Sliced raw meat may have played key role in human evolution

A study in which people chewed on pieces of raw goat meat and veggies smashed with rocks sheds light on how changes in our ancestors' diets helped us evolve into who were are today.

Volunteers chew raw goat meat and pounded veggies for science

Scientists said on Wednesday the advent of meat-eating combined with the use of simple stone tools to make food easier to consume meant that members of the human lineage about 2.5 million years ago all of a sudden had less need for chewing. (Ahmed Jadallah/Reuters)

A study in which people chewed on pieces of raw goat meat and vegetables smacked with a rock is shedding light on how changes long ago in the way our ancestors dined paved the way for physiological advances that helped make us who were are today.

Scientists said on Wednesday the advent of meat-eating combined with the use of simple stone tools to make food easier to consume meant that members of the human lineage about 2.5 million years ago all of a sudden had less need for chewing.

I can tell you that eating raw goat is not pleasant. It's a little on the gross side.- David Lieberman

Without needing to spend much of the day chewing food as chimpanzees do, our ancestors underwent significant evolutionary changes, acquiring smaller teeth, jaws and chewing muscles while losing the snout possessed by their predecessors.

"Shortening the snout might have been beneficial for producing articulate speech, for having a more balanced head, 
especially useful when running, or perhaps for other reasons," Harvard University evolutionary anthropologist Daniel Lieberman said.

The changes also may have enabled the development of larger brains in early human species like Homo erectus compared to earlier members of the human lineage like Australopithecus, who combined ape-like and human-like traits.

Meat compared to plants added a calorically dense food to the diet of these early humans as their brains and bodies got bigger.

Before cooking existed

The researchers conducted experiments measuring how much chewing effort was expended in eating the type of diet our ancestors are thought to have had. Cooking was not commonplace until roughly 500,000 years ago.

Study volunteers chewed on tough raw goat meat, selected to mimic wild game, and three root vegetables: beets, carrots and yams. Electrodes were placed on their faces to measure chewing activity.

Harvard evolutionary anthropologist Katherine Zink, the study's lead author, said the amount of chewing declined 
markedly when the food was processed with the type of basic stone tools used at the time: slicing the meat into smaller pieces and pounding the vegetables six times.

The number of chews dropped by 17 per cent and the chewing force by 20 per cent while the volunteers were able to swallow meat bits that were about 41 per cent smaller and thus more digestible.

Lieberman served as a test subject before the volunteers stepped in.

"I can tell you that eating raw goat is not pleasant. It's a little on the gross side," Lieberman said. "It's really 
amazingly like chewing gum." 

Lieberman said unlike carnivores, whose teeth are tailor-made for slicing meat, human teeth are "really designed 
like mortars and pestles, for crushing."
 
The research was published in the journal Nature

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.