Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

NEIL MACDONALD:

Washington's reluctance to pay the piper

March 3, 2007

The Atlanta Journal Constitution ran a rather pointed editorial cartoon the other day. It featured one of those "Support Our Troops" yellow ribbons you see on bumpers all over the United States.

But underneath it, the cartoonist wrote: "Offer void if injured mentally or physically, requiring quality care, therapy, recuperation and/or disability income."

In other words, all the good intentions and kind words are just ashes if the bills aren't being paid. And while Americans are a people of remarkably good intentions, they are not particularly diligent at paying bills.

Ask the grievously wounded soldiers at Walter Reed Medical Centre, the famous military hospital here in Washington. A months-long newspaper investigation recently exposed dreadful, mouldy living quarters and overloaded services. It also chronicled the desperate existences of veterans who sink into profound depressions waiting for disability allowances and proper treatment of their terrible physical and psychological wounds.

So much for the cherished American vision of a grateful nation welcoming its veterans home and sparing no expense to care for them.

The fact is, many of them were sent to war without proper armour in the first place, because top-grade armour costs money, as does first-rate post-battlefield health care. And paying these sorts of bills ultimately requires raising taxes, and that is something the American public is not prepared to tolerate, no matter what all the magnetic yellow-ribbon bumper stickers might say.

Get out the calculator

The war in Iraq costs $2 billion a week. But this hardly seems like a nation at war. The good times roll on, with no sacrifice evident anywhere, except of course in those families who have lost sons or daughters.

Mercedes sedans and Lexuses, often with a yellow ribbon on the bumper, are common in big American cities. All over the country, people are blithely remortgaging their homes to build new in-home theatres or to finance luxurious improvements (all tax deductible here).

On an individual level, Americans are racking up colossal amounts of personal debt. This is a country with a maxed-out credit card. Average monthly balance in each American household is between $9,000 and $12,000. The average load of unsecured consumer debt per U.S. household sits at about $35,000.

It is no wonder, then, that American voters send their elected representatives to Washington with a clear guiding principle: No new taxes.

In fact, President George W. Bush and the (until recently) Republican-controlled Congress went much further: They cut taxes, and pushed up spending at the same time. Not the best combination, from a fiscal standpoint.

So, unsurprisingly, the entire Iraq war is being fought essentially on borrowed money, which of course adds to the federal deficit, which of course feeds the national debt, which, as of this writing, stands at nearly $8.8 trillion US, a figure with so many zeroes as to be nearly incomprehensible.

Add in the grey heads

What's more, what's coming down the road in the way of anticipated expenditures could make that bit of red ink look like chump change.

Ben Bernanke, the Federal Reserve chairman and the man who controls the central bank strings, made a game effort to explain the numbers to legislators here this week.

The big demographic bulge known as the baby boomers is getting ready to retire, he noted. Meaning they will start to collect social security, and will likely require considerably more medical attention.

Those two items represent an unfunded liability that can also be measured in the trillions, and no one has done a thing to prepare for it.

Bernanke delivered a simple lesson about the public ledger sheet. Basically, that the money has to come from somewhere.

Either taxes have to go up, and considerably, or spending has to be slashed on an unheard-of scale. Keep borrowing, and the public debt balloons so fantastically it becomes an unmanageable fiscal crisis.

"This is sort of like a snowball rolling down the hill," said Bernanke, striving for a metaphor to impress a panel of skeptical politicians. "It's already a pretty big snowball, but it's going to get a lot bigger a lot faster."

In denial

Republicans, of course, argue that their tax cuts provide such an economic stimulus that the treasury will become much richer. Bernanke doesn't buy it. Tax cuts, he told the politicians this week, "usually do not pay for themselves."

"Whatever it is, you have to pay for it," he said. "That's what I'm saying."

And, of course, the longer politicians wait, the more severe and the more disruptive the eventual reckoning will be. "I think the right time to start is about 10 years ago," said Bernanke. Not a pleasant prospect for the legislators.

"We have difficulty explaining to the American public why the deficit is such a serious matter," House Budget Committee Chairman John Spratt told the Fed chairman.

But the explanation is actually simple. If something isn't done, it means a reduction in Americans' wealth and spending power, which is a very bad thing indeed, not just for Americans, but for the rest of the world, especially America's closest trading partner, Canada.

Something can be done of course. Canada did it. In 1995, the Wall Street Journal shocked Canadians by declaring their country an honorary member of the Third World. "Bankrupt Canada?" was the headline on the editorial.

Canada's debt at the time was 68.4 per cent of its gross domestic product. Thirty-five per cent of federal revenues were drained by interest payments on the debt. The deficit that year was $30 billion.

