Google's 'knowledge' project takes aim at Wikipedia
Last Updated: Friday, December 14, 2007 | 12:29 PM ET
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Google Inc. is testing a new user tool that invites people to write authoritative articles on particular subjects, a move that could put the internet search giant in direct competition with the popular online encyclopedia Wikipedia.
The user-generated knowledge project, dubbed Knol, was made available this week to a small group of users in a trial, said Google's vice-president engineering, Udi Manber, in a Thursday evening post on Google's official blog.
"We believe that many do not share that knowledge today simply because it is not easy enough to do that," wrote Manber. "Our goal is to encourage people who know a particular subject to write an authoritative article about it."
Google said it would provide tools for writing, editing and provide free hosting of the content. Authors would receive credit for their work and could choose to include Google ads on their pages, with authors getting a share of the revenue generated from those ads.
Multiple articles — called knols — on the same subject would be allowed. The articles would be ranked according to a reader voting mechanism.
"Once testing is completed, participation in knols will be completely open, and we cannot expect that all of them will be of high quality," wrote Manber. "Our job in Search Quality will be to rank the knols appropriately when they appear in Google search results."
The project, with its emphasis on individual authors, appears to take aim at Wikipedia, the online encyclopedia that anyone can write, edit or contribute to.
"Books have authors' names right on the cover, news articles have bylines, scientific articles always have authors — but somehow the web evolved without a strong standard to keep authors names highlighted," wrote Manber. "We believe that knowing who wrote what will significantly help users make better use of web content."
Anonymous contributions under scrutiny
Wikipedia has been criticized in the past for allowing anonymous contributions to the site, a policy that some have argued encourages vandalism of entries and discourages experts from writing for the website.
In March 2007, the online encyclopedia suffered a blow to its reputation when it was revealed an editor who had represented himself as a university professor was in fact a 24-year-old from Kentucky with no higher-education credentials.
Knol wouldn't be the first project to try to address this perceived shortcoming.
Earlier this year, Larry Sanger, Wikipedia's former de facto editor in chief, launched a rival online encyclopedia called Citizendium, one that would be written and edited by experts in their fields.
Sanger told CBC News that while Knol would provide authorship, its voting-by-the-masses model was unlikely to attract genuine experts.
"The notion that anyone may write a 'knol,' and be compared and ranked by 'the crowd' — not by expert peers — is apt to attract relatively little notice from experts who are very careful about where they publish," he said in an e-mail Friday.
Knol is unique, though, in that it makes the content part of Google's ad-generated business, as opposed to Wikipedia and Citizendium, which are non-profit organizations.
Sanger said such a policy wouldn't go over well with the "free culture crowd" who have made Wikipedia popular.
But he said that as a business model, it might be successful.
"Other web companies have had reasonably good success making money with such web services, and Google might make a lot of money with theirs."
Knol also marks Google's latest attempt to move into areas on the web traditionally dominated by social media, where content is created, or directed, by users. This fall, the company announced plans to build a software platform for sharing applications across the web in a manner similar to social networking site Facebook.
It also announced plans to test a way to alter search results based on user-generated voting, similar to how news aggregrator websites such as Digg and Reddit rank articles.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Canadian woman continues tweeting her way to the top of Everest
- Sandra Leduc is taking a second run at Mount Everest's summit after a deadly storm forced her back down the mountain and killed four others on Sunday. The Canadian lawyer and government worker is tweeting her progress along the way. more »
- Employment Insurance review boards to be scrapped
- The federal government is scrapping two review boards used by people appealing decisions made about their employment insurance. more »
- Teens share bullying tales in confession booth
- Raw stories about bullying emerged when a video booth was set up inside a Quebec high school. more »
- Canada ending 'Buffalo shuffle' for visas, closing consulate
- The federal government is shutting the Canadian consulate in Buffalo less than two years after costly renovations, while dropping a requirement for visas to be renewed outside the country, CBC News has learned. more »
Latest Technology & Science News Headlines
- SpaceX capsule docked at International Space Station
- The privately bankrolled unmanned SpaceX Dragon capsule has been securely bolted to the Harmony module of the International Space Station. . more »
- Bonavista, N.L., 'coyote' was really wolf, tests confirm
- Wolves have not been seen in Newfoundland since around 1930 and were believed to have been hunted to extinction on the island, but genetic tests have confirmed that an 82-pound animal shot on the Bonavista Peninsula in March was, in fact, a wolf. more »
- Once-rare argus butterfly thriving thanks to climate change
- Global warming is threatening the existence of many species, such as the giant polar bear, but in the case of Britain's brown argus butterfly, it took a species in trouble and made it thrive. more »
- How curry spice helps the immune system kill bacteria
- A spice used in curry dishes helps to prevent infection and now scientists think they've got a lead on how. more »
Bob McDonald's Blog
Government to shut down unique fresh water research area May. 25, 2012 12:31 PM The Experimental Lakes Area research facility in Northern Ontario is being closed down after 44 years of providing invaluable data to scientists in Canada and internationally, a decision that has stunned researchers and environmental groups.
Quirks & Quarks
- May 26: Before the Lights Go Out May. 25, 2012 3:58 PM A new book, "Before the Lights Go Out: Conquering the Energy Crisis Before It Conquers Us", suggests that the unpredictable, unplanned, ad-hoc way our energy use developed in the past will shape our energy future.
Latest Features
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges
- Everest victim's family asks for government help
- Reclaiming the dead on Mt. Everest
- Employment Insurance review boards to be scrapped
- Teens share bullying tales in confession booth
- Canada ending 'Buffalo shuffle' for visas, closing consulate
- Conservatives move again to have robocalls suits tossed
- Workers' EI history to affect claim under new rules
- Double-lung recipient dances on Ellen show

