Make them stop lying
Comments (27)
Thursday, July 26, 2007 | 02:04 PM ET
By Henry Champ
As a lifelong sports fan, I keep wondering when do we, the fans, say enough is enough.
When do we insist that the lying stop.
Take this year's Tour de France, the world's premier cycling event. Already two entire teams have dropped out amid doping charges, the winners of four of the stages couldn't pass clean urine and the overall leader, Danish rider Michael Rasmussen, has been sent home for violating team rules.
Sent home? What an understatement. On three occasions over the past year Rasmussen missed mandated drug tests and yet his team, the Danish Cycling Federation, and the organizers of the Tour de France turned a blind eye and let him enter the race. So much for a determined effort to clean up a sport that has been plagued by doping accusations and suspensions for several years now.
But back to the fans, like those thousands upon thousands who line the course in France. Why do they still flock to the hillsides to watch a split-second flash of colour sweep past, surely knowing that what they are watching is probably tainted?
If only they were alone. But the bad news wafting over pro basketball, baseball and football these days has to have all of us down in the dumps.
I gave up on NBA basketball some years ago. Spending a couple of hours waiting for the last three minutes of a game when the players would go all out for victory, that was a price I was no longer willing to pay. As a parent, I was not impressed either with player conduct on and off the court, so I am not terribly sympathetic now that an NBA referee has been caught up in a gambling scandal.
NBA commissioner David Stern gets high marks for his contrite and rueful press conference after the allegations and the existence of a grand jury investigation came to light. Stern talked of betrayal, and about the efforts of the league to ensure a fair product and avoid any hint of gambling.
And yet this is the same commissioner that chose Las Vegas to host the league's all-star game last year. That's the same Las Vegas where point spreads, over-and-under betting and wagering on a player's scoring have made professional basketball one of the biggest "handles" in gambling. A handle being the total amount bet on a contest.
The list goes on
In football, Michael Vick, the star quarterback of the Atlanta Falcons has been indicted on charges of despicable animal cruelty. Vick has been charged with running a dog-fighting enterprise on his estate in Smithfield, Va.
This time it's another commissioner, the NFL's Roger Goodell, who is out there talking about the integrity of the game. He has also scheduled meetings with the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.
Goodell says the league and the ASPCA are working on a program to teach players about the proper treatment of animals. Presumably, Goodell will also want programs with the National Rifle Association, to be hauled out when one of his players is arrested on gun charges, and with Mothers against Drunk Driving when those issues arise.
And then we have Barry Bonds, the San Francisco Giants slugger who is on the brink of becoming major league baseball's all-time home run hitter.
Let's be clear, it has never been proven that Bonds has used steroids or any other performance-enhancing drug. But he is linked to trainers who have admitted distributing these drugs, his hat and shoe size have grown noticeably since he's been in the league, and it is clear that steroid use among pro ballplayers is a fact.
Now, as Bonds inches toward a new home run record, MLB commissioner Bud Selig wanders back and forth on how to treat this historic event even as it is being reviled by many in the stands. Should he be in attendance when Bonds breaks the record or should he been conveniently elsewhere?
Make them stop
Who cares? What is important for fans to know is that Selig, in concert with the MLB Player's Association, is continuing to oppose real drug-testing reform within the league. When early reports of steroid use surfaced, Selig and Donald Fehr, the player's representative fought to water down the league's testing regimes.The player's association is currently fighting in court to keep private the names of dozens of players who have been named by a former bat boy of the New York Mets. He admits supplying drugs, not only to Mets players but to those on visiting teams as well.
The bat boy, 37-year-old Kirk Radomski, has pleaded guilty to money laundering and distributing steroids and other performance-enhancing drugs over a 10-year period. As part of a plea bargain, Radomski was ordered to co-operate with the MLB steroid investigation being conducted by former Senate majority leader George Mitchell. These names should come out when Radomski is sentenced, but MLB and the player's association are fighting against disclosure.
This picture of the big three sports commissioners in North America appearing ashen faced and humble before their fan base isn't a pretty one. But it isn't going to get it done any longer. Pro sport is a big-ticket item in the U.S. and, apart from that, has an emotional connection with so many people.
There's no reason to ramble on about the players' responsibilities to the community. Or to repeat the most-quoted line on the sports pages this week: "to whom much is given, much is expected." Or even to rabbit on about the responsibilities of team owners and league executives.
