of a Nova Scotia woman at CFB Trenton in eastern Ontario is among the cases being re-examined after murder charges were laid against Col. Russell Williams.
Neighbours stunned by arrest of Col. Williams
Ottawa resident Michael Gennis was stunned when he found out his new neighbour, Col. Russell Williams, had been charged with killing two women in eastern Ontario.
more »

Politics »

Tories need plan for isotope shortage: Ignatieff
Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff accused the Conservative government of having no plan of action to deal with a medical isotope shortage expected to worsen later this month.
Ottawa to appeal injection site ruling Video
The federal government is asking the Supreme Court of Canada for leave to appeal a lower court ruling that sanctioned Vancouver's supervised drug injection site.
Montreal inventor unveils 3-D baggage scanner Video
A Montreal inventor has developed a three-dimensional baggage scanner that he says can make air travel safer and more convenient for passengers.
more »

Health »

Ottawa to appeal injection site ruling Video
The federal government is asking the Supreme Court of Canada for leave to appeal a lower court ruling that sanctioned Vancouver's supervised drug injection site.
Antidepressant interferes with breast-cancer drug
Women taking the breast cancer drug tamoxifen should avoid taking the antidepressant Paxil because the antidepressant may cancel out the benefits of the cancer treatment, researchers say.
Obamas aim to improve kids' health, fitness
A nationwide campaign to combat childhood obesity was launched Tuesday by U.S. President Barack Obama and his wife Michelle.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Perez Hilton, Black Eyed Peas manager settle
A civil lawsuit stemming from a scuffle between outrageous celebrity blogger Perez Hilton and a manager for the Black Eyed Peas has been dropped.
Winners, losers emerge in native art deal Audio
When Vancouver was granted the Olympics, the organizing committee struck a formal partnership with four First Nations who claim the lands where the Games are to be held and spoke of showcasing native culture to the world. But some native people say the promise of jobs, training, and business opportunities for aboriginals is proving empty.
Halifax concert raises $270K for Haiti
Thousands of people packed the Halifax Metro Centre Monday night to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars to help the people of earthquake-devastated Haiti.
more »

Technology & Science »

Google adds social media to Gmail
Google is introducing Buzz, a group of features that add Facebook and Twitter-like functionality to Gmail.
Montreal inventor unveils 3-D baggage scanner Video
A Montreal inventor has developed a three-dimensional baggage scanner that he says can make air travel safer and more convenient for passengers.
Tech buying bounces back in 2009: NPD
Canadians spent $4.66 billion on computer and information technology products in 2009, up one per cent from 2008.
more »

Money »

Health costs push Alberta budget deficit to $4.75B Video
Alberta's Progressive Conservative government is projecting a record $4.75-billion budget deficit and planning cuts in many departments while increasing health-care spending.
Honda recalls 378,000 cars for airbag defect
Honda Motor Co. is adding more than 378,000 cars to a safety recall for airbag inflation problems.
Toyota recall spreads to Prius and beyond Video
Toyota is recalling 437,000 Prius and other hybrid cars worldwide to fix brake problems — the latest embarrassing safety defect for the world's largest automaker.
more »

Consumer Life »

Tim Hortons defends customer ban
Tim Hortons is defending a New Brunswick store owner's decision to ban a customer who complained repeatedly about its decaffeinated coffee.
500,000 cribs recalled in U.S.
Government safety officials in the U.S. have announced a recall of more than 500,000 drop-side cribs sold at Buy Buy Baby, Kmart, Wal-Mart and other stores after the death of three infants.
Montreal inventor unveils 3-D baggage scanner Video
A Montreal inventor has developed a three-dimensional baggage scanner that he says can make air travel safer and more convenient for passengers.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Senators keep marching with win over Flames
The Ottawa Senators notched their 12th win in the last 13 games with a 3-2 come-from-behind win over the visiting Calgary Flames on Tuesday.
Canucks struck down by Lightning
Martin St. Louis had two goals and one assist as the Tampa Bay Lightning beat the Vancouver Canucks 3-1 on Tuesday night.
B.C. Lions owner Braley buys Argonauts
Toronto Argonauts co-owners David Cynamon and Howard Sokolowski have completed an agreement to sell the franchise to B.C. Lions owner David Braley.
more »