Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

Don Murray

'Uneasy lies the head that wears a crown'

October 4, 2007

Shakespeare had a term for it: "polished perturbation." He was referring to the problem of royal succession.

It continues to perturb modern leaders. Monarchies, with notable exceptions, have become symbolic satrapies; real power now lies with politicians. But the problem remains the same: how to keep it in the family?

Fathers and sons

Curiously, those leaders who come to office espousing ideologies of equality based on merit have been the most brazen nepotists. North Korea's Communist leader Kim Il-sung insisted on being worshipped like a king and on his death the crown was handed to his son, Kim Jong-il.

In the same way ex-communist Heydar Aliyev (he was a member of Mikhail Gorbachev's politburo) simply carried on as president of Azerbaijan when it emerged from the rubble of the Soviet Union. A dozen years later, on his deathbed, he appointed his son as the candidate of the ruling party for president. Ilham Aliyev duly won and carries on the family tradition.

The Baath party began life as a secular, socialist party in Syria. Yet when president Hafez al-Assad died, after 30 brutal years in power, the presidency passed to his son Bashir. Bashir set out to be an eye doctor. In 2000 he became a modern-day monarch.

Down Argentine way

Then there is the Argentine way: husband-to-wife succession.

Juan Peron, the populist demagogue who had twice been the country's president before being forced into exile, returned to his country in 1973 and ran for president again with his third wife, Isabel, as his running mate. Peron dropped dead a year later. Isabel succeeded him.

The story doesn't end happily. She was unpopular and toppled in a military coup two years later. She remained under house arrest and then was forced into exile. In 2006 she was arrested again, this time in Spain, and charged in relation with forced disappearances during her presidency. Once again she's under house arrest, awaiting extradition to Argentina.

Argentina is doing it again. The president, Nestor Kirchner, a Peronist himself, didn't have to step aside; he chose to after just one term, despite high approval ratings. But he manoeuvred to ensure that his wife Cristina, an Argentine senator, would get the nomination. She is the odds-on favourite to win the presidential election on Oct. 28.

All in the family

In two of Asia's biggest nations the modern succession pattern has been father-to-daughter. Consider:

  • India: Jawarhwal Nehru to daughter Indira Gandhi 19 months after his death (and then, when she was assassinated, to Indira's son Rajiv - all were prime ministers of India. Now Rajiv's widow, Sonia, controls the ruling Congress Party but has declined to become prime minister.)
  • Pakistan: Zulfikar Ali Bhutto to Benazir Bhutto (she became the leader of the Pakistan People's Party after he was deposed as prime minister and then hanged. She was prime minister twice and is on the point of returning to Pakistan after years in exile to try for the job again.)
  • Sri Lanka: truly a family compact. Father SWRD Bandaranaike was prime minister until his assassination in 1959. His wife Sirimavo took his place. For good measure Sirimavo's daughter Anura became the country's prime minister and then president in 1994 then naming her mother to succeed her as prime minister.
The Americans, with their penchant for firsts, are attempting the political equivalent of Olympic synchronized swimming, a sort of political double helix manoeuvre – father-to-son (the Bushes), interwoven with husband-to-wife (the Clintons), and all this seamlessly, in just 20 years.

Putin's 'polished perturbation'

Then there is Russia. Successions there have long been fraught. Like monarchs, five of the seven leaders of the Soviet Union died in their beds. Only one left an obvious successor.

Vladimir Lenin, the founder of the bloody Soviet state, wrote a letter while he was dying warning his lieutenants about Josef Stalin. Stalin pocketed the letter, organized the state funeral for Lenin, and then took over the state. When Stalin died, his political lieutenants were so scared of his fellow Georgian and potential successor, secret police chief Lavrenti Beria, that they pulled pistols from their pockets at a politburo meeting, arrested Beria, rolled him in rug, smuggled him out of the Kremlin on the floor of a limousine, and had him shot a few months later.

Vladimir Putin has pondered these problems. The Russian president is barred by the constitution drawn up by his predecessor, Boris Yeltsin, from holding the presidency for more than two successive terms. Who will replace him? It has become a long-running political parlour game in Moscow, with Putin's studied silence increasing the suspense.