If we could just get them to stop the lying.
« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »
This discussion is now Open. Submit your Comment.
« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »
Post a Comment
Washington File »
About the Author
Henry Champ is CBC Newsworld's correspondent in Washington, D.C., delivering Canadian viewers the latest developments in the U.S. political arena. Recently, he has been a leading Canadian voice on coverage of the war on terrorism, the war in Iraq and the growing concerns over the Canada-U.S. relationship.
Recent Posts
- Vapour ads create successful campaign smokescreens
- Henry Champ
- Thursday, September 11, 2008
- The parties are over
- Henry Champ
- Friday, September 5, 2008
- The attack dog fights back
- Henry Champ
- Thursday, September 4, 2008
- The plan for Sarah Palin
- Henry Champ
- Wednesday, September 3, 2008
- Paying a high price for Palin
- Henry Champ
- Tuesday, September 2, 2008
- Subscribe to this blog
Recent Comments
- I quite following professional sports when players starte...
- Make them stop lying
- Want to stop athletes, politicians and others from lying?...
- Make them stop lying
- You answered your own questions when you wrote "Pro sport...
- Make them stop lying
- I stopped watching amateur & professional sports years ag...
- Make them stop lying
- hey Henry, maybe you can look into getting the BB...
- Make them stop lying
Archives
- September 2008
- (6 postings)
- August 2008
- (6 postings)
- June 2008
- (3 postings)
- May 2008
- (6 postings)
- April 2008
- (3 postings)
- March 2008
- (4 postings)
- February 2008
- (5 postings)
- January 2008
- (7 postings)
- November 2007
- (2 postings)
- October 2007
- (7 postings)
- September 2007
- (1 postings)
- July 2007
- (6 postings)
- June 2007
- (5 postings)
- May 2007
- (6 postings)
- April 2007
- (6 postings)
- March 2007
- (5 postings)
- February 2007
- (7 postings)
- January 2007
- (8 postings)
- December 2006
- (7 postings)
- November 2006
- (8 postings)
- October 2006
- (10 postings)
- September 2006
- (9 postings)
- August 2006
- (9 postings)
Comments (27)
MK
BC
I quite following professional sports when players started making more money per game than I earn per year. They don't need my support. I'll leave that to the beer-bellies that stream onto the streets following a "Big Game", chanting "We're Number 1". (Like they really had something to do with it)
As long as people are willing to pay the price at the gate, and support the high salaries, the doping will continue.
Professional Sports is not "Sport", it's "Entertainment".
Posted August 2, 2007 09:33 PM
Peter
Edmonton
Want to stop athletes, politicians and others from lying?
It's up to us.
Don't vote for them.
Don't watch them.
Don't buy their stuff.
Posted August 1, 2007 03:14 PM
John Dunbar
You answered your own questions when you wrote "Pro sport is a big-ticket item". Big money corrupts, and the biggest money corrupts the most.
On the positive side, there are notable exceptions. Steve Nash, Mkembi Mtumbo and Tim Horton are the only 3 that come to mind immediately from the sports world but Bill and Melinda Gates and Warren Buffet show that its even possible for business people to be heroes.
Despite these few examples, I long ago gave up on looking for inspiration from pro sports (and the Olympics for the same reason) years ago. Heroes are where you find them. Romeo Dallaire, Stephen Lewis, David Suzuki, these are the kind of people we Canadians should be pointing out to our children to look up to.
We could also point out that Steve Nash is a hero in spite of being a top pro athlete, not because of it. That makes him all the more remarkable.
Posted July 29, 2007 04:30 AM
Russell
I stopped watching amateur & professional sports years ago when I realised there was no longer any hope of seeing players who were undoped. The level of lying is so high, I just stopped watching.
It's the same as watching politicians - I no longer believe any of them either.
It's gone so far, I threw my TV set away about 8 years ago. What an incredibly freeing act that was! I just stopped watching TV and all my grumbles went away. Since I already know it's all faked up, doped up, and fixed, I just can't be bothered.
I don't miss it.
Posted July 28, 2007 11:22 PM
derek
vancouver
hey Henry,
maybe you can look into getting the BBC to stop lying as well...
