Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

Don Murray

Balfour's legacy: Creating Israel from empire's needs

November 2, 2007

It has long been a land divided, a small patch of Earth where Israelis and Palestinians share little except, as a famous Irish poet said of his own land, "great hatred and little room."

In the beginning, at least at the beginning of the 20th century, it was a backwater, a forgotten corner of empire. The empire was Turkish, the Ottoman Empire. The land was Palestine and there were almost no Jews.

But 90 years ago, on Nov. 2, 1917, something happened that would create a conflict that would run like a tributary of blood through the century.

David Lloyd George, the Welsh nationalist was British prime minister from 1916 to 1922 and was a key figure at the Paris Peace Conference in 1919. (Hulton Archive/Getty Images)

In London, a letter was written. It was short. Its author was the British foreign secretary, Lord Arthur Balfour. Its recipient was Lord Rothschild, a prominent British Jew. The content was explosive.

The British government, it said, "view with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object."

At that time, Jews were no more than eight per cent of the population of Palestine. Zionists were overjoyed. The small movement launched in its modern form by Theodor Herzl had only taken root 20 years earlier.

Now a great imperial power was backing its goal.

Why then?

Why did Britain make such a promise? The answer, perhaps not surprisingly, was war and empire.

The First World War was grinding its way through millions of men. For the British prime minister of the day, David Lloyd George, the declaration was a desperate throw of the dice to try to keep Russia engaged on the side of Britain.and France.

The Russian Revolution had just taken place and the Bolsheviks in power were calling for the country to pull out of the fighting. Even more important, Lloyd George was desperate for the United States to plunge into the conflict with enthusiasm, men, money and machines.

"The British and French were bleeding to death on the Western Front," observes British historian David Cesarani, who specializes in modern Jewish history.

"Lloyd George thought that maybe, if he could swing Jewish opinion in Russia behind the Allies, that might keep Russia in the war. And if he could win over Jewish opinion in America, maybe that would push America into the war on the side of the Allies.

"And what would be the key to winning Jewish opinion? The promise to set up a Jewish national home in Palestine. That was the crucial trigger for the Balfour declaration."

The road from 1919

The Balfour declaration was, as Lloyd George wrote later, a military decision that wildly overestimated the influence of the Jews in both Russia and the U.S. when it came to the war.

But empire still played a role in it going forward. The Ottomans were fighting on the side of the Germans in the First World War. Defeated, these Turkish territories in the Middle East would be ripe for plucking. And the British wanted to box out the French.

Thus the play for Palestine as a homeland for Jews, but to be administered by the British.

At the Paris Peace Conference in 1919, Britain was duly given a mandate to rule Palestine. The World Zionist Organization came to the conference and presented a map of what it saw as the future Jewish homeland. It looked remarkably like a map of modern Israel that included Gaza and the West Bank.

With the end of the First World War, however, British leaders began to regret their commitment to a Jewish homeland. There were fewer than 60,000 Jews in Palestine, facing more than 500,000 Arabs.

"The British government found that its army was policing a potential Jewish national home with a tiny number of Jews faced by a very large number of angry Arabs," Cesarani says. "This was a nightmare."

Balfour's legacy

Lord Arthur Balfour, a Scottish parliamentarian was Britain's prime minister from 1902-1905 and came out of retirement to be Lloyd George's foreign secretary in 1916. (Getty Images)

The Arabs in Palestine were not even mentioned by name in the Balfour declaration. They were simply referred to as non-Jewish peoples.

After the war, the British colonial secretary saw the commitment to a Jewish homeland as an unnecessary burden on the empire. He tried to appease the Arabs by hiving off a territory from Palestine known today as Jordan and giving it to the Hashemite dynasty. The colonial secretary was Winston Churchill.

But appeasement didn't work. There were periodic explosions of violence: In 1920, 1921 and again in 1929. Then came an Arab uprising, which began in 1935.

