Hungarian Roma refugee claimants targeted in CBSA report
Roma community and refugee advocates call report 'racial profiling'
By Louise Elliott, CBC News
Posted: Oct 17, 2012 5:05 PM ET
Last Updated: Oct 17, 2012 5:36 PM ET
An intelligence report completed last year by the Canada Border Services Agency warns of "significant" levels of welfare fraud and other crimes committed by a surging number of Hungarian refugee claimants to Canada.
The report says many of the claims appear to be part of an organized effort to exploit Canada's social safety net.
Refugee advocates and leaders from the Roma community say the report is an example of unfair racial profiling that exaggerates the level of crime and fraud relative to the Roma population, and furthers negative stereotypes based on ethnicity.
The partially redacted report, obtained by CBC News, draws largely on an intelligence operation dubbed Project Sara, which investigated allegations of fraud and criminality among some Hungarian claimants in 2011, most of whom claimed to be ethnic Roma, and the effect of their activities on social services and communities in the Greater Toronto Area.
Commissioned by the head of border services for the region, the report also summarizes data provided by several police departments in southern Ontario, provincial corrections officials, financial institutions and the Ontario Ministry of Community and Social Services, which is responsible for issuing welfare cheques.
Among its findings, the report concludes that Hungarian Roma refugee claimants pose a "significant" risk of committing crimes after they arrive in Canada.
"The information received is not all encompassing, nor is it a depiction of all members of the community, however it serves to demonstrate that there is significant criminal activity occurring within this group."
The report cites several documented examples, including:
- Repeat claims, and claims with altered or falsified names.
- Credit and debit card fraud and the theft of cheques.
- Failed claimants continuing to receive benefits after being deported.
- One case of human trafficking — called the largest in Canadian history — in which 12 Hungarian nationals were charged.
The report also mentions cases where people arrive to claim refugee status and then exit Canada in possession of thousands of dollars in cash as well as goods, including electronics and laptop computers. The report makes no conclusions about the source of the money and goods.
The report does not indicate what proportion of refugee claimants are broadly implicated in such crimes or suspected of crime.
Report denounced as 'racial profiling'
Gina Csanyi-Robah, executive director of Toronto's Roma Community Centre, called the report "classic racial profiling" and the latest example in a flood of negative stereotyping of the Roma in Canada.
"There are a lot of unsubstantiated allegations in this report, very detrimental allegations that are in this report that are misleading," she said. "The vast majority of Roma who have come here seeking asylum in Canada have tried their absolute best to build better lives here and become a part of our society ... not at all to take advantage of the system."
Csanyi-Robah said she's concerned such reports will influence decisions about Roma claimants before the Immigration and Refugee Board.
"There's a huge gap between the reality and the fiction," she said. "You're walking into the room where people already are believing what they're hearing, that you likely are not a bona fide refugee, and that you likely came here just to see what you can get from Canada."
In an email, a spokesperson for the border agency said it is not singling out the Roma.
"The CBSA prepares a variety of intelligence reports, based on changing migration trends that significantly impact Canada’s immigration program," the spokesperson said in the email to CBC News.
But refugee expert Peter Showler argues the report provides little or no evidence for its conclusions.
"It is a badly skewed document," says the former chair of the Immigration and Refugee Board. "It really starts with the presumption that they're fraudulent or invalid claims."
No evidence of organized crime
Showler notes the report documents a tendency of Hungarian claimants to arrive in a family group, and then interprets it as evidence people are trying to get more money from the welfare system (families receive more benefits). He says they could be travelling as a family because the entire family was threatened by persecution, something that has been well documented in countries, such as Hungary, where the Roma face severe discrimination.
The report says there is no evidence that organized crime is involved, but adds "there are indications that once in Canada, Hungarians are working together with other members of their community in the commission of serious offences. They are proving adept at manipulating Canadian systems to obtain the greatest possible financial benefit before returning to Hungary, either voluntarily or with the assistance of the CBSA."
Showler says the report simply doesn't prove it.
"It does make allegations that are completely unfounded.… It does make an allegation that there is a significant amount of minor criminality that occurs. And it offers no data whatsoever to support that allegation."
The report was spurred by a surge in Hungarian nationals claiming refugee status since 2008, when the old visa restrictions were lifted. In 2011 alone, 4,442 Hungarian nationals entered a claim for refugee protection in Canada — representing 17 per cent of the country's total refugee claims that year.
Showler points out that of those claims that received a full hearing at the Immigration and Refugee Board, 20 per cent were accepted as legitimate refugees.
- In His Own Words: Bob Rae on his decision to leave the House by Kady O'Malley Jun. 19, 2013 12:04 PM Read his statement here.
Top News Headlines
- 30,000 Canadians are homeless every night
- A new national report into homelessness in this country tells a grim story — at least 200,000 Canadians experience homelessness in any given year and least 30,000 Canadians are homeless on any given night. more »
- Obesity called a disease by U.S. doctors group
- In order to fight what it described as an "obesity epidemic," the American Medical Association voted to recognize obesity as a disease and recommended a number of measures to fight it. more »
- Neil Macdonald: Washington's obsession with leakers
- Julian Assange and Edward Snowden are just the most prominent targets in an all-out legal and propaganda campaign that America's security apparatus is mounting against leakers everywhere, Neil Macdonald writes. more »
- How open is Ottawa's new 'open data' website?
- Treasury Board President Tony Clement is touting the federal government's revamped data portal as a "new natural resource." But that online window for previously published data arrives at the same time the government faces controversy over just how open it really is. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Bob Rae stepping down as an MP
- Bob Rae, who has represented the Toronto Centre riding for the Liberals since 2008, is stepping down as a Member of Parliament to devote more time to his work as a negotiator for First Nations in Northern Ontario. more »
- MPs take stock as they wrap up spring sitting
- The NDP and Liberals are holding their final caucus meetings today before the summer break and Conservative House leader Peter Van Loan is holding a news conference to highlight what got accomplished in the last few months. more »
- Wednesdays with @Kady: House off for summer, Rae gone for good
- A flurry of sudden deal-making has sprung MPs from a grumpy House of Commons a few days early. Kady O'Malley's final "people's caucus" of the spring sitting follows the three parties' final news conferences before summer break. more »
- Wearing a mask at a riot becomes a crime today
- The bill that bans the wearing of masks or disguises during a riot or unlawful assembly is scheduled to become law today when it gets royal assent. more »
- Senator Tkachuk defends secretive committee's work Jun. 15, 2013 8:03 AM This week on The House, we ask Senator David Tkachuk about Mac Harb taking the Senate to court and Pamela Wallin's explanation for her expenses problems. Plus, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations Shawn Atleo has strong words for the Harper government's approach to First Nations issues. The Aboriginal Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt is here to respond.
- 2 men jailed in Dominican wedding fight back in Canada
- Bob Rae stepping down as an MP
- Half of First Nations children live in poverty
- All-party deal on bills, MP oversight lets House out early
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- Huge ancient city at Angkor Wat revealed by lasers
- Tim Hortons being circled by Wall Street hedge funds
- B.C. teacher duct-taped students' mouths
- Most groups don't want return of Trudeau speaking fees