Today, of course, Canada runs surpluses, and has for almost a decade. Its debt is now less than 30 per cent of GDP.

The Canadian government cut spending dramatically and raised Canada Pension Plan payroll taxes years ago to deal with the anticipated burden of retiring boomers. The public wasn't happy, but accepted it.

The U.S., meanwhile, is creeping towards the kinds of debt levels that would qualify it for the Third World status that the Wall Street Journal once applied to Canada. Whistling past the graveyard was one characterization Bernanke agreed with this week.

You won't see the Wall Street Journal's editorial page say that nowadays, of course. But it's all a frightening prospect, or should be.


LETTERS:

Many Canadians who have travelled to some of the big American cities and have met and talked to Americans would agree that the United States is maybe close to a third world country in terms of debt, but is certainly a "second world country" if such a term can be used,in most other regards.

The big American cities are filthy, in need of repairs, and most of the less fortunate citizens are neglected, left with no healtcare of proper social assistance, including their soldiers as it turns out.

Canada is a fist world country, the United States isn't. It is only a matter of time until China becomes the new world superpower especially with the uncontrolled arrogance and spending the current american administration is displaying.

—Claude Lavigne | Olds Alberta

I really enjoyed this article. I am a History major attending the University of Guelph taking mainly American History. You brought up a lot points that I have been really interested in understanding.

My concern is that with all this overspending and massive debt from the war, it seems like the United States and the world is headed towards a massive economic depression.

Because the US for the last one hundreds years has made a concerted effort for economic imperialism, they have stuck their greasy fingers into every nations economy. If and when their economy falls, the rest of the world's economies will fall with them.

My question for you is there any way to avoid what seems quite imminent?

—Dave Mullock | Toronto

This article by N. Macdonald really says it all--EXCEPT!What happens then!

The present Government seems to have taken off on the wrong foot AND in typical Conservative fashion as they did last time around with P.M. Mulroony-set out to prove that adulation of the U.S.A.to the the point of trying to emulate them is not necessarily a wise thing to do.

Whatever you may think personally of Cretien/ Martin of the 90's their leadership is largely responsible for the options in direction that Canada has available now.

—John McLenahan | Qualicum Beach,B.C.

As usual, your description of the situation in the USA was great.

When the Americans went to the invasion of Iraq; they thought they would enjoy the Iraqi oil income and the profit from the international contracts which they would award to the other countries! You remember exactly after the war haw Mr. Preimer was dividing the cake between the allies!

They thought it was a play in the theatre! They thought they could let the others pay for cost of the war. Only Britain and Canada who responded in real way. The USA planned to make money from the war as they did in the first Gulf War!!!!

It will be not far from now when the Wall Street journal would announce the USA as Third World country. Bankrupt USA. That started long time ago, from the beginning of the nineties. The saving in the USA is negative. The credit cards debt is over $ 14,5 billion. The money of the pension plan has been spent by the USA governments started by President Johnston when the congress allowed the government to borrow from that money after it was Trust Money!!!

This means the government has no money to pay for the retirees! They have to borrow money for that purpose. Actually, the USA government does not have the cash money or the sources to borrow money for its day to day expenditures! They play with the oil prices by increasing them; so the Gulf States invest the profits in the American Government Bonds which bring liquidity to the government of the USA!!

—Wa'el Darwish | Montreal

An excellent article. It also should concentrate minds who plan ahead in Ottawa that there is a huge problem looming for the Canadian economy if Canada does not diversify its trading economy. Because clearly as it stands now, the USA will implode one day and Canada with it however good our economic number are.

—D Laurin | Victoria

Go to the Top

ABOUT THIS AUTHOR

Biography

A 19-year veteran of CBC Television News, Neil Macdonald is currently The National's Washington correspondent. Macdonald joined CBC News in 1988. He was initially assigned to Parliament Hill, where, between Southam newspapers and THE NATIONAL, he would spend a combined total of a decade covering Parliament, reporting on five federal elections, and covering six prime ministers. Macdonald then reported from the Middle East for five years. Macdonald took up his post in Washington in March 2003. He speaks English and French fluently, and Arabic conversationally.

