The expanding world of online scams
We're not just victims, we're unwilling partners
Last Updated: Tuesday, December 15, 2009 | 1:51 PM ET
By Charlene Sadler CBC News
Related
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Special report
Analysis
- Russell D. Storring: 10 years of change in the Canadian Armed Forces
- Neil Macdonald: Middle East peace - hardened hearts and a decade lost
The decade online
- Networking pioneer Vint Cerf: we've only scratched internet's surface
- Profile: AskMen.com - a decade of manliness
- The expanding world of online scams
- Retail online: What's next in e-commerce
- Hardware: Trendy technology of the past decade
- Health: The emergence of the e-patient
Pop culture
- 10 pop culture trends that defined the decade
- Faces of the 2000s: Looking back at the biggest entertainers of the decade
- QUIZ: Test your knowledge of pop culture in the 2000s
Entertainment
- The 10 most important films of the decade
- Video games that shaped the decade
- The 10 most important TV series of the 2000s
- The 10 defining singles and albums of this decade
Arts
- 10 of the most significant visual artists of the decade
- The biggest publishing phenomena of the last 10 years
- Theatre, dance and classical music from the decade
- Style: Designers adapt to harder times
Photo galleries
Internet scams have have gone global in the past decade as criminal organizations get involved. (iStockphoto)David Fewer was describing how internet scams have changed — from the mischievous tricks pulled by amateurs 10 years ago to the potentially dangerous cons run by organized crime today.
Fewer, an expert in internet scams, was about to talk about phishing as a seminal development in scamming when he was interrupted by an email from Scotiabank. The email was a scam — of the phishing variety.
Someone from "some dark corner of the world" was trying to get Fewer's banking information at the very moment he was being interviewed about how scammers try to get our banking information.
"And I've got pretty good security on my computer," said Fewer, director of the Canadian Internet Policy and Public Interest Clinic, run by the law faculty at the University of Ottawa.
This Scotiabank phishing scam arrived on David Fewer's computer as he was being interviewed about online scams. (CBC)A few things about the email triggered what Fewer calls his spidey sense: the URL used scotiabank-canada and he was tweaked by the dash and the fact Canada was named.
"There's a bunch of hints," he said.
A big hint: The real Scotiabank would never send an internet notice to clients. No bank would.
Hundreds of thousands of complaints
To say internet scamming has grown in the last 10 years is an understatement. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission, which goes after bad business practices, received 25,000 complaints about internet scams in 2000. Last year, it received 200,000.
The Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre, better known as Phonebusters, receives 140,000 complaints by phone each year, and about 36,000 by email, said Cpl. Louis Robertson,
'The dumb criminal will take a gun and steal $50 from a store. The smart criminal sets up a website. Guess who's going to be spending his winter on a sunny island?'— Cpl. Louis Robertson
the centre's head of criminal intelligence. He calculates that Canadian consumers lose about $2 billion a year to mass-market and identification fraud.
"The dumb criminal will take a gun and steal $50 from a store," Robertson said. "The smart criminal sets up a website. Guess who's going to be spending his winter on a sunny island? I'm being sarcastic but … ."
The internet is filled with people venting about being scammed. Many complaints start with "I stupidly signed up for," or "I stupidly fell for," or "I'm usually quite internet savvy, but . …"
And these are just the people who realize they've been scammed. Many people don't. They may have clicked, for instance, on an email that installed spyware or malware on their hard drive, turning their computer into a "bot'" that helps send out spam to other computers.
"We're not just victims, we're unwilling partners," Fewer said. "Organized crime has gotten involved, so scams are more systematic, more persistent, more creative."
Scammers get creative
Dan Salsburg of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission would agree. In earlier days, there wasn't a lot of imagination in a typical scam.
"It was old wine in new bottles," said Salsburg, assistant director of the marketing practices division in the bureau of protection. "Now they've shown remarkable creativity.
"The bottom line is, bad guys want to take your money. And if not your money, somebody else's."
Some bad guys will persuade you to pay for a security patch when you can do it for free by changing your default settings, Salsburg says. That's scareware.
Bad guys will install nasty programs on your computer so that you host pop-ups that allow them to collect fees from advertisers who only count clicks. That's adware.
