Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

MINORITY REPORT

Holocaust deniers should spend a day at Auschwitz

April 29, 2008

As we approach Holocaust Remembrance Day on May 1, I've noticed the reemergence of Holocaust denial.

I am reminded of the day two years ago, when I visited the Auschwitz death camps in Poland to meet the ghosts of a million dead souls. There I was, a Muslim woman entering a place where the attempted extermination of the Jewish people took place more than 60 years ago. I was there to see the dark side of humanity for myself.

Conflicting emotions overcame me as I walked towards the iron gate. Was I coming to pay tribute to the millions killed by the Nazis or was I a tourist coming to check off one more world historic site? I decided this was to be a private sojourn and I would not talk or write about it. And so I didn't, until now — when I've begun to realize that Holocaust deniers continue to insist that the event never happened; that it is a Jewish conspiracy. In denying the Holocaust, we fall prey to the same evil that almost wiped out one of humanity's most ancient people.

Auschwitz and the sister camp Birkenau are located in a small town called Oswiecim, where huge apartment buildings are just a few metres away from one of history's worst death camps. It's hard to imagine why anyone would want to live here, but I read that after the end of the war, some Jews returned to this area and still live here. An act of defiance to the German master plan, I suppose. At the Auschwitz entrance is the infamous gateway that reads "Arbeit Macht Frei" which translates into "Work shall set you free." I wondered what the purpose of that sign was. Was it a way to throw off the Jews, so that they might actually believe freedom was a possibility? Or did the Nazis erect it as some sort of cruel joke?

Tourist mecca or tourist trap?

Auschwitz is a surprisingly small area, only 40 square kilometres and containing about 40 sub-camps where the captives worked and slept. Despite its size, thousands and thousands of people lived, worked and died in this tiny, confined area. It's dark, dusty, and damp — an appropriate atmosphere for a place like this. The place feels hollow and empty. But Auschwitz is hardly empty. It is teeming with tourists.

The former living and working quarters have been converted into a museum, and people from all walks of life come to see this historic relic. And again, this is where my discomfort comes in. Outside the gates to Auschwitz are dozens of tour buses with camera-happy travellers pushing their way through the gate. It didn't seem right — why would Sunshine Tours and Safeway Travels and their palm-tree, smiley-face logo-ed buses come here? I wonder what the survivors of Auschwitz think about people like us, spending a few hours here, before we move on to our next tourist attraction.

The museum houses several huge aquarium-like displays that encase the belongings of the Jews who lost their lives. One display was filled with eyeglasses. Another was brimming with toothbrushes; another, with dishes and bowls. There was an entire room filled with shoes, all of which were torn and ripped and looked fit for the trash. A tour guide from Spain explained that the Nazis only kept the ugly shoes at Auschwitz. All the beautiful, expensive shoes were immediately sent back to Germany and distributed to "real" Germans. As a Jew, you weren't even fit to have a decent pair of shoes.

I saw a display filled with the empty cans that once contained the gas that was used to kill millions of Jews. But even more disturbing than that was a display filled with human hair, millions of strands of hair. Hair, shaved off the heads of the women who were brought to Auschwitz, just before they were sent to the gas chambers. Their hair was used to make clothes and blankets for Germany. It is thought that many of those blankets must still be in German basements and closets.

One of the last displays holds thousands of pieces of luggage, each one with the owner's name and address written in chalk. I can only imagine what the owners of the luggage were thinking. Coming here with all their belongings, unaware of the hell awaited them. Every single name on every single piece of luggage represents a life, a family, a neighbourhood, a community, part of all of our communities — stolen from us.

A 15-minute walk from Auschwitz is Birkenau, the sister camp, which is where most of the Jews were gassed. I stood outside the camp, staring at the bunks and rooms, and the towers from which the guards must have kept an eye on their captives 60 years ago. But even all these years later, it doesn't seem like we've learned much.

Just two years after allied troops liberated Auschwitz, in faraway India, Muslims, Hindus and Sikhs butchered each other in a religious frenzy that produced one million dead bodies in just three months of bloodbath. Had they not learned anything from the holocaust? Today, genocide continues to take place in Darfur, where fairer skinned Muslims slaughter their darker skinned African brothers and sisters. Will anyone learn from history? Not if we continue to deny the Holocaust and let the memory of six million dead vanish into thin air.

Go to the Top

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

Biography

Natasha Fatah

Natasha Fatah is a producer for CBC Radio's Current Affairs Show "As It Happens." Prior to that, she was a television and radio reporter in Windsor, Ontario. She has degrees in Journalism from Ryerson University and in Political Science from the University of Toronto. She has lectured on anti-racism, politics and media studies at elementary and secondary schools around the Greater Toronto Area. In 1996, she was the host of 'News from the Muslim World' on Vision TV.

