MEDICAL TECHNOLOGY
Neuroprosthetics
Human-machine mergers promising, but reality yet to live up to hype
Last Updated: Tuesday, May 25, 2010 | 8:29 AM ET
By Grant Buckler, special to CBC News
The Utah Electrode Array can "talk" to nerves, telling parts of the body what to do.
Jens Naumann had been blind for 19 years. But in 2002, in a Portuguese hospital, the Canadian, then 39, began seeing flashes of light, then shapes of large objects.
That's because he was the first recipient of a brain implant called the Dobelle Eye.
Biomedical researcher William Dobelle worked for years to wire a tiny camera to a brain implant so people with irreparably damaged eyes might see again. It was an example of work being done in the field of neuroprosthetics, which explores making electronic devices communicate directly with the brain. One of the most common neuroprosthetic devices, the cochlear implant, has already helped nearly 200,000 people with hearing loss.
But technology to restore vision is still in the early development stages. Naumann says the Dobelle Eye implant gave him only rudimentary vision: "It is like seeing in a way, because you did feel a visual awareness."
Still, he could navigate around obstacles, locate objects and, with practice, read block letters 10 centimetres high. He even drove a car — slowly — in a parking lot. Sadly, it didn't last.
"The device was pretty functional for as long as you could baby it and doctor it," Naumann recalls. But after Dobelle's death in 2004, Naumann could not maintain it. The implant is still in his brain, but infections forced removal of the connectors placed in his skull to connect the external camera.
Sixteen patients had the implant, he says, but none had better luck than he did. The device was never approved in the U.S. or Canada — all operations were done in Portugal. Dobelle demonstrated the promise in feeding visual information directly into the brain — but also that was not ready for widespread use.
Neuroprosthetic progress
Researchers are exploring ways to use neuroprosthetics to restore broken communications between the brain and other parts of the body. It still isn't — but promising work continues in a number of areas.
While Dobelle placed his implant on the surface of the brain, for example, Mohamad Sawan, Canada research chair in smart medical devices and director of the Polystim Neurotechnologies Laboratory at Montreal's Ecole Polytechnique, is working on one with a needle-like probe that enters the cortex to reach the precise area where the optic nerve goes. Like Sawan, other researchers are going right into the brain so they can use weaker but more efficient electrical signals.
Sawan uses radio waves to connect his external camera with the brain implant, so there is no need for the external connectors that caused problems for Naumann. The technology is still in the trial stage, Sawan says, but the use of these types of implants in humans might be possible in as little as four to five years.
His implant will allow patients to see low-resolution images, he says, but it will be possible to zoom in on objects, so patients should even be able to read: "The patient can be completely independent."
While brain implants best suit people whose eyes are damaged past repair, other researchers are creating implants that go in the eye itself, stimulating the retina to overcome problems including macular degeneration and retinitis pigmentosa.
Optobionics of Glen Ellyn, Ill., has developed a tiny chip that stimulates dormant retinal cells when implanted in the eye. Alan Chow, Optobionics' founder, says his team initially expected electrical impulses from the chip would simply allow patients to see some light, but they actually stimulated dormant cells to start functioning again, restoring near-normal vision.
Trials in about 40 patients showed that while the implant won't restore dead retinal cells, it works in the approximately 60 per cent of cases where cells are simply dormant. But faced with costs of hundreds of millions of dollars for more extensive testing before the device could get regulatory approval in the U.S., Optobionics' backers have pulled out. Chow is trying to revive the company, and says simpler approval procedures in Canada might allow his technology to be used here first.
The Boston Retinal Implant Project has tested a similar implant that bypasses dead photoreceptors in the eyes of patients who suffer from macular degeneration and retinitis pigmentosa. The researchers plan human trials of their latest prototype soon, and Shawn Kelly, a researcher with the project, says the implants would probably cost $40,000 to $60,000 (including surgery) — similar to the cost of a cochlear implant.
Restoring movement
Rajesh Rao is a researcher at the University of Washington. Vision is just one area of neuroprosthetic development. Researchers are exploring ways to use neuroprosthetics to restore broken communications between the brain and other parts of the body, which could restore natural movement to people who are paralyzed or allow their brains to control prosthetic replacements for missing limbs.
A key to neuroprosthetics is the fact that the human nervous system uses weak electrical impulses to transmit information. The Utah Electrode Array is a tiny device — less than a sixth the size of a penny — that when implanted in the body can "talk" to nerves, telling parts of the body what to do.
Imagine a person paralyzed by spinal cord damage. The muscles function, but the brain can't communicate tell them to move. An electrode array can stimulate those muscles, says Greg Clark, associate professor of bioengineering at the University of Utah, giving the patient some motor control.
