Judge delays ruling on Facebook lawsuit
Last Updated: Thursday, July 26, 2007 | 8:25 AM ET
The Associated Press
A federal judge on Wednesday delayed ruling on whether to throw out a lawsuit filed against the founder of Facebook.com, saying he needed more information about allegations that Mark Zuckerberg stole the ideas of the creators of a rival social networking website.
Judge Douglas Woodlock, presiding over the hearing at a courthouse in Boston, gave ConnectU founders Cameron Winklevoss, Tyler Winklevoss and Divya Narendra until Aug. 8 to flesh out their allegations against Zuckerberg, which include fraud, copyright infringement and misappropriation of trade secrets.
The lawsuit also names several other founding members of Facebook and asks the court to give control of the company and its assets to ConnectU's founders.
Facebook said in a statement that it was pleased with the outcome of the hearing.
"We continue to disagree with the allegations that Mark Zuckerberg stole any ideas or code to build Facebook," the statement said. "We intend to honour the judge's request not to comment further in the media and will continue to vigorously defend this case in court."
Facebook and ConnectU connect college students and others online. Both allow users to post profiles with pictures, biographies and other personal information and create extended networks of people at their schools or jobs or with similar interests.
ConnectU originally filed suit in September 2004, but it was dismissed on a technicality in March and immediately refiled. The lawsuit claims that in December 2002 the ConnectU founders began to develop a social networking site for the Harvard community called Harvard Connection.
In November 2003, the three asked Zuckerberg to complete software and database work on the site. They repeatedly asked him to finish before they graduated in June 2004, and Zuckerberg assured them he was working hard to complete it, the lawsuit says.
Zuckerberg launched Thefacebook.com in February 2004. ConnectU started its website in May of that year. By beating ConnectU to the market, Facebook gained a huge advantage, the lawsuit claims.
More details needed, judge says
Woodlock repeatedly asked lawyers for ConnectU's founders to give specific details of shareholding distribution and other clauses of a contract they say they had with Zuckerberg while at Harvard, which they could not do Wednesday.
"Zuckerberg agreed to finish the code and become a member of the Connection team helping to get the website launched," ConnectU attorney John Hornick said. In return, Zuckerberg was to become one of four shareholders of the company, he said.
The judge, however, was not satisfied and ordered Hornick to file a fresh plea and specify the facts supporting the allegations.
"Dorm room chit chat does not make a contract," Woodlock said.
The judge also questioned individual liability of other defendants in the case who are accused of using stolen trade secrets and code to help Facebook set up operations.
"Are they being properly sued here?" Woodlock asked in court, adding that the allegations fail to show that the defendants were involved in copyright violation.
Hornick said those individuals were named in the lawsuit because there was no corporate entity in the initial stages of Facebook operations that could assume legal responsibility. He said the social networking site's holding company, Facebook Inc., was formed much later.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Everest victim's husband says family not seeking government help
- The husband of a Toronto woman who died trying to climb Mt. Everest on Saturday says his family is not seeking government help to cover the cost of bringing his wife's body home. more »
- B.C. premier unhappy with disgraced Mountie's transfer
- B.C. Premier Christy Clark says she is not happy with the RCMP decision to transfer a disgraced Alberta Mountie to the West Coast. more »
- Henrique's OT goal sends Devils into Stanley Cup final
- The New Jersey Devils will vie for a potential fourth Stanley Cup in franchise history after defeating the New York Rangers in six games in the Eastern final, courtesy of rookie Adam Henrique's goal early in overtime. more »
- Employment Insurance review boards to be scrapped
- The federal government is scrapping two review boards used by people appealing decisions made about their employment insurance. more »
Latest Technology & Science News Headlines
- Unloading of docked SpaceX capsule to start Saturday
- The privately bankrolled SpaceX Dragon capsule made a historic arrival at the International Space Station on Friday, and astronauts will begin unloading some of the 544 kilograms of food, water, clothing and other supplies its carrying starting Saturday.
more »
- South Africa, Australia to share world's largest telescope
- South Africa and Australia will jointly host the Square Kilometre Array, which promises to be the world's largest telescope, the international consortium in charge of the project said Friday. more »
- Bonavista, N.L., 'coyote' was really wolf, tests confirm
- Wolves have not been seen in Newfoundland since around 1930 and were believed to have been hunted to extinction on the island, but genetic tests have confirmed that an 82-pound animal shot on the Bonavista Peninsula in March was, in fact, a wolf. more »
- Once-rare argus butterfly thriving thanks to climate change
- Global warming is threatening the existence of many species, such as the giant polar bear, but in the case of Britain's brown argus butterfly, it took a species in trouble and made it thrive. more »
- Yahoo scraps digital magazine designed for iPad
- Yahoo has killed Livestand, a tablet magazine, just six months after its debut on the iPad. more »
Bob McDonald's Blog
Government to shut down unique fresh water research area May. 25, 2012 12:31 PM The Experimental Lakes Area research facility in Northern Ontario is being closed down after 44 years of providing invaluable data to scientists in Canada and internationally, a decision that has stunned researchers and environmental groups.
Quirks & Quarks
- May 26: Before the Lights Go Out May. 25, 2012 4:15 PM A new book, "Before the Lights Go Out: Conquering the Energy Crisis Before It Conquers Us", suggests that the unpredictable, unplanned, ad-hoc way our energy use developed in the past will shape our energy future.
Latest Features
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges
- Everest victim's husband says family not seeking government help
- B.C. premier unhappy with disgraced Mountie's transfer
- Third B.C. salmon farm quarantined
- What a Greek euro exit could mean for Canada
- RCMP officer charged in fatal crash
- Canada ending 'Buffalo shuffle' for visas, closing consulate
- Reclaiming the dead on Mt. Everest
- Employment Insurance review boards to be scrapped

