Trudeau says no to Garneau offer of 1-on-1 debate
Liberal Party debate formats only gave contenders one chance to spar directly
CBC News
Posted: Feb 25, 2013 10:45 AM ET
Last Updated: Feb 25, 2013 3:26 PM ET
Marc Garneau and Justin Trudeau traded shots during the Liberal leadership debate in Mississauga, Ont. on Feb. 16 - but only for three minutes. (Chris Young/Canadian Press)
Related
Justin Trudeau doesn't intend to take up Marc Garneau's challenge to meet him for a one-on-one debate in the federal Liberal leadership debate.
Federal Liberal Party leadership candidate Garneau dropped the gauntlet at a press conference in Ottawa Monday morning, saying that Trudeau, his fellow candidate and thought to be the front-runner, should have the "courage of his convictions" to debate with him directly.
The Liberal Party has not scheduled any one-on-one debates in the run-up to the final deadline for leadership voting on April 14. Garneau said he has only had three minutes so far to debate one-on-one with Trudeau, although he refused to blame the Liberal Party for the way it has structured the three debates that have been held.
Garneau told reporters at a press conference that Trudeau was "untested" and was hiding behind a "carefully crafted public relations campaign."
"It is time for Justin to step up and defend his ideas, because if he can't defend them to me in front of a room full of Liberals, he will never be able to do it against Stephen Harper," Garneau said.
Minutes after Garneau finished speaking, Trudeau tweeted: "I respect all the candidates for #LPCLdr. See you in Halifax, Marc. I hear there are 1 on 1s. ;-)".
Speaks for itself
Asked if Trudeau was rejecting the idea of a special debate just with Garneau, his campaign office spokeswoman Kate Monfette said in an email, "I think the tweet speaks for itself. He will be happy to debate with Mr. Garneau in Halifax on Sunday, as planned."
The one-on-one debate, if it were to happen, would have to take place outside the auspices of the Liberal Party, Garneau acknowledged. He said he envisions a one-hour debate, moderated by a journalist. Garneau said he would clear his schedule so he could meet Trudeau for the proposed debate.
Asked about how the other seven leadership candidates would feel about being excluded from such a debate, Garneau said it is up to them to make their own arrangements. He added that "polls" tell him that he and Trudeau are the two front runners in the race.
Garneau made a reference to the recent American presidential debates in which voters were able to see Mitt Romney and Barack Obama defend their ideas in lengthy two-person exchanges. He said that the Liberal Party leadership debates provide "limited opportunity" for the nine candidates to offer a full picture of their contrasting views.
The next scheduled Liberal leadership debate takes place in Halifax on March 3, to be followed by a final debate on March 23.
Share Tools
Power & Politics' Ballot Box question by Hannah Thibedeau Mar. 1, 2013 4:58 PM Do you support the Keystone XL Pipeline?
Top News Headlines
- Surrey Liberals call for B.C. Premier's resignation
- Over one hundred Liberal party members called for the resignation of B.C. Premier Christy Clark at a breakfast meeting in Surrey Sunday morning. more »
- Body of man found in home where police officer was killed
- The lifeless body of a man has been found inside a home in northern Quebec, ending a 17-hour standoff that left one police officer dead and another seriously injured on Saturday night. more »
- Pakistan bomb outside mosque kills 37
- Police say a car bomb has killed at least 37 people and wounded another 141 in a neighborhood dominated by Shia Muslims in the southern Pakistan city of Karachi. more »
- Liberal MPs Murray and Garneau challenge frontrunner Trudeau
- Liberal leadership hopefuls made a last-ditch effort to shore up support for their campaigns before tonight's midnight deadline in the fourth of five federal Liberal leadership debates in Halifax on Sunday. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Toronto saw greatest benefit from FedDev Ontario money
- Canada's newest have-not region, southern Ontario, got its own billion-dollar bailout fund from Ottawa in 2009, after recession devastated the province's manufacturing sector. more »
- Surrey Liberals call for B.C. Premier's resignation
- Over one hundred Liberal party members called for the resignation of B.C. Premier Christy Clark at a breakfast meeting in Surrey Sunday morning. more »
- Ex-Tory senator doesn't see 'usefulness' of the Senate
- Former Conservative senator Michael Fortier, whose nomination to the upper chamber once drew considerable controversy, says it's time to do away with the Red Chamber as it's outlived its usefulness in an interview with CBC Radio's The House. more »
- Keystone XL supporters hail U.S. State Dept. report
- A new U.S. State Department report is the latest evidence that the long-delayed Keystone XL oil pipeline from Canada should be approved, supporters say. more »
The National
The House
- PBO warns government shipbuilding costs are off the mark Mar. 2, 2013 6:18 AM This week on The House, Evan Solomon sits down with Canada's Parliamentary Budget Officer Kevin Page to discuss his latest report on the purchase of joint support ships. Why did Page conclude that the government's estimated costs are off the mark? We also get reaction to Page's report from the Parliamentary Secretary to the President of the Treasury Board, Andrew Saxton.
- Body of man found in home where police officer was killed
- Surrey Liberals call for B.C. Premier's resignation
- Queen in hospital with stomach ailment
- Iceland tests find meat pies contain no meat at all
- Dragon capsule docks at space station
- Highways close as snow storm hits southern Alberta
- Westjet strands flyers in Moncton during March break
- Italian coffee shop in Montreal in trouble with language watchdog
- Florida sinkhole threatens neighbouring homes