There are already simple systems that do this, Clark says, but they lack the fine control to produce smooth and efficient movement, so patients move awkwardly and tire quickly. By transmitting more data, the Utah Array should allow more precise control.
Clark says the ultimate system would use one pair of arrays to relay signals from the brain to nerves in, say, a leg, and two more arrays to return sensory feedback from the leg (so patients would feel their foot touching the floor, for instance). One scientist has already tested an electrode array collecting sensory feedback in his own arm, and all the necessary components have been tested in animals. However, a complete two-way sensory and muscle control system has not yet been built and tested in people, he says.
Other projects focus on using the brain to directly control devices outside the body. The BrainGate Research Team, with researchers at Brown University, Massachusetts General Hospital and Providence VA Medical Center, has tested a brain implant that can use signals from the brain to control a computer cursor.
Reasoning that fine muscle control is a difficult problem, University of Washington researchers are taking a different tack. The Neural Systems Group is experimenting with a small humanoid robot controlled by sensors worn outside the head. Because the robot has intelligence of its own, "when you tell it to pick up an object you don't have to tell it how to move its hand," says Rajesh Rao, associate professor of computer science and engineering. So imprecise signals from many neurons — detectable without an invasive implant — are enough.
Rao says the control system could use a menu where options would flash on a screen one by one, and the sensor would detect the user's recognition of the one wanted. The robot would also learn, so having once been taught step by step how to go to the refrigerator, the next time it would know the way.
Because this system would be worn, not implanted, approvals for its use should be easier, and Rao says possible entertainment uses of the technology could help bring the price down. Like most of today's neuroprosthetic research, it will take time to reach the point where the technology is ready for real-world use.
Still, progress is being made in many areas that help meld humans and machines. Jens Naumann's brief glimpse of the world a few years ago was a landmark event, and medical technology is going to make that world a lot more accessible to people with a range of physical challenges in the coming years.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Target dangles designer Jason Wu to lure Canadians
- Target Corporation's move into Canada, premiering with cheap fashions by hot designer Jason Wu, needs to promise and consistently deliver quality fashions at retail prices similar to U.S. rates, analysts say. more »
- Santorum, Romney spar in Republican debate
- Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum swapped accusations about spending and taxes Wednesday night in the 20th and possibly final debate of the roller-coaster race for the Republican presidential nomination. more »
- Qur'an burning riots kill 2 NATO soldiers
- Two NATO soldiers were shot and killed Thursday by a man wearing an Afghan army uniform who had joined protesters objecting to Qur'an burnings that took place at a U.S. base earlier in the week, says Reuters. more »
- Graham James apologizes to sex-abuse victims
- Graham James, the former junior hockey coach and convicted sexual abuser whose victims included ex-NHLers Theoren Fleury and Sheldon Kennedy, has told a courtroom: "For my behaviour, I am deeply sorry.… Parents expected sons to be safe; not all were." more »
Latest Technology & Science News Headlines
- EU at stalemate on Canada's oilsands ranking
- European Union officials are at a stalemate after voting on whether to classify Canada's oilsands crude as more harmful to the environment than other fuels — a proposal that Canada would fight. more »
- Twitter head tells those who spend hours on site to stop
- To those of you who tweet and follow others on Twitter all the livelong day, the co-founder of the immensely popular social networking site has a message for you. more »
- Obama to spend $50 million to stop Asian carp
- The Obama administration will spend about $50 million in 2012 to shield the Great Lakes from greedy Asian carp and determine whether the destructive fish have established a foothold in Lakes Michigan and Erie. more »
- Online surveillance bill setup costs estimated at $80M
- It's going to cost at least $80 million to implement the government's lawful access bill to force internet and telecommunications service providers to collect customer information in case police need it for an investigation, CBC News has learned. more »
Bob McDonald's Blog
Canadian science on show in Vancouver Feb. 17, 2012 9:16 AM The largest annual gathering of scientists in the world is happening in Vancouver this week, as delegates from almost 60 countries assemble for the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) meeting. Canadians should be proud of our science, yet most people are unaware of the fine work that goes on from sea to shining sea.
Quirks & Quarks
- February 18: Guitar Hero, or Guitar Zero? Feb. 17, 2012 4:56 PM An NYU professor of psychology describes how he was able to learn to play the guitar in midlife in spite of a limited musical aptitude, and what it tells us about how our brains learn.
Latest Features
- Target set to alter Canadian retail landscape
- EU at stalemate on Canada's oilsands ranking
- Mountie who had sex with superior fights to keep job
- 'Faster than light' measurement blamed on loose cable
- Graham James apologizes to sex-abuse victims
- Fire at Vancouver restaurant goes to 3 alarms
- Qur'an burning riots kill 2 NATO soldiers
- Alleged B.C. rave rape victim seeks witnesses
- Santorum, Romney spar in Republican debate

