Royal baby bill opens a 'royal Pandora's box'
Do changes to the royal line of succession steer Canada close to a slippery republican slope?
By Janyce McGregor, CBC News
Posted: Jan 28, 2013 7:31 AM ET
Last Updated: Jan 28, 2013 7:49 AM ET
Queen Elizabeth, seen here at a ceremony at the British Foreign and Commonwealth Office last month, remains popular. But once countries begin debating changes to how the royal line of succession works, is there an opportunity for republicanism to creep into the debate? (Alastair Grant/Pool/AP Photo)
Related
Related Stories
External Links
(Note:CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external links.)
At its heart, the three changes that comprise the bill to change the Royal line of succession are about removing discrimination and adding more freedom to a centuries-old system.
The bill ends the preference for males over females, removes a ban on marrying Roman Catholics, and abolishes the need for certain, more distant members of the royal family to have the sitting monarch approve their marriages.
But does talk of rights and freedoms even make sense when it comes to the Royal Family?
Technically, the monarch is not a citizen or a legal subject of the country over which he or she reigns, so laws and legal rights don't really apply to him or her. The person wearing the crown stands apart from his or her subjects.
A Canadian monarch isn't likely to mount a Charter of Rights challenge demanding the right to freedom of religion, for example.
But the reforms soon up for discussion in Canada's Parliament would be an important symbol of an institution based on bloodlines at least trying to more closely resemble the more merit-based democracy over which it presides.
"The minute you start talking about removing discrimination from the crown — which is inherently discriminatory — it starts becoming weird," admits Philippe Lagassé from the University of Ottawa.
Other parts of the system need revisiting?
Indeed, as British constitutional expert Robert Morris told the committee of British MPs studying the rules of succession last November, it is hard "to infuse logic into a system that isn't logical."
So these changes could open what Northern Ireland's Ian Paisley last week called "a royal Pandora's box." By that, the former leader of the Democratic Unionist party meant that once the first changes come up for debate, other questions will likely emerge about the wider role and entitlements of the Royal Family in 21st-century democracies.
In the case of the U.K., the system also includes inherited titles and property, including the hereditary peerages in the House of Lords, Britain's upper house.
Prince Charles, the first in line to the throne, also has reportedly raised private concerns that the British legislation may have unintended consequences for other titles and entitlements handed down through the male line. (He is also said to be concerned about the change to allow a potential heir to the throne to marry a Roman Catholic.)
The passing on of titles and land across the British aristocracy would not become gender-neutral under the limited scope of this bill, so some feel the reforms don't go far enough.
Removing gender discrimination across the system could help bring more women into the upper house of the British Parliament too. The roughly 10 per cent of seats still allocated to "hereditary peers" in the House of Lords remain male-dominated.
Cue the republicans?
Both inside and outside the U.K., if the public debate doesn't stop at the specific, old-fashioned rules this bill addresses, republicans may see an opening to reconsider the entire system.
Canada's republican movement is not as strong as it is in Australia, but it does exist. While this legislation is intended to be a simple, quick process of making limited reforms, some may want a wider debate.
The Parti Québécois government in Quebec so far has been officially mute on how it feels about the reforms. But in the House of Commons, sovereigntist Bloc Québécois MPs seem unlikely to agree to anything that renews or modernizes the institution of the monarchy, so unanimous consent for the Canadian bill seems unlikely.
That would mean it will likely have to pass through the House of Commons in the usual, stage-by-stage fashion.
Would other republican-leaning MPs also give voice to concerns? What would potential parliamentary committee hearings draw out?
And will the Harper government be forced to set time limits on the bill to keep its commitment to the Commonwealth? British Prime Minsiter David Cameron fast-tracked his government's legislation.
The prime minister's office has said from the start it wants this bill passed "quickly."
Perhaps otherwise, legislation intended to breathe new life into a centuries-old institution may end up giving birth to other changes.
Share Tools
Speaker rules Bezan/Glover case raises prima facie privilege questions by Kady O'Malley Jun. 18, 2013 6:29 PM Conservatives move to shut down debate on motion to send the matter to committee for further study.
Top News Headlines
- G8 leaders agree to 7-point plan on Syria as summit wraps
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the other G8 leaders reach a seven-point plan aimed at stopping the conflict in Syria, wrapping up a two-day summit in Northern Ireland following talks on trade, tax evasion, poverty and terrorism. more »
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- As electronic or e-cigarettes grow in popularity, some health advocates want them to be regulated. more »
- In Bangladesh's garment trade, empowerment comes at $20 a week
- The pay is laughable by Western standards, and the shantytowns of Dhaka offer a difficult life. But the surge of mostly young women into the country's increasingly important clothing industry is having a profound change on this largely Islamic society, Margaret Evans writes. more »
- Tory MP bows to Elections Canada in fight over expenses
- Conservative MP Shelly Glover has bowed to Elections Canada in a battle over her 2011 campaign expenses, days after filing a court challenge against the agency. more »
Must Watch
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Most groups don't want return of Trudeau speaking fees
- Most of the 17 charitable and other organizations that have paid speaking fees to Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau during his time as an MP say they aren't interested in having their fees returned, despite Trudeau's offer on the weekend to reimburse any organization unhappy with his services.
more »
- Tory MP bows to Elections Canada in fight over expenses
- Conservative MP Shelly Glover has bowed to Elections Canada in a battle over her 2011 campaign expenses, days after filing a court challenge against the agency. more »
- G8 leaders agree to 7-point plan on Syria as summit wraps
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the other G8 leaders reach a seven-point plan aimed at stopping the conflict in Syria, wrapping up a two-day summit in Northern Ireland following talks on trade, tax evasion, poverty and terrorism. more »
- Leaders downplay reports of stalled Canada-EU trade talks
- Both Prime Minister Stephen Harper and his British counterpart, David Cameron, downplayed signs of trouble in the Canada-EU trade negotiations Tuesday, even as the European Union's spokesman suggested Canada hasn't shown enough "pragmatism and flexibility" at the table. more »
- MPs and senators' side income provokes ethics debate
- The debate over Justin Trudeau's speaking fees has raised questions about what MPs and senators should be allowed to earn on top of their salaries, with some political watchers urging a wider discussion about financial conduct among parliamentarians. more »
The National
The House
- Senator Tkachuk defends secretive committee's work Jun. 15, 2013 8:03 AM This week on The House, we ask Senator David Tkachuk about Mac Harb taking the Senate to court and Pamela Wallin's explanation for her expenses problems. Plus, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations Shawn Atleo has strong words for the Harper government's approach to First Nations issues. The Aboriginal Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt is here to respond.
- Canadians in Dominican wedding fight freed from jail
- TV chef Nigella Lawson's husband cautioned by police for assault
- Disabled woman's care before dying on bus still a mystery
- Huge ancient city at Angkor Wat revealed by lasers
- Montreal mayor resigns amid corruption charges
- 'Standing man' inspires new, silent protests in Turkey
- Student with bullied past, 'The Doorman,' graduates
- G8 leaders agree to 7-point plan on Syria as summit wraps
- Parents of son 'brutally beaten' playing hockey want charges