Bad guys register URLs with misspelled names of movie stars to attract you to their sites. And you can never leave, as you become ensnared in pop-ups that direct you to other sites. That's mousetrapping, although it's largely been beaten.
Pagejacking, too, where you click on one website URL and find yourself at another, has been eliminated, thanks to pop-up blockers and improved search engines.
But this is the internet. As one scam is eliminated, another evolves. Any scam can be done more efficiently on the internet, Robertson said.
"Instead of phoning one (potential victim), you hit a button and reach 1,000 people — 100 that will talk to you and 10 that you'll scam."
A decade of internet scams started with worms and viruses that tried to get access to your financial and personal information without you knowing.
In 2003, the federal Competition Bureau, which is involved in Canada's fight against cyber fraud, registered its first complaints.
Money sent to fake school
Around 2005, phishing arrived, with scammers trying to trick people into releasing their financial and private information through emails that mimicked official websites.
Phishing is a common scam these days. (iStockphoto)About 18 months ago, scammers hijacked the website of the Université de Sherbrooke, in Sherbrooke, Que. It was a small community of targets: 5,000 to 6,000 students registering and paying for courses online. A duplicate website was created, with the only difference being the name: Université a Sherbrooke instead of de Sherbrooke.
Soon, complaints started coming in from students who'd been duped into sending money to, well, not to the Université de Sherbrooke. But who did they send their money to?
Phonebusters tried to find out. The centre followed the IP address, which landed in Switzerland, then bounced into Russia. More information was sought, unsuccessfully, from Swiss authorities, Robertson said. The case was never solved.
"You're talking about a very small community," Robertson said of the targets. "Did the (scammers) have a contact in town? Did they have someone who knew someone? It just shows you how huge the problem is. The scammers don't have borders and we're still functioning on borders and jurisdiction. We're 15 to 20 years behind the ball."
Many scams live in a grey zone between legitimate and fraudulent, selling tooth-whitening products, Acai berry weight-loss schemes, auction internet packages and access to government bailout money, both Canadian and American.
No end to bills
In a twist on the classic bait-and-switch scam, people who click on ads don't get what they thought they bought but are billed monthly at a much higher rate and find there's no way to cancel.
"Some of these scams are out-and-out fraud — you don't get anything — but some of them look like fairly legitimate business," said Ian Nielsen-Jones, assistant deputy commissioner at the Competition Bureau in Ontario.
There is a belief that only greedy, vulnerable or lazy consumers get scammed, but this is no longer true. Fraudulent cheques, fake websites and misleading offers often bear out research and double-checks, he said.
"We interviewed tonnes of victims and they aren't the dullards of the world," Nielsen-Jones said.
David Fewer would like to see more attention paid to online scams in Canada. Many internet scams still fly below the radar of enforcement agencies, which tend to focus efforts on the bricks-and-mortar scams: bad mechanics, deceptive contractors and the like.
Robertson holds out his own unit as an example of the lopsided fight. More than half of scams now involve the internet. But what does he have in his armoury? Six analysts. None of them experts in cyber fraud.
"If we don't have enough analysts," Robertson said. "There's going to be other people targeted, and it's not just seniors, it's everybody."
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Teen struck by lightning in Ottawa dies
- The victim of a Friday lightning strike during a storm in east Ottawa has died, CBC News has learned. more »
- Montreal protesters march in peaceful defiance
- The clanging of pots and pans sounded throughout Montreal's downtown core Saturday night and into early Sunday morning, as thousands of protesters marched on in peaceful — but loud — defiance of Bill 78. more »
- Syrian children massacred by the dozens, UN says
- More than 90 people have been killed by regime forces in a district of central Syria, with the head of the UN team in the country confirming at least 32 children and 60 adults were killed in an artillery attack. more »
- Missing Winnipeg children found in Mexico
- Two Winnipeg children reported missing and possibly in Mexico have been found alive, according to unofficial reports from an agency that works to find missing people. more »
- Teen struck by lightning in Ottawa dies
- Missing Winnipeg children found in Mexico
- Quebec tornadoes cause millions in damage
- Everest team unable to bring down Toronto woman's body
- Pope's butler arrested in Vatican leaks scandal
- Woman's remains found in hockey bag on Cape Breton river
- Syrian children massacred by the dozens, UN says
- WWE apologizes to Brazil over Canadian's flag stomp
- What a Greek euro exit could mean for Canada
