Tories under fire for staffing of Ukraine election observers
Two Liberals dropped from bi-partisan group that includes MP whose election was overturned
The Canadian Press
Posted: Oct 19, 2012 10:56 AM ET
Last Updated: Oct 19, 2012 4:08 PM ET
A Conservative MP whose election was overturned due to numerous voting irregularities is being sent as part of a Canadian observer mission charged with ensuring free and fair elections in Ukraine.
And while Ted Opitz will be part of the mission, at least two former Liberal cabinet ministers have been given the boot.
The makeup of the mission is sparking accusations that the Conservative government is compromising Canada's international reputation by injecting domestic partisan politics into its staffing of the 500-member team.
Most observers depart Ottawa on Saturday to monitor Ukraine's Oct. 28 election — a campaign itself marred by corruption charges against the ruling Russian-leaning party.
The selection of Opitz is drawing particular criticism because of the uncertainty that lingers over his own election victory.
The Supreme Court of Canada is to decide whether Opitz was the actual winner of the Toronto riding of Etobicoke Centre in the 2011 federal election over Liberal incumbent Borys Wrzesnewskyj.Conservative MP Ted Opitz, whose election in Etobicoke-Centre was thrown out by a judge due to irregularities, is on a Canadian mission to monitor Ukraine's elections. Opitz appealed the decision. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)
Opitz is appealing a decision by an Ontario Superior Court judge who threw out 79 ballots due to procedural irregularities, nullifying the MP's narrow 26-vote victory.
If the Supreme Court denies Opitz's appeal, he would have to square off against Wrzesnewskyj in a by-election in Etobicoke Centre, which has a large Ukrainian-Canadian population. The top court heard the landmark case in early July and is expected to rule on it soon, conceivably while Opitz is in Ukraine.
While the court case focused on procedural snafus, Wrzesnewskyj has made more serious charges, backed up by affidavits sworn by Elections Canada officials, of voter suppression and intimidation by members of Opitz's campaign team.
None of those allegations has been proven in court.
Opitz played a prominent role last August when Immigration Minister Jason Kenney — the government's political point man on wooing ethnic communities — chose the riding next door to Etobicoke Centre to announce the mission.
Liberals say they were dropped
Meanwhile, former Liberal cabinet ministers Elinor Caplan and David Anderson both received telephone calls earlier this month from Canadem — the independent agency that recruits observers for the federal government — telling them they didn't make the cut as election monitors.
"You don't need to be a genius to figure this out," Caplan said in an interview. "Obviously, this is seen as very political by the government."
Caplan, who served as an observer in Belarus and has taken United Nations courses on election monitoring, said she was asked by Canadem to apply. She did and was notified that she was "good to go," other than the formality of having the minister sign off on her involvement.
Then over the Thanksgiving weekend, Canadem left a message on her home phone advising her that "at the direction of the government of Canada, we've been directed to remove you from the delegation."
She said it appears the government is bumping Liberals while "doing what they can to keep (Opitz) front and centre" with his Ukrainian-Canadian constituents in case he winds up having to fight a byelection.
"It's a pity because, you know, it tarnishes Canada's international reputation ... if the message is we're sending over a partisan, highly unbalanced (delegation) or there are political reasons for who gets selected."
Anderson received a similar telephone call on the same weekend, and was told he was off the team. He said he has questions, given that he's very familiar with the practices and policies of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, a recognized leader in international monitoring.
"I'm happy to apply for these things. But if I'm always going to get blackballed, I'd like to know that too. Whether it's my age, my politics, the colour of my eyes."
As for Opitz taking part in the mission, Anderson said: "It's a curious choice, given the controversy surrounding his election."
Taras Zalusky, the mission's chief of staff, said the selection process "was exactly the same" for this mission as it was when Caplan and Anderson were in cabinet.
"So, it sounds like sour grapes to me," Zalusky said.
Zalusky, who has been involved in two earlier Canadem missions to Ukraine, said 1,500 people applied for the 490 available short- and long-term observer spots. Another 10 are reserved for parliamentarians, chosen by their respective parties.
"The delegation is made up of lots of people with all kinds of expertise," Zalusky said. "There are people who are electoral experts, there are people with language skills, there are people with all kinds of backgrounds."
However, the mission has raised eyebrows, even among some observers, with the disproportionate number of Ukrainian Canadians who've been selected — many of whom, including Zalusky himself, are connected to the Ukrainian Canadian Congress (UCC), an organization that has been highly critical of Ukraine's governing party.
One observer, who asked not to be identified, estimated that 50 per cent of Canada's observers are of Ukrainian heritage.
"It's hard to imagine they're objective," the observer said.
Anderson said it's understandable that the Ukrainian community in Canada tends to be "more hostile to the Russian party," but that makes it problematic for members to serve on a supposedly neutral election monitoring mission.
"They tend to be more on one side. That means that Ukrainian Canadians like any other ethnic group in the diaspora of any country are not necessarily accepted by the home country as unbiased."
Indeed, the diaspora-heavy contingent would seem to be contrary to Canadem's own guidelines for election monitoring missions.
"Regardless of how impartial and professional an observer is, the perception of bias or conflict of interest is a huge challenge, particularly for observers who are returning to their country of origin," Canadem says on its website.
"Therefore, in many situations, election observer missions cannot be staffed by observers who originated from the country in which the election is taking place.
"Regardless of how good they are, local voters will assume that they are not impartial. At a minimum, the standard practice is that the number of country-of-origin observers on an international mission must be relatively small."
