Corrections Canada to drop Ashley Smith inquest challenge
'Stark videotaped evidence' shamed correctional service into decision, Smith family lawyer says
CBC News
Posted: Nov 2, 2012 3:35 PM ET
Last Updated: Nov 2, 2012 8:58 PM ET
Ashley Smith is shown in this still image taken from a coroner's video. The effects of long-term solitary confinement and repeated transfers are among issues that must be explored at an inquest into the death of Smith, a deeply troubled teenager who died in custody after repeated episodes of self-harm, the presiding coroner has decided. (Canadian Press)
Lawyers for Corrections Canada have told Ashley Smith's family they are dropping their challenge to the scope of an Ontario coroner's inquest into the circumstances of her death.
In addition, they will no longer support a challenge against out-of-province doctors being called as witnesses.
Smith was 19 when she choked to death after wrapping a ligature around her neck in a Kitchener, Ont., prison five years ago as guards, who say they had been instructed not to intervene, stood watch outside her cell.
The New Brunswick teen was initially incarcerated as a young offender, but was later transferred to the federal system. In the year before her death, Smith was transferred 17 times between nine institutions across the country.
Canada's correctional service had been arguing that Dr. John Carlisle, who is presiding over the inquest, didn't have jurisdiction to examine how Smith was treated in prisons outside Ontario. The correctional service had also taken the position that the videos shouldn't be played before the coroner's jury.
On Friday evening, the Smith family received a statement from legal counsel for the Department of Justice saying Canada is "withdrawing its submissions regarding the scope of the inquest and the issuance of out-of-province summonses."
Julian Falconer, lawyer for the Smith family, said the move paves the way for parties at the inquest to request summonses for a series of prison managers from outside of Ontario to be grilled over their handling of Ashley Smith.
"This is a huge one for the Smith family and all those who support the search for the truth about Ashley's death," Julian Falconer said.
"It is perfectly clear that the stark videotaped evidence shamed the correctional service into doing the right thing. One wonders what it would take for those doctors who treated Ashley Smith to feel the same sense of shame and allow us to get on with the inquest."
Corrections Canada told to 'co-operate fully'
Candice Bergen, parliamentary secretary to Public Safety Minister Vic Toews, said earlier in the day that the government had instructed Corrections Canada to "co-operate fully with the coroner's inquest" into Smith's death.
"That was our instruction and that's what we expect them to do."
Government lawyers had fought to keep videos depicting the teenager's time in prison from being released.
The screening this week of one disturbing video that shows guards duct-taping Smith and drugging her against her will prompted Prime Minister Stephen Harper to criticize correctional authorities for "unacceptable" behaviour.
There are still hours of videos that remain unseen by the inquest, but Bergen offered no clues as to whether they will be released.
Ashley's mother, Coralee Smith, said in a statement that her family had made a "very hard decision" when they decided "the Canadian public must see what happened to our daughter, so that this can never be allowed to happen again."
"I think about Ashley every day," said Smith, who thanked the public for the support the family received following the initial release of the video of her daughter in custody.
The New Brunswick teenager was first charged with a criminal offence in March 2002, when she was 14 years old. In the following year, she faced charges of causing a public disturbance, trespassing and assault, according to a report from the New Brunswick Office of the Ombudsman & Child and Youth Advocate.She was first incarcerated at age 15 after she threw crab apples at a postal worker. She was convicted of multiple charges of breach of probation, common assault, trespassing and causing a disturbance.
Carlisle's inquest is the second attempt to investigate the teenager's death. The first inquest, led by Dr. Bonita Porter, was halted when the presiding coroner retired.
Smith, who had developed an escalating pattern of self-harm and choking herself while incarcerated, spent much of the last year of her life in segregation.
The current inquest is expected to start calling witnesses in January.
With files from CBC's Dave Seglins and The Canadian PressShare Tools
Power & Politics Ballot Box question by Rosemary Barton May. 24, 2013 4:48 PM Does Rob Ford's statement put an end to the allegations of crack use?
Top News Headlines
- 3 more suspects arrested in slaying of U.K. soldier
- British police investigating the savage killing of an off-duty soldier in London have arrested three more suspects. more »
- Hockey Canada votes to ban bodychecking in peewee hockey
- Hockey Canada's board of directors voted to eliminate bodychecking from peewee-level hockey on Saturday in Charlottetown. more »
- Neil Macdonald: How serious is Obama about curbing the drone surge?
- In a key speech this week, the U.S. president set out a host of supposed new safeguards for America's controversial practice of remote-controlled rough justice. But as Neil Macdonald writes, the underlying rationale for drone use has not fundamentally changed. more »
- Ontario man lost in Australian mountains has survival skills
- The sister of an Ontario man who disappeared in Australia's Snowy Mountains nearly two weeks ago says she remains hopeful he will be found, partly because of his training as a Canadian Forces reservist. more »
Must Watch
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Ethics probe comes with limits, federal watchdog says
- As the federal ethics commissioner readies for a third look at Prime Minister Stephen Harper's former chief of staff Nigel Wright, Mary Dawson is reminding Canadians her office can only look so far. more »
- PM's credibility at stake in growing Senate expenses crisis
- With the prime minister's credibility at stake in a growing political crisis, has Stephen Harper done enough to explain his former chief of staff's $90,000 cheque to Senator Mike Duffy? Listen to CBC Radio's The House with Evan Solomon here. more »
- Wallin may be forced to repay thousands in travel expenses
- Pamela Wallin, the Senator from Saskatchewan, was back in the news this week, refusing to tell CBC News if she had repaid any travel expense money. more »
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford denies using crack cocaine
- The mayor of Canada's largest city told a packed news conference that he doesn't use crack cocaine and isn't a crack addict — and new allegations surfaced Saturday involving Ford's brothers. more »
The National
The House
- Harper's credibility at stake in growing Senate expenses crisis May. 25, 2013 2:21 PM This week on The House, Conservative MP Michelle Rempel and Liberal Senator James Cowan on the Senate expenses scandal. Former chief of staffs Keith Beardsley and David McLaughlin on Nigel Wright's $90,000 gift to Senator Mike Duffy. Plus, Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall on his plea to abolish the Senate. All that and much more!
- McDonald's CEO chastised by 9-year-old B.C. girl
- Will Rob Ford's supporters leave Ford Nation?
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford denies using crack cocaine
- Dog snared on baited hooks near Vancouver's Grouse Grind trail
- Washington police blame bridge collapse on Alberta trucker
- Wallin may be forced to repay thousands in travel expenses
- Canada ranks 3rd last in paid vacations
- 3 more suspects arrested in slaying of U.K. soldier
- Ontario man lost in Australian mountains has survival skills

