Samsung copied iPhone's 'entire design,' patent trial hears
Rival chose to copy successful Apple products rather than innovate own designs, lawyer argues
The Associated Press
Posted: Jul 31, 2012 4:04 PM ET
Last Updated: Jul 31, 2012 9:20 PM ET
Apple attorneys argued Tuesday that when faced with the choice of innovating its own products or copying the design of Apple's successful smartphones and tablets, Samsung chose the latter. Lawyers for both sides were to make opening remarks on the second day of a closely watched patent trail between the two tech rivals. Above, the Apple logo is seen at the Apple store in Grand Central Terminal in New York. (Mark Lennihan/Associated Press)
An attorney for Apple told a jury in a San Jose, Calif., courtroom Tuesday that rival technology company Samsung faced two options to compete in the booming cellphone market after then Apple CEO Steve Jobs introduced the iPhone to critical acclaim in 2007: innovate or copy.
Harold McElhinny claimed Samsung Electronics Inc. chose to copy, making its smartphones and computer tablets illegal knockoffs of Apple's popular products.
Samsung "has copied the entire design and user experience" of Apple's iPhone and iPad, McElhinny told a 10-person jury during his opening remarks at the closely watched patent trial.
Samsung denies the claims, and its lawyers were expected to deliver their opening statement later Tuesday.
Samsung has previously countered that Apple did the stealing. It has also said some of the technology at issue — such as the rounded rectangular designs of smartphones and tablets — has been the industry standard for years.
Apple CEO won't testify
The witness lists of both sides are long on experts, engineers and designers and short on familiar names. For example, Apple CEO Tim Cook is not scheduled to testify.
Cupertino-based Apple filed its lawsuit against Samsung last year and is demanding $2.5 billion US in damages, an award that would dwarf the largest patent-related verdict to date.
The case marks the latest skirmish between the two companies over product designs. A similar trial began last week, and the two companies have been fighting in other courts in the United Kingdom and Germany.
U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh in San Jose last month ordered Samsung to pull its Galaxy 10.1 computer tablet from the U.S. market pending the outcome of the patent trial. However, she barred Apple attorneys from telling jurors about the ban.
"In some sense, the big part of the case is not Apple's demands for damages but whether Samsung gets to sell its products," said Mark A. Lemley, a professor and director of the Stanford Program in Law, Science, and Technology.
A verdict in Apple's favour could send a message to consumers that Android-based products such as Samsung's are in legal jeopardy, Lemley said.
A verdict in Samsung's favour, especially if it prevails on its demands that Apple pay its asking price for certain transmission technology, could lead to higher-priced Apple products.
Apple late to cellphone market, Samsung claims
In court papers filed last week, each company laid out its legal strategy in trial briefs.
Apple lawyers argue there is almost no difference between Samsung products and its own, and that the South Korean company's internal documents show it copied Apple's iconic designs and its interface.
Samsung denies the allegation and counter-claims that Apple copied its iPhone from Sony. Samsung lawyers noted that it has been developing mobile phones since 1991 and that Apple jumped into the market in 2007.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Remains found on murder suspect Millard's Ontario farm
- Police searching the farm that belonged to Dellen Millard, the 27-year-old suspect charged with first-degree murder in the death of Ancaster, Ont., man Tim Bosma, have found more remains on the property. more »
- Can the Senate fire a senator?
- An expert on parliamentary rules says the Senate has the power to turf a senator from the chamber, as long as a majority approves the expulsion, and as long as there is cause. more »
- Harper chief of staff resigns amid Senate expense scandal
- Nigel Wright has resigned as Prime Minister Stephen Harper's chief of staff, following revelations he wrote a $90,000 cheque to repay living expenses claimed by Senator Mike Duffy. more »
- Jeep driver apologizes after stunt kills Edmonton woman
- A man claiming to be the driver of a Jeep that struck and killed a spectator at a charity event in Edmonton says he is sorry for what happened. more »
Must Watch
Latest Technology & Science News Headlines
- Bell Mobility to appeal ruling in 911 lawsuit
- Bell Mobility says the company plans to appeal a Northwest Territories Supreme Court ruling that says the company is liable for charging 911 fees to customers that aren't receiving the service. more »
- Anteater's birth in female-only pen stumps zoo staff
- Confused Connecticut conservation officers are wondering how a female anteater, who has given birth at the centre, conceived without a male in the pen. more »
- High Arctic research station saved by new funding
- Canada's northernmost research lab won't have to shut down after all and will be able to resume year-round operations, with the help of a new grant from the federal government. more »
- 2 earthquakes felt in Ontario and Quebec
- Two earthquakes near the Ontario-Quebec border could be felt across both provinces this morning. more »
Bob McDonald's Blog
Chris Hadfield: The gravity of gravity May. 17, 2013 9:58 AM After five months of being Superman and a media superstar, Canadian astronaut Chris Hadfield is now beginning the challenging task of adapting his mortal body and brain to life back on Earth.
Quirks & Quarks
- May 18: Apps for Apes May. 17, 2013 4:26 PM Scientists at more than 2 dozen zoos around the world, including the Toronto Zoo, have been using computer tablets to stimulate our bright orange primate cousins, the orangutans. And the orangutans have been loving it.
Latest Features
- Remains found on murder suspect Millard's Ontario farm
- Petition looks to rename Victoria Day
- Vancouver man attacked, killed in Costa Rica
- Jeep driver apologizes after stunt kills Edmonton woman
- Rob Ford should resign if allegations true, councillors say
- Missing Toronto woman's parents unfazed by Millard link
- Harper chief of staff resigns amid Senate expense scandal
- Saudi coronavirus work stymied at Canadian lab
- Central Newfoundland digs out from freak snowfall