Jews, galvanized by the Balfour declaration and, more importantly, by the lash of Hitler from 1933 on, continued to pour in. By the mid 1930s there were almost 400,000 Jews in Palestine, 30 per cent of the population. The Arabs then feared that they would be swamped within a few decades.

At that point, the British did what governments do. They set up another commission, the third since Balfour, under Lord Peel.

In 1937, it concluded there were "irreconcilable national aspirations" and, for the first time, recommended the partition of Palestine into Jewish and Arab-controlled entities.

In the brief span of 20 years, groping for policies to win a war and consolidate an empire, Britain had outlined the future Middle East — a Jewish homeland in a territory divided.

According to Cesarani, the Peel partition idea "was a very far-sighted proposal."

After a while, he says, "the British government ditched it because it was afraid of a very powerful Arab backlash. The emerging Arab states would not tolerate even a mini-Jewish state in Palestine or the Palestinian territories.

"Of course, in the end partition was what the UN decided and what the Jews agreed to."

In the wake of the Second World War, Britain began to shed its empire. It abandoned its mandate in Palestine in 1948. The Jews immediately proclaimed the state of Israel and fought for and won its survival.

Now another imperial power, based in Washington, oversees the region and its troubles.

It periodically sends out emissaries, including its secretary of state, with gifts and threats. It talks of a yet another conference to find diplomatic solutions. The Israeli and Palestinian leaders meet but resolve nothing.

Yet Balfour, Cesarani says, has left a powerful history.

"It gave the Jews a place in the world. And you could say that, as well as the troublesome legacy of the Balfour declaration, that is a pretty miraculous legacy."

The Jewish homeland is now a state. Partition is now a fact on the ground even if there is not yet a second state for the Palestinians. The legacy of Balfour is both miraculous and bloody and bitter.

Go to the Top

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

Biography

During his 30 years at CBC, Don Murray has filed hundreds of reports in French and English from China, Europe, the Middle East and the Soviet Union. He is currently based in London. He wrote A Democracy of Despots, documenting the collapse and rebirth of Russia. From Berlin, he reported the Bosnia peace agreement talks and, based in London, the death of Diana and Northern Ireland peace talks. He authored Family Wars for the International Journal, paralleling Northern Ireland and Bosnia. He has covered wars in Kosovo, Afghanistan and Iraq.

» Read full bio

More From
DON MURRAY »
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

new Markets gain after Greece approves austerity plan
World stock markets rise after Greece's parliament approves a new set of austerity measures that were required by international lenders in exchange for an emergency bailout.
Houston autopsy results withheld by police video
Whitney Houston was found in a hotel bathtub but it'll take weeks to determine precisely how she died, a Los Angeles coroner's official says.
Arab League wants UN peacekeepers in Syria
The Arab League has called for the UN Security Council to create a joint peacekeeping force for Syria and urged Arab states to sever all diplomatic contact with President Bashar Assad's regime.
more »

Canada »

Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters video
A small Quebec town is in mourning Sunday after a Quebec man was charged with killing his nieces and his mother, who were found dead in their family home.
new Hit and run victim's family fears accused will walk
The family of a young mother killed in a hit and run is outraged that the case against the alleged driver is among thousands in B.C. at risk of being thrown out because of a huge court backlog.
Doors blocked in fatal Manitoba trailer blaze
Four men who died in a residential trailer fire in Selkirk, Man., may not have been able to escape because both of the home's exits were blocked, says a local fire official.
more »

Politics »

NDP leadership hopefuls face off in Quebec City video
Federal NDP leadership candidates argued over Canada's global standing, climate change and language during a French-only debate in Quebec City on Sunday.
Tibet PM sees human-rights 'tragedy' unfolding
In an exclusive interview Saturday on CBC Radio's The House, the prime minister of the Tibetan government-in-exile, Lobsang Sangay, sounded the alarm on the "tragedy" unfolding in Tibet and called on Canada to take action.
Attawapiskat receives first modular home
The first of 22 modular homes promised by the federal government to Attawapiskat has arrived to the remote northern Ontario First Nations community, the Aboriginal Affairs minister's office has confirmed.
more »