Posted July 28, 2007 03:38 PM
jeff
Hey now,
you academics aren't suggesting that we take doping out of professional:
medicine
politics
music
art
literature
and film making,
now are you?
Posted July 28, 2007 03:31 PM
Jeff Wilson
Winnipeg
"Make them stop lying." Wow! This is gonna be great! "h" is gonna get super-pertinant with regard to these very early, 21st century woes that we all feel! And that may kill us all!!
Not!
I'm with the others who have been drawn by the title of your article, but very disappointed by the content.
"Make them stop lying" is a rallying call more pressingly neeeded to be applied to all those in politics, the Media, multi-nationals, religions, etc..., than it is currently needed to be applied to atheletes who are, as was rightly pointed out, mere "entertainers!"
Please, "h," you are a jounalist! Won't YOU please "make them stop lying?"
And by them I mean the people whose lies truely affect us! Bary Bonds doesn't cause global warming, jihads, massive lay-offs, nor start wars!
Please, "h," won't you make the people who actually do these terrible things stop lying about them. You can do this by hammering away at them with questions that must be answered. When they don't answer, everyone will know that they are lying. But you must make sure that it is known that your question was not answered! And you can do this by NOT MOVING ON!!!! untill the question is answered!
And so... by all that you hold dear as a journalist... will you please "make them stop lying?" It's the ONLY THING we really want from you!
It really is up to all of you in the media.
After all, it's not like I'll ever have a chance to get to the truth like you do!
I don't have a press pass!
By the way, ya know all those journalists from all over the place who are following Barry Bonds from ball-park to ball-park, I hear they are fed very well for free! I hear it's buffets with roast beef, or is it roast ham, or turkey, or ALL of the above with ALL the fixens! And the booze is ALL-you-can-drink and free too! That's what I hear.
Posted July 28, 2007 01:31 AM
Alex
saskatoon
There are arguments on both sides of the Bonds home run debate. Some claim innocent until proven guilty; others like Bob Costas just point out the obvious freakish physical growth of Barry as well as the statistics. Actually, his stats are even more freaky and damning than his appearance.
For me, the issue is not even one of honesty (although who wouldn't agree with Champ on that count). It is a matter of trying to have it both ways. You can't try to sell the game as a healthy pursuit for kids and for family entertainment while turning a blind eye to steroid abuse. If you want to see home runs hit in superhuman numbers at all costs, then you just can't at the same time sell the sport to kids. Those commercials for boys' and girls' clubs of America by baseball players are about as hypocritical as they come when you consider how MLB has reneged on their social responsibilities. The fact that THEY make money from this wholesome image should automatically commit them to a more rigorous testing process.
Posted July 27, 2007 06:16 PM
Paul Klimstra
Hamilton
Three weeks ago I caught my friend (who is a diehard cycling fan, with the Tour his annual highlight) offguard when I asked him, "What's the drug of choice this year?"
Sadly my humourous poke has come true.
I also agree with BNL...when I saw the title I thought for sure it was one of 3 or 4 of the current Bush scandals.
Posted July 27, 2007 05:02 PM
BS
Vancouver
With all the money and privelege that's heaped on athletes, pro or not, I'm not surprised that so many fall into corruption. It only gets worse when they're also made into celebrities, vehicles for advertising, and sometimes even symbol's of their country's politics. Consider the artificially high place they get in society, plus the squads of agents, parents living through them, personal doctors and coaches, sponsors, groupies, gamblers, and the rest of the "entourage" that follow these guys around - no wonder sportsmanship doesn't stand a chance!
Posted July 27, 2007 04:20 PM
Chris
The problem is that doping is a part of the culture in many sports. Players feel pressured to dope, because if they don't, they a) won't get paid as much, or b) won't make the team.
In many sports, this doping culture filters all the way down to college sports. I had a friend who gave up on his baseball scholarship after 2 years because he was being pressured by his coach to dope.
As such, to rid the sport of doping (or at least make it trustworthy), its going to take management that's serious about clamping down on doping. We need commissioners who are willing to say: "I admit doping is a problem in my league, I admit that many records have been broken by doping players, I am now naming doping as unacceptable, and will be introducing a tough anti-doping program across the league."
Once pro-players realize they can't get away with doping, it will eventually filter down to our college and highschool players too.
Posted July 27, 2007 03:55 PM
Gerald
edmonton
It may be small consolation, but at least they are being forced to lie as opposed to the free pass that the press / society previously accorded to celebrities / people of authority in the past.
Posted July 27, 2007 03:25 PM
Adrian Kelly
Sports are to be played, as in game, as in fun, recreation. However. I've noticed that in all sports the most funding goes to the elites of the sport to the detriment of everyone else playing. When money rules the outcome don't expect reason to be a part of equation. Sports are just another example of the common malaise of our society.
Posted July 27, 2007 02:55 PM
Deb Johnson
Frankly I've given up on the Tour de Farce, as a whole. I've never watched NBA, nor MLB, and never will. I'll watch F1 where the cars have to be driven by guys who know what they're doing. At least the drivers aren't cheating, I hope.
Sadly, it starts at the top. We see dishonest politicians, and accept them by not demanding impeachment, as in the case of the Prez. So why should we treat athletes any differently? Are we going to be tougher on them than on the people in charge of our tax dollars? Not bloody likely!
Posted July 27, 2007 01:57 PM
Steve Wqaterston
What really tickles my funny bone is the suggestion elsewhere that the sport of cycling be dropped from the Olympics until it cleans up its act. Is this to say that the Olympics are CLEAN!?!?!?
We should all realize that in any sort of competition, the stakes can often be high, and when there are many competitors, some if not many, will try to gain an edge on the rest. The latest scandals to hit the Tour and the other professional sports should really be no surprise to anyone. If you were truly surprised, it's time to wake up from your Pollyanna dream world.
If these scandals really bother you, stop watching televised events, stop attending the games and stop buying the merchandise. Ultimately, it is we the consumer that drives this behaviour because we need to see winners and want to associate with winning teams.
Rather than watch a sport, do something for yourself and participate in a sport, you'll feel better for it and these scandals won't trouble you nearly as much.
Posted July 27, 2007 12:52 PM
Dave
Calgary
It should be well noted that the vast MAJORITY of athletes are clean, hard-working individuals that are highly involved in the community. But all it takes is a few high profile cases and people beleive that entire sports are tainted. This is just another case of how powerful the media can be in public influence.
Posted July 27, 2007 12:34 PM
GGW
Ottawa
What about the Bush guys who seem to make a habit of lying to Congress, Grand Juries and the public viz.Gonzales and Mueller, Libby, Cheney, Wolfowitz, et al.?
Posted July 27, 2007 11:38 AM
Steve Staniek
Hamilton
When I saw Henry's title I was sure he was set to blast the Bushie-American press partnership,or the Harper-Canadian press partnership including the CBC for the endless litany of lies they've been imposing on us.
The do not want us to know or accept the nasty truth which is that the international violence that has caused our governments to lock down our free and democratic western nations is due largely to the actions of our governments using military might to support international corporate interests in eastern nations. It's common knowledge that the attacks on Saddam and the Taliban followed failed business dealings with those two American business partners.
But it's amazingly disappointing how our tolerance of lies has grown. Perhaps it's the corporate culture most westerners live in that has cranked up our immunity levels. Corporate speak, like political rhetoric uses positive cliches like: "moving forward, "having said that", "on balance", and other distracting phrases to: distance, disown, and disconnect from their past lies. Bush, like other tyrants is a master of this method of lying.
I thought this time Henry you would stick your neck out and speak the real truth.
Steve
Hamilton.
Posted July 27, 2007 09:42 AM
Arcosenate
Ottawa
The only possible solution to this problem is to have two versions of every tournament, the clean competition and the all drug competition. It's the only way to determine exactly what we fans prefer, a competition limited by the natural abilities of the human body or the unnatural, superhuman competition created through science. And it shouldn't be limited to just chemical enhancement either, if someone figures out how to graft a human head onto a horse for the MegaMan Marathon, well, so be it. Imagine, in Canada we would have curlers with 60 feet long arms who could just reach out and drop the rock on target. If the money is there, the fame and so on, we as fans should sucker these people into seeing how far they will actually go. Or we could just turn off the TV and go play sports ourselves.
Posted July 27, 2007 09:08 AM
JD
Toronto
Many the capitalist well tell you greed is good...I beg to differ. What do you expect when you give millions of dollars to under-educated muscle heads for chasing balls on a field...responsible behaviour???
Posted July 27, 2007 08:36 AM
Joe
Halifax
Pro athletes are among the luckiest people on the planet. They get to play a sport that they have pretty much always been a star in for vast sums of money, get paid to stay in tip top physical shape, spend summers golfing or whatever and usually retire before they’re 40. Sounds like a sweet deal to me and in a world where being an “almost professional” counts for basically nothing, I can certainly understand the pressure to perform. Now considering that motivation, it’s also a safe bet that top athletes didn’t spend much of their early years debating ethics, delving into great works of literature or science, writing short stories, travelling the world or exploring art. It is also unlikely that an NBA center grew up in an exclusive Vermont neighborhood and went to private schools.
So, in essence, we have a class of people who have exercised their bodies probably at the expense of at least some of their brains, play games for a living instead of actually doing anything much as a part of the society, are paid large sums of money and are treated like media gods when successful. When you add all of that up, I find it incredibly bizarre that we would expect a group of people like that to somehow be these moral pillars of society to be emulated and admired. Debating moral quandaries is just not what pro athletes do.
If we want to pay to watch a group of 7 foot expert ball throwers run around a court every week then so be it but let’s not expect much of these people beyond that. After all, if someone is lying about doping or gambling or whatever then it is simply because the general public chooses not to deal with reality and come to grips with the idea that when the proverbial “dumb jock” is (or may be) turned into a demigod millionaire overnight he just might be tempted to engage in less than above board activities.
Posted July 27, 2007 08:33 AM
Ken
Toronto
Money trumps integrity.
Professional sports biggest concern is loss of public interest. Loss of interest leads to lower advertising, TV and gambling revenues the real drivers of this business. Substance abuse is easy to rationalize from a player and even the corporate perspective as even "bad" publicity is better than no publicity.
The majority of fans have limited engagement in professional sports. They are interested in what ever is marketed or televised principally. Substance abuse is just sports noise in the end. Fans truly interested in the integrity of sports are just too few to influence.
Posted July 27, 2007 08:19 AM
Bill McIntosh
I think the phrase "the product" says it all.
Bill.
Posted July 27, 2007 06:50 AM
Tom Fry
Calgary
Perhaps the dismissal of Vegas was a bit hasty. if you put the sports books in charge of organized professional sport, they'd probably take the necessary steps to deal with anyone (crooked refs, 'roid users, etc.) who might interfere with the marketability of their product. People won't bet if they figure the contests are rigged, so it would actually be in the bookies' interests to keep things clean. And, perhaps, offenders wouldn't get off with wussy suspensions - so I've heard ;)
Posted July 26, 2007 05:59 PM
Don
We all know the tour de dope is a farce, as is hockey, baseball, football and soccor. Hell's bells, North American football has been a doper's paradise since the very beginning: it's always easier to play through the pain when you're higher than a kite and can't feel a damn thing. Why bother wondering or worrying whether your team gets in, it's no secret that the MVP on every team in every sport is the team pharmacist.
the monsters who take the field on game day are barely human anymore: they are the end products of training, doping, genetic engineering and God knows what all else. My question is why anyone would take pro sports seriously anymore when the abuses are so obvious to anyone who can look past the hype. Pro sports is a trillion dollar business - look at the Olympics - so sports associations and governing bodies may as well make all the performance enhancers legal for use and drop the idiotic hypocrisy once and for all. We can then sit back, relax, and enjoy the spectacle of impossibly huge athlete's perform for our amusement. No matter if they burn out young: there is so much money to be made that we'll have a never ending supply of genetic freaks and mutations willing to take a shot at the limelight. I say go for it!
Posted July 26, 2007 04:53 PM
BNL
Tulsa
When I saw your title, I thought you would offer some insight to the current goings-on with Alberto Gonzales.
Oh, well.
Posted July 26, 2007 03:40 PM
C McCoy
Edmonton
I understand the Spanish have a saying, nothing truly evil will last a century. Meaning,of course, such contains within itself the seeds of its own destruction.
Ok, so let's even ignore all that and just discuss monetary. With the ever escalating demands of all these people, ordinary workers are simply priced out of attendance. There's only so much corporate tax writeoff out there, even that is a limited commodity.
Is not the whole professional sport system poised for a fall?
Posted July 26, 2007 02:27 PM