More From This Author

More From
NEIL MACDONALD »

News Features

Story Tools: PRINT | Text Size: S M L XL | REPORT TYPO | SEND YOUR FEEDBACK

World »

Indonesian ferry sinks in storm
Rescuers saved more than 240 people aboard an Indonesian passenger ferry that sank Sunday in rough waters off Sumatra island, but at least 25 people have died, officials said.
Iranian forces practise defending nuke sites
Iran on Sunday began large-scale air defence war games aimed at protecting the country's nuclear facilities against any possible attack, state television reported.
China mine blast toll rises to 87
The death toll from a coal mine explosion in northern China rose to 87 on Sunday as rescue crews worked in frigid temperatures to reach 21 miners still trapped underground.
more »

Canada »

Disgraced N.S. bishop's replacement named Video
The Roman Catholic Church has appointed a replacement for Bishop Raymond Lahey, of the Diocese of Antigonish, N.S., who is facing child pornography charges.
Vancouver Island evacuation order lifted Video
An evacuation order has been lifted for hundreds of south Vancouver Island residents forced from their homes by flooding.
Journalists enhance Canadians' freedom: PM
Prime Minister Stephen Harper urged journalists to "shine light into dark corners" of government affairs during a speech late Saturday, but wouldn't take questions from reporters covering the event.
more »

Politics »

Journalists enhance Canadians' freedom: PM
Prime Minister Stephen Harper urged journalists to "shine light into dark corners" of government affairs during a speech late Saturday, but wouldn't take questions from reporters covering the event.
Colvin's job safe despite Afghan torture testimony Video
The Conservatives will not try to remove Richard Colvin from his post in Washington, Defence Minister Peter MacKay says, even though they question the credibility of his testimony on Afghan prisoners.
Hillier didn't hear detainee torture allegations Video
Former chief of defence staff Rick Hillier says he's never heard suggestions that Canada may have been complicit in the torture of detainees in Afghanistan.
more »

Health »

More H1N1 vaccine, ventilators to come Video
Ontario supplied hospitals with 200 additional ventilators on Friday in anticipation of a surge in swine flu cases.
Trade show pitches surgical passages to India Video
Exhibitors at a Toronto trade fair are hoping to add surgery to the list of reasons Canadians travel, but a medical ethicist questions the lack of oversight.
Weight gain in pregnancy guides updated
Health Canada is formally replacing its guidelines on weight gain during pregnancy to match new U.S. recommendations.
more »

Arts & Entertainment»

Plaskett double winner at Canadian Folk Music Awards
Joel Plaskett's triple album Three earned the Halifax singer-songwriter a double win at the Canadian Folk Music Awards on Saturday.
Jackson’s glove fetches $350,000 US
Michael Jackson's iconic rhinestone-studded glove got the white-glove treatment on Saturday, bringing $350,000 US on the auction block in New York.
Rare Darwin book found in Oxford washroom
A first edition of Charles Darwin's On the Origin of Species will go on the auction block 150 years after its publication
more »

Technology & Science »

Bell quietly drops system access fee
The cellphone system access fee is all but extinct. Bell Canada has quietly axed the charge, joining rivals Rogers and Telus.
Beam sent around Large Hadron Collider
The operators of the Large Hadron Collider have successfully sent a beam of particles around the ring of the world's largest particle collider in Switzerland.
Astronauts complete 6-hour spacewalk
Astronauts from space shuttle Atlantis completed the second of three scheduled spacewalks Saturday, spending just over six hours installing equipment on the International Space Station.
more »

Money »

Ottawa will stay course on stimulus: Flaherty Video
Rather than turning off the stimulus taps or pouring more fuel on the economic fire, Ottawa will stand pat with the $61 billion in stimulus spending announced in January, Finance Minister Jim Flaherty says.
Canada Post struggles to innovate
Canada's postal service is reinventing itself as it struggles to make up for dwindling demand in the face of a devastating global economic slowdown.
The 10-billion-barrel battle
Henry Lyatsky wants B.C.'s coast opened to oil drilling but environmentalists stand opposed.
more »

Consumer Life »

Bullying is a public health issue: researcher
Bullying should be considered a public health problem and governments should adopt national strategies against it, says a Canadian professor who led a study of bullying in 40 countries.
Early Canadian stamps auction nets $3.2M US Video
A New York stamp collector auctioned parts of his collection in New York on Thursday, including a Canadian-issued stamp that is one of the world's rarest.
Fake hairstyling irons pop up in Regina
Hundreds of knock-off hairstyling irons were seized Friday morning by RCMP acting on a hot tip.
more »

Sports »

Scores: NHL NBA

Stamps vs. Riders: A little food for thought
A tongue-in-cheek guide to Sunday's Western final between the Calgary Stampeders and the Saskatchewan Roughriders.
Signs point to Sedin for hot Hawks
The Vancouver Canucks hope to have Daniel Sedin back in the lineup for the first time in 19 games Sunday night when they host the Chicago Blackhawks.
Canadian speedskater Groves wins gold
Kristina Groves of Ottawa won her first World Cup gold of the season on Sunday, prevailing in the 1,500-metre race in Hamar, Norway.
more »