Health »

Chronic fatigue may be reversed with exercise
Taking it easy is not the best treatment for chronic fatigue syndrome, rather exercise and behaviour therapy are, a large study finds.
AT&T buys T-Mobile USA for $39B US
AT&T Inc. said Sunday it will buy T-Mobile USA from Deutsche Telekom AG in a cash-and-stock deal valued at $39 billion US, becoming the largest cellphone company in the U.S.
Milky Way home to 50 billion planets: NASA
Scientists have compiled the first cosmic census of planets in our galaxy: at least 50 billion planets are estimated to call the Milky Way home.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Adele wins best album, best record Grammys
Adele capped off a "life-changing" year by winning six Grammys Sunday night, including record of the year and album of the year for 21
Britain's BAFTAs honours The Artist
Silent movie The Artist dominated the British Academy Film awards, the U.K. equivalent of the Oscars, winning seven awards, including best picture.
Houston autopsy results withheld by police video
Whitney Houston was found in a hotel bathtub but it'll take weeks to determine precisely how she died, a Los Angeles coroner's official says.
more »

Technology & Science »

NASA to scale back Mars exploration
Scientists say NASA is about to propose major cuts in its exploration of other planets, especially Mars, with the space agency's former science chief calling the plan irrational.
Ancient Antarctic lake may harbour microbial life
If scientists find microbes in a frigid lake 3.2 kilometres beneath the thick ice of Antarctica, it will illustrate once again that somehow life finds a way to survive in the strangest and harshest places, and it will offer hope that life exists beyond Earth.
B.C. killer whale habitat protection ruled a legal duty
The federal minister of fisheries has no discretion when it comes to protecting the critical habitat of B.C.'s southern resident killer whales, the Federal Court of Appeal has ruled.
more »

Money »

new Markets gain after Greece approves austerity plan
World stock markets rise after Greece's parliament approves a new set of austerity measures that were required by international lenders in exchange for an emergency bailout.
Greece passes new austerity deal amid rioting video
Greek lawmakers have approved harsh new austerity measures demanded by bailout creditors to save the debt-crippled nation from bankruptcy, after riots in Athens and other cities left stores looted and burned and more than 120 people hurt.
Air Canada reaches tentative deal with dispatchers
Air Canada has reached a tentative collective agreement with the Canadian Airline Dispatchers Association, representing the airline's 74 flight dispatchers.
more »

Consumer Life »

Honda recalls Fit subcompacts
Honda Canada says it will recall 14,640 of its 2009 and 2010 Fit subcompact cars to replace lost motion springs.
U.S. travel fee proposal criticized by Harper
Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he doesn't think much of a new border tax that's being proposed by the United States, calling it a cash grab designed to help a budget crisis.
Bell class action suit approved by Que. court
A Quebec Superior Court judge has authorized a class action lawsuit to go ahead against Bell Mobility.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Virtue, Moir outduel Davis, White to win Four Continents video
For the first time in nearly two years, Canada's Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir beat the American team of Meryl Davis and Charlie White in ice dancing. The reigning Olympic champions won gold at the Four Continents Championships on Sunday in Colorado after outduelling Davis and White in the free skate.
Red Wings tie NHL record with 20th straight home win video
The Detroit Red Wings equalled an NHL record with their 20th straight win at home, beating the Philadelphia Flyers 4-3 Sunday night on the strength of Johan Franzen's tiebreaking goal early in the third period.
blog PEI hockey players are proud and inspire each other
Gerard Gallant had Errol Thompson. Brad Richards had Gallant. Mark Flood and Adam McQuaid had Richards. Somewhere down the line there will be other hockey players from Prince Edward Island who will be inspired by McQuaid or Flood, writes Tim Wharnsby.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »