Fake 'expert' scandal forces Wikipedia to review editor policy
Last Updated: Wednesday, March 7, 2007 | 1:16 PM ET
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
External Links
- Wikipedia: Jimmy Wales's response after EssJay dismissal
- arXiv: Assessing the value of cooperation in Wikipedia
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Wikipedia contributors who wish to call attention to their credentials in their role as editors of the online encyclopedia might have to back their claims with evidence after an editor was exposed as a fraud last week.
The online reference website suffered a blow to its reputation after it was revealed an editor who had represented himself as a university professor was in fact a 24-year-old from Kentucky named Ryan Jordan with no higher-education credentials.
Jordan, who went by the name EssJay, told the New Yorker magazine last year he was a tenured professor of religion at a private university with "a PhD in theology and a degree in canon law." But Jordan was exposed after he accepted a job at Wikia, the Internet company run by Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales.
Wales initially backed Jordan but has since asked for his resignation and has removed him from the Wikipedia website.
"I have asked EssJay to resign his positions of trust within the community," Wales wrote on Wikipedia's website. "From the moment this whole thing became known, EssJay has been contrite and apologetic."
Wales said the site would consider requiring editors who wish to represent themselves as experts in a particular field to provide evidence to back it up, but said editors should not be required to have expertise in order to make changes to a particular entry.
"Wikipedia is built on (among other things) twin pillars of trust and tolerance. The integrity of the project depends on the core community being passionate about quality and integrity, so that we can trust each other. The harmony of our work depends on human understanding and forgiveness of errors."
Wikipedia has come under fire for its volunteer editing policy, which allows users to post, edit and delete items, a process critics argue exposes entries to vandalism.
Golfer sues
In the most recent case involving vandalism on the website, pro golfer Fuzzy Zoeller launched a lawsuit against the owner of an internet address last month in an effort to track down the author of what he considered a defamatory paragraph about him on Wikipedia.
The lawsuit said the entry alleged Zoeller abused drugs, alcohol and his family with no evidence to back up the statements. Wikipedia editors have since taken down the derogatory information.
Wikipedia critic Daniel Brandt blasted the site last year when he pointed out 142 passages that had been plagiarized.
But despite the scandals, Wikipedia's popularity continues to grow, and some researchers have suggested the practice of community editing leads to improved accuracy.
A study published on Cornell University's arXiv website last week found that stories edited more frequently were also the most accurate.
The researchers looked at 1,211 featured articles — those deemed by users to be particularly useful — and found on average they had more edits and contributors than entries deemed less accurate or thorough on the site.
"Wikipedia article quality continues to increase, on average, as the number of collaborators and the number of edits increases," said the report by Dennis Wilkinson and Bernardo Huberman from the Hewlett Packard Information Dynamics Laboratory in Palo Alto, Calif.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Immigrants the proudest Canadians, poll suggests

- Most Canadians feel immigrants are just as likely to be good Canadian citizens as people who were born here and don't object to them keeping their original citizenship, according to a recent Environics survey. more »
- NDP MPs urged to scrap gun registry in final vote
- Public Safety Minister Vic Toews urges opposition MPs to break party ranks and side with the government during tonight's vote on scrapping the long-gun registry. more »
- Honduras prison fire kills hundreds
- Trapped inmates screamed from their cells as a fire swept through a Honduran prison, killing at least 300 inmates in one of the world's deadliest fires in decades, authorities said Wednesday. more »
- Iran loads nuclear fuel into reactor
- Iran begins loading domestically made nuclear fuel rods into its Tehran research reactor, a defiant move in response to toughening Western sanctions over its controversial nuclear program. more »
Latest Technology & Science News Headlines
- Online privacy erosion dismays critics
- Government and law enforcement access to people's electronic communications is the norm in dictatorships around the world, but the same intrusion appears to be creeping into North America, say opponents of a new online surveillance bill tabled in the House Tuesday. more »
- Venus slowdown puzzles planetary scientists
- Scientists have detected a sudden and dramatic slowdown in the rotation of Earth's sister planet Venus. more »
- Electric cars can handle Canadian winter
- New data obtained by CBC News suggests the range of electric cars is significantly impaired by extreme cold, but not enough to affect the commuting habits of most Canadians. more »
- Online surveillance bill targets child porn: Toews
- A bill that would give police and intelligence agencies new powers to access Canadians' electronic communications is needed to protect against child pornography, says Public Safety Minister Vic Toews. more »
- McGuinty backs Wi-Fi in schools
- Premier Dalton McGuinty is shrugging off concerns raised by an Ontario teachers' union about Wi-Fi in public schools. more »
Bob McDonald's Blog
Glacier Discovery Walk: Will the visitor centre enhance the view? Feb. 14, 2012 9:22 AM Environment minister Peter Kent has announced the construction of a new Glacier Discovery Walk and visitor centre on the Icefields Parkway in Jasper National Park. It raises the issue of how to balance commercial development in our National Parks against the preservation of the last refuges of wilderness.
Quirks & Quarks
- February 18: Guitar Hero, or Guitar Zero? Feb. 15, 2012 10:53 AM An NYU professor of psychology describes how he was able to learn to play the guitar in midlife in spite of a limited musical aptitude, and what it tells us about how our brains learn.
Latest Features
- Barefoot Newfoundland girl survives icy ordeal
- Immigrants the proudest Canadians, poll suggests
- Legalize pot, say former B.C. attorneys general
- Online privacy erosion dismays critics
- Russians in abusive plane tirade to be sentenced
- Botox injected by unlicensed practitioners
- Honduras prison fire kills hundreds
- Trudeau says sovereignty less of a bogeyman now
- Toronto NBA fans experience 'Lin-sanity'

