Royal succession bill raises religious questions
Will the British throne cut its ties to the Church of England?
By Janyce McGregor, CBC News
Posted: Jan 28, 2013 7:31 AM ET
Last Updated: Jan 28, 2013 9:03 AM ET
Prince Charles, seen here during a meeting with Prime Minster Stephen Harper in Regina last May, is said to hold concerns about the religious aspect of new legislation to change the royal line of succession. (Paul Chiasson/Canadian Press)
Related
Related Stories
External Links
(Note:CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external links.)
Prince Charles is said to be concerned that changes to the relationship between the Crown and the Church of England have not been thought through.
Despite the fact that the current bill to change the rules surrounding the Royal line of succession only removes the current ban on marrying a Roman Catholic, it could be the first steps on a slippery slope.
The Daily Mail reported earlier this month that the man who is first in line to inherit the throne from his mother, Queen Elizabeth, raised his concerns about the "rushed" bill in a private government meeting, fearing "unintended consequences" from some of its features.
The popular British tabloid also reported that some Church of England bishops shared his worries about what might happened if the son or daughter of Prince William and Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge first married a Roman Catholic and then had to confront the Catholic canon law requirement to raise that child as a Roman Catholic.
During second reading debate in the British House of Commons last week, Sir Tony Baldry, a veteran Conservative MP who also carries the responsibility of officially representing the Church of England in the British Parliament, said that church leaders had no objections to the changes meant to modernize the monarchy.
But the bill could be seen as a first small step towards de-coupling the Royal family from its historic relationship with the Anglican church.
'Defender of [all?] Faith'
The Prince of Wales mused in 2008 about wanting to alter the Royal title he receives on his eventual coronation day, from "Defender of the Faith" – held by all British monarchs since Henry VIII – to "Defender of Faith," in recognition of the multicultural country and Commonwealth over which he would reign in the 21st century.
But in a speech last May, Queen Elizabeth appeared to defend the existing title and what it symbolizes.
"[The church's] role is not to defend Anglicanism to the exclusion of all other religions, instead the church has a duty to protect the free practice of all faiths in this country," she said.
The monarch's role as the supreme governor of the Church of England is essentially ceremonial and may not need to restrict a king or queen's personal religious practice.
King James II was both a Roman Catholic and the head of the Church of England in his brief tenure — although no Catholic has reigned since he was deposed in 1688.
The Act of Settlement, passed in 1701 and still in effect, says that only Protestants can become king or queen.
The new legislation doesn't alter that, but it does remove the ban on marrying Roman Catholics.
No ban exists on marrying another faith because doing so would have been unthinkable when the current rule was written centuries ago.
British Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg, the government spokesman for the U.K. legislation, said during the Commons debate at Westminister last week that there is nothing in the bill's provisions that alters the status of the monarch as head of the Church of England.
For now, the greater question about whether a religious role or title should be an entrenched part of the monarchy waits for another day.
Present-day compromises
When Prince Michael of Kent (Queen Elizabeth's first cousin) married a Catholic, papal dispensation was sought to waive the Catholic obligation under canon law to raise the children as Catholic. His children remain in the line of succession.
Reports suggested Prince Charles finds this potential solution to the issue going forward "unsatisfactory" and "unconvincing."
Canadian Autumn Kelly, the wife of Princess Anne's son Peter Phillips, renounced her Roman Catholic faith at the time of her 2008 marriage to the Queen's grandson. Phillips is 11th in line to the throne.
For Canada's part, its own Anglican church has been independent of the Church of England for decades, so whether or not the British Crown continues to head the Church of England doesn't really apply here: Canada's monarch is not the symbolic head of any Canadian church, and Canada has had its own Crown since 1931.
Still, the written assurances provided by the Harper government last month include an agreement to remove the ban on marrying a Roman Catholic in Canada's new bill.
For their part, Canadian churches don't appear to be active in the debate.
"It's not on our radar," Sam Carriere from the Anglican Church of Canada said.
René Laprise, the communications officer for the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops, said his organization had "no comment" on the changes either.
Share Tools
Wright out over Duffy payback: Reaction from the Hill and beyond by Kady O'Malley May. 19, 2013 10:39 AM New chief of staff expected to be longtime Harper aide and current principal secretary Ray Novak
Top News Headlines
- Harper chief of staff resigns amid Senate expense scandal
- Nigel Wright has resigned as Prime Minister Stephen Harper's chief of staff, following revelations he wrote a $90,000 cheque to repay living expenses claimed by Senator Mike Duffy. more »
- Jeep driver apologizes after stunt kills Edmonton woman
- A man claiming to be the driver of a Jeep that struck and killed a spectator at a charity event in Edmonton says he is sorry for what happened. more »
- Senior Pakistani politician Zahra Shahid shot dead
- Voting in Karachi goes ahead a day after gunmen killed a senior member of Imran Khan's Movement for Justice (PTI) party outside her home in Karachi. more »
- Vancouver man attacked, killed in Costa Rica
- A Canadian man has been killed in Costa Rica in an apparent home invasion, but Foreign Affairs has released few other details on the matter. more »
Must Watch
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Email is proof Senate greenlit expenses, Brazeau says
- Senator Patrick Brazeau, in an interview with CBC Radio's The House, says the Senate gave him the green light to claim expenses for an apartment in the Ottawa area, in an email dated March 8, 2011 — the same $48,000 expenses a Senate report now says he has to pay back. more »
- Senator Pamela Wallin leaves Conservative caucus
- Senator Pamela Wallin says she is recusing herself from the Conservative caucus while her travel expense claims are under scrutiny. Wallin's departure comes one day after Senator Mike Duffy left the Tory caucus amid controversy over his expense claims. more »
- Reaction to Nigel Wright's resignation as PM's chief of staff
- In statement, Nigel Wright insists he did not advise the prime minister "of the means by which Sen. Duffy's expenses were repaid, either before or after the fact." more »
- Ads tout job grants program that doesn't yet exist
- The federal government has been airing ads touting its Canada Jobs Grant for training workers, but the Conservative government House leader acknowledges the announced program is merely a "proposal that needs to be fleshed out." more »
The National
The House
- Questions mount for Harper and chief of staff Nigel Wright in Senate scandal May. 18, 2013 1:15 PM This week on The House, with Senators Wallin and Duffy now out of the Conservative caucus, we get reaction from NDP Ethics critic Charlie Angus. We also hear directly from Senator Patrick Brazeau who says the Conservatives have thrown him under the bus. Plus we speak with B.C. Premier Christy Clark after her stunning victory.
- Harper chief of staff resigns amid Senate expense scandal
- Jeep driver apologizes after stunt kills Edmonton woman
- Spectator killed at Edmonton Jeep event
- Rob Ford should resign if allegations true, councillors say
- Police find bodies of 2 missing New Brunswick fishermen
- Astronaut Chris Hadfield adjusts to 'earthling' life
- Remains found on murder suspect Millard's Ontario farm
- Vancouver man attacked, killed in Costa Rica
- Car drives into crowd at Virginia parade