All observers are Canadian citizens
Zalusky, who is taking a leave of absence from his job as executive director of the UCC to take part in the mission, dismissed any concerns. "Every single one" of the observers is a Canadian citizen, he said; there are no "new arrivals" from Ukraine.
They have all passed both Canadem and United Nations training courses and must adhere to "a very strict code of conduct on not being biased," he added.
Moreover, Zalusky argued, it's an asset that 40 per cent of Canada's long-term observers, who've been in Ukraine for the past two months, speak Ukrainian or Russian.
"Frankly, when you have people on the ground for two months, in order to catch nuance, in order to be able to understand what's going on in a complex political system like Ukraine — where, as good as they are, interpreters won't catch everything and sometimes they're afraid to translate everything — it's good to have people who actually understand what's being said."
Many have been involved in previous election observation missions to Ukraine, added Zalusky, who previously served as an adviser to Liberal ministers as well as chief of staff to Bev Oda, the former Conservative minister of international co-operation.
"I have every confidence that the Canadian observers know that when they go out in the field that they're representing Canada and that they all behave appropriately," he said.
"The usual suspects are going to complain about this but I can honestly say that Canadem runs a top-rate operation ... They do a first-rate, bang-up job."
Wrzesnewskyj declined to comment on Opitz's involvement in the mission, but he defended the heavy involvement of Ukrainian Canadians.
He took credit for persuading former Liberal prime minister Paul Martin to make use of the diaspora in Canada's first election monitoring mission to Ukraine in 2004, over the objections of Foreign Affairs bureaucrats who worried about objectivity.
Canadem is not involved in choosing the parliamentary contingent. Opitz's office said he'll be accompanied by three other Tories: Manitoba MP James Bezan and Toronto-area MPs Wladyslaw Lizon and Corneliu Chisu.
The New Democrats are sending Toronto MP Peggy Nash, Hamilton MP David Christopherson, Edmonton MP Linda Duncan and Montreal MP Eve Peclet. The Liberals are sending Toronto MP Judy Sgro and Prince Edward Island MP Lawrence MacAulay.
The final list of observers has not yet been released, nor has the head of mission been named. Prime Minister Stephen Harper is to speak today at a public send-off for short-term observers.
CBCNews.ca will have live coverage of Stephen Harper's address to the short-term observers at 2:30 p.m. ET.
- The PMO $100K+ Club:Tories lift veil on staffer salary range by Kady O'Malley May. 22, 2013 11:01 AM Documents reveal 21 staffers make $100,000 or more while nearly as many take in $50,000 or less
Top News Headlines
- Video forensics: How easy would it be to fake a Rob Ford video?
- Two media outlets reported last week that they had seen a cellphone video of Mayor Rob Ford allegedly smoking crack, a claim that has gone global. If a video does surface, how easy would it be to determine its authenticity? CBC News asked video forensic analyst David McKay. more »
- Oklahoma residents begin to return home after deadly tornado
- Rescue workers raced to complete the search for survivors and the dead in the Oklahoma City suburb where a mammoth tornado destroyed countless homes, cleared lots down to bare red earth and claimed 24 lives, including those of nine children. more »
- Xbox One: A closer look
- The design, performance, Kinect camera, controller, requirements and limitations of Microsoft's Xbox One get a critical look. more »
- Over 1 million Montrealers face boil water advisory
- A boil water advisory is in effect for at least 24 hours across much of Montreal. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Wednesdays with @Kady: Senate expenses questions continue
- As Ottawa waits to see whether Prime Minister Stephen Harper takes questions on the Senate expenses scandal in Peru this afternoon, CBC Politics blogger Kady O'Malley is available to answer your questions on the latest controversial developments. more »
- Harper in Peru for trade talks amid Senate expense scandal
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper is meeting with business leaders and Peruvian politicians this morning as part of a four-day trip to South America that will focus on trade and bilateral relations, but is expected to be asked about the growing Senate expense scandal. more »
- Senate sends Duffy expense audit for 2nd internal review
- The Senate decided to send Senator Mike Duffy's audit report back to its internal committee for a second review, despite objections from the Liberal Senate leader, who argued the RCMP should be tasked with the job. New travel rules for senators will be announced today. more »
- Marshall asks Senate committee to review her pay
- Conservative Senator Elizabeth Marshall says she has asked the Senate Rules Committee to look at whether some of the additional pay she receives for additional work is appropriate. more »
- Harper's $100K+ Club: Tories lift veil on staffer salaries
- Documents tabled in the House reveal few aides could afford to cut a $90 K personal cheque to help out an embattled senator. more »
- Questions mount for Harper and chief of staff Nigel Wright in Senate scandal May. 18, 2013 1:15 PM This week on The House, with Senators Wallin and Duffy now out of the Conservative caucus, we get reaction from NDP Ethics critic Charlie Angus. We also hear directly from Senator Patrick Brazeau who says the Conservatives have thrown him under the bus. Plus we speak with B.C. Premier Christy Clark after her stunning victory.
- Video forensics: How easy would it be to fake a Rob Ford video?
- Bosma memorial told, 'Life is precious. Treat it with care'
- Jodi Arias asks for 'second chance' during jail interview
- Oklahoma residents begin to return home after deadly tornado
- Children's mouths allegedly taped shut at N.S. school
- Man being questioned in Boston bombing probe shot dead by FBI
- Judge scolds 'flabby, sad generation' for skipping jury duty
- Yukon couple hold record for longest marriage in country
- Only 1 set of human remains found at Millard farm, police say