The Russian resolution

Now he has unveiled his solution: he will succeed himself. Not as president, that would be too easy. His party controls two-thirds of the seats in the Russian Duma; he could have easily changed the constitution. Many of his advisers thought he would do it, pleaded with him to do it.

Instead the president will run for parliament even while remaining president. He has announced he will head the list of United Russia, the party he created, in the parliamentary elections in December. Under the country's system of proportional representation, that assures him a key position in the lower house, the Duma. Then he plans to become prime minister.

"Heading the government is a realistic idea," Putin told his followers at the party congress. The only proviso was that a "decent, competent and effective person with whom I could work" would be elected as president in spring 2008.

Putin had already laid the groundwork by selecting a decent, competent, faceless and aging bureaucrat as his interim prime minister a couple of weeks earlier. This gentleman, Viktor Zubkov, is 66 but within days was talking of running for president himself. It seemed a little peculiar until Putin's move to make himself prime minister after stepping down as president. Power would simply drain from one office to another in the Kremlin.

Stalin as role model

Putin, the ex-KGB agent, is a careful student. One of his role models is Stalin. The Kremlin has even helped edit a new guide for Russian high school history teachers. In it they're instructed to teach that Stalin was an "effective" leader whose murderous purges in the 1930s, which killed millions, were a stimulus to Soviet elites and helped kick-start the country's industrialization.

Putin will have noted that Stalin never held high government office, either that of president or prime minister. His power resided in his position as general secretary and his control of the Communist party apparatus.

Putin has updated that approach, placing ex-KGB officers in key positions in the Kremlin, the ministries and the provinces. He is at the centre of that web of power, whether as president or eventually as prime minister.

The succession problem is solved. And four years on, he may move back into the president's office.

"Uneasy lies the head that wears a crown." Shakespeare also wrote that. It may apply to others; it doesn't appear to apply to Vladimir Putin.

Go to the Top

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

Biography

During his 30 years at CBC, Don Murray has filed hundreds of reports in French and English from China, Europe, the Middle East and the Soviet Union. He is currently based in London. He wrote A Democracy of Despots, documenting the collapse and rebirth of Russia. From Berlin, he reported the Bosnia peace agreement talks and, based in London, the death of Diana and Northern Ireland peace talks. He authored Family Wars for the International Journal, paralleling Northern Ireland and Bosnia. He has covered wars in Kosovo, Afghanistan and Iraq.

» Read full bio

More From
DON MURRAY »
[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]
Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

London attack victim's widow speaks of 'our future together' video
The family of the young British soldier who was killed in a brutal daytime slaying spoke at a press conference on Friday, including his widow who talked about their plans for the future.
Russia says Assad regime willing to attend Syria peace talks
The Syrian government has agreed "in principle" to attend a conference proposed by Russia and the United States on ending the country's civil war, Russia's Foreign Ministry say. However, Damascus has not issued a definitive statement on the talks.
Washington police blame bridge collapse on Alberta trucker video audio
Washington State police say an Alberta trucker was responsible for hitting a steel beam precipitating a bridge collapse on one of the busiest routes in the American northwest.
more »

Canada »

Toronto Mayor Rob Ford denies using crack cocaine video
The mayor of Canada's largest city told a packed news conference that he doesn't use crack cocaine and isn't a crack addict.
Man accused of killing child in patio crash granted bail
Emotions ran high in a packed Edmonton courthouse Friday as Richard Suter, accused of causing a crash into a restaurant patio that killed a young boy, was granted bail.
Royal Bank pledges not to outsource jobs for cash savings
Royal Bank has promised it will never outsource a Canadian job to a foreign worker solely to save money.
more »

Politics »