More From This Author

More From
NATASHA FATAH »
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Mideast Quartet urges Israel to freeze settlement Video
Top international diplomats on Friday called on Israel and the Palestinians to return to peace negotiations with a goal of reaching a final settlement that would create an independent Palestinian state within 24 months.
Arrests end UN talks with Taliban
Pakistan's recent arrests of top Taliban leaders have halted the United Nation's secret talks with the insurgency, the former UN envoy to Afghanistan says.
Canadians safe after yacht hits Galapagos reef
A Toronto couple and their relatives were among 16 Canadians and eight Ecuadorian crew members rescued from a yacht that ran aground Wednesday evening in the Galapagos Islands.
more »

Canada »

Montreal shootings may be revenge killings Video
A brazen fatal shooting in an Old Montreal clothing store Thursday afternoon could be a response to the recent slaying of the son of Vito Rizzuto, the reputed head of the Montreal Mafia, police sources said.
February inflation hotter than expected Video
Consumer prices rose 1.6 per cent in the 12 months to February, topping the forecasts of economists and boosting the possibility of interest rate hikes by the Bank of Canada.
Children's Aid worker stabbed in Windsor
A Windsor, Ont., children's aid worker is in hospital after she was stabbed in the parking lot of the Children's Aid Society.
more »

Politics »

Contraception 'option' in maternal health plan Video
Birth control won't be excluded after all from the Conservative government's new maternal health intitiative for developing countries.
Mideast Quartet urges Israel to freeze settlement Video
Top international diplomats on Friday called on Israel and the Palestinians to return to peace negotiations with a goal of reaching a final settlement that would create an independent Palestinian state within 24 months.
Harper collects on beer bet with Obama
Prime Minister Stephen Harper collected on his sudsy Olympic hockey bet with President Barack Obama as the U.S. ambassador to Canada delivered beer to 24 Sussex Drive.
more »

Health »

Seniors take 5 drugs or more: study
Almost two-thirds of Canadian seniors in some provinces are taking five or more types of prescription drugs, according to a new report.
Sweetened drinks may aggravate liver disease Video
The daily consumption of high-fructose corn syrup might aggravate liver damage in people who suffer from non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, a U.S. study suggests.
Public defibrillators improve survival
Placing portable defibrillators in public places such as schools and workplaces has helped people survive cardiac arrest, Japanese researchers say.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Fess Parker of Davey Crockett fame dies
Actor Fess Parker, who played American frontier heroes Davy Crockett and Daniel Boone, died Thursday. He was 85.
Beaverbrook Foundation faces money woes Video
The Beaverbrook U.K. Foundation may have to sell some of its assets to pay mounting legal bills stemming from its seven-year dispute with Fredericton's art gallery, an audit has revealed.
Canadian broadcasters lost money in 2009
Financial data on Canada's private broadcasters confirms a steep slide in industry profitability and revenues in 2009.
more »

Technology & Science »

Cassini reveals Saturn's raucous rings
New data from the Cassini probe has revealed that Saturn is a turbulent planet with odd weather patterns and constantly shifting rings.
Large Hadron Collider sets beam energy record
Operators of the world's largest atom smasher have ramped up their massive machine to three times the energy ever previously achieved, in the run-up to experiments probing the secrets of the universe.
Cloaking device takes microscopic step
Researchers in Germany report they were able to cloak a tiny bump in a layer of gold, preventing its detection in three dimensions at nearly visible infrared frequencies.
more »

Money »

February inflation hotter than expected Video
Consumer prices rose 1.6 per cent in the 12 months to February, topping the forecasts of economists and boosting the possibility of interest rate hikes by the Bank of Canada.
High dollar hurting British ex-pats
The high-flying Canadian dollar might bring many benefits but British pensioners living in B.C. say the high-flying loonie is hurting their bottom lines.
Canadian retail sales pick up in January
Retail sales increased 0.7 per cent in January as consumers opened their wallets on home improvements to take advantage of expiring tax credits.
more »

Consumer Life »

February inflation hotter than expected Video
Consumer prices rose 1.6 per cent in the 12 months to February, topping the forecasts of economists and boosting the possibility of interest rate hikes by the Bank of Canada.
Facebook password email a scam Video
Another email scam is circulating online trying to ensnare unsuspecting Facebook users into divulging their passwords.
Air Canada stands by pilot
Air Canada is standing by a pilot at the centre of a bizarre incident two years ago in which co-workers refused to fly with him, fearing he was suicidal and accusing him of threatening to ditch his aircraft in the Atlantic Ocean.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Luongo redeemed as Canucks beat Sharks
Roberto Luongo made 32 saves as the Vancouver Canucks beat the San Jose Sharks 3-2 on Thursday night.
Maple Leafs defeat Devils in shootout
Phil Kessel, Nikolai Kulemin and John Mitchell all scored in the shootout as the Toronto Maple Leafs beat the New Jersey Devils 2-1 on Thursday night.
Senators throttled by Thrashers
Nik Antropov and Colby Armstrong each scored twice as the Atlanta Thrashers beat the Ottawa Senators 6-3 on Thursday night.
more »