Group calls for probe of Tory database used in election robocalls video
The Council of Canadians is calling on the Conservative Party to make a list of everyone who had access to its electoral database during the last federal election and turn the information over to the RCMP and the commissioner of elections. "Anything less at this point would be a coverup," the council said in a press release Friday.
Lobbying saved Montreal's UN aviation agency, Paradis says video
Qatar's decision to drop its bid to bring the International Civil Aviation Organization's headquarters to Doha from Montreal was the result of hard work and intense lobbying on the part of three levels of government, federal Industry Minister Christian Paradis said Friday.
analysis Greg Weston: Senate scandal may be Harper's worst hour
The widening Senate scandal that the prime minister flippantly tried to dismiss as a 'distraction' just days ago has instead become arguably Stephen Harper's worst hour.
more »

Health »

Chronic fatigue may be reversed with exercise
Taking it easy is not the best treatment for chronic fatigue syndrome, rather exercise and behaviour therapy are, a large study finds.
AT&T buys T-Mobile USA for $39B US
AT&T Inc. said Sunday it will buy T-Mobile USA from Deutsche Telekom AG in a cash-and-stock deal valued at $39 billion US, becoming the largest cellphone company in the U.S.
Milky Way home to 50 billion planets: NASA
Scientists have compiled the first cosmic census of planets in our galaxy: at least 50 billion planets are estimated to call the Milky Way home.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Rolling Stones to rock with Mississauga choir video
The Rolling Stones take to the stage in Toronto Saturday night, accompanied by a Mississauga high school choir, for the first of three hotly anticipated Canadian concerts.
Robert Bateman Centre to promote more than artist's work audio
Celebrated Canadian nature artist Robert Bateman is opening a new gallery in Victoria this weekend, but the artist says the aim is to do much more than showcase his work.
FILM REVIEW: The Hangover Part 3
In a final outing with the wolf pack, the joke's on us, says Eli Glasner. The Hangover Part 3 is a strangely serious and laugh-free sequel in the popular, offensive and raunchy series.
more »

Technology & Science »

Venus, Jupiter and Mercury to perform Dance of the Planets
During sunset on Saturday, three planets will form a bright cluster in the western sky known as the Dance of the Planets.
3D printers give rise to 'desktop manufacturing'
Customizable objects from plastic dollhouse furniture to medical prosthetics can now be designed and printed out by almost anyone at the press of a button, and is going to lead to an 'explosion of new stuff,' predicts author Chris Anderson.
Google Street View captures Galapagos Islands
Few have explored the remote volcanic islands of the Galapagos archipelago, an otherworldly landscape inhabited by the world's largest tortoises and other fantastical creatures that inspired Charles Darwin's theory of evolution.
more »

Money »

Royal Bank pledges not to outsource jobs for cash savings
Royal Bank has promised it will never outsource a Canadian job to a foreign worker solely to save money.
Canada threatens retaliation over U.S. meat-labelling rules
The federal government is threatening "retaliatory measures" against the United States in a dispute over meat-labelling rules that Ottawa and the World Trade Organization consider discriminatory.
Canada ranks 3rd last in paid vacations
Canada ranks third last among economically advanced countries in the amount of paid vacation time it guarantees its workers, a new U.S. study indicates.
more »

Consumer Life »

Honda recalls Fit subcompacts
Honda Canada says it will recall 14,640 of its 2009 and 2010 Fit subcompact cars to replace lost motion springs.
U.S. travel fee proposal criticized by Harper
Prime Minister Stephen Harper says he doesn't think much of a new border tax that's being proposed by the United States, calling it a cash grab designed to help a budget crisis.
Bell class action suit approved by Que. court
A Quebec Superior Court judge has authorized a class action lawsuit to go ahead against Bell Mobility.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

live Watch & Chat: Senators at Penguins, Game 5
Watch live and interact as the Ottawa Senators and the Pittsburgh Penguins clash in Game 5 of their Eastern Conference semifinal (CBC, CBCSports.ca, live now).
live TELUS Break Away Cam: Pick the player you want to see video
The TELUS Break Away Cam follows the player or camera angle you want to watch during featured Hockey Night in Canada games. Check out tonight's Senators-Penguins game on 2nd Screen and vote for your favourite player.
video Did You See That? Brenden Morrow's controversial goal
The Penguins will take it, but the Ottawa Senators were up in arms after a controversial goal by Brenden Morrow opened the scoring on Friday night.
more »

Diversions »

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
more »