4 key things to know about today's Supreme Court election case
Canada's top court hears appeal from MP Ted Opitz over 2011 election result
By Laura Payton, CBC News
Posted: Jul 10, 2012 5:03 AM ET
Last Updated: Jul 10, 2012 9:20 AM ET
Conservative Ted Opitz, left, won the May 2011 election in Etobicoke Centre by 26 votes, but Liberal incumbent Borys Wrzesnewskyj succeeded in overturning the result in court citing voting irregularities. The Supreme Court was hearing Opitz's appeal Tuesday. (Canadian Press)
Conservative MP Ted Opitz and former Liberal MP Borys Wrzesnewskyj are facing off in the Supreme Court of Canada today over the House of Commons seat in Toronto's Etobicoke Centre.
Opitz won the riding in the 2011 federal election, but Wrzesnewskyj argued there were clerical errors by Elections Canada that meant some of the ballots shouldn't have been counted. Wrzesnewskyj won a victory in Ontario Superior Court in May, leading to Opitz's appeal to the country's top court.
The Supreme Court is holding a special hearing, outside of its normal schedule, to speed up the legal process. This is the last arena for Opitz to argue to keep his job and for Wrzesnewskyj to make his case for a new election in the riding.
Here are four things you should know about the case:
1. Tuesday's legal arguments
Lawyers for both Opitz and Wrznewskyj will make their cases in the Supreme Court hearing. The top court justices will also hear from interveners who want to make points about the case, including Elections Canada.
Supreme Court cases normally take months, even years, to render a decision. In this case, the court will speed up its normal process, but that could mean the reasons for the ruling won't be released until months later.
2. What the case is about
Wrzesnewskyj, who lost the seat to Opitz on May 2, 2011, says Elections Canada made a number of clerical errors that meant they couldn't prove all the ballots cast came from people living in the riding. If voters arrive at a polling station without a voter identification card, they can sign a registration certificate to swear they live in the area. But some of those registration certificates weren't signed or just didn't exist. In other cases, the workers employed for the writ period by Elections Canada vouched for more than one person, which isn't allowed under the agency's rules.
Ontario Superior Court Judge Thomas Lederer found that 79 ballots shouldn't have been counted because of those errors, and those ballots outnumbered the 26-vote margin by which Opitz won. Because of the number of ballots Lederer threw out, the election result was declared null and void. Opitz is challenging Lederer's decision, arguing those 79 ballots are valid even though mistakes were made at the polls.
Elections Canada has since found that 44 of the voters whose ballots were disqualified were on the National Register of Electors, meaning they are Canadian citizens and qualified to vote. But the documents tabled in advance of the court case have the voters' addresses blacked out, so it's not clear whether they live in the right area to have voted where they did. A code next to the redacted addresses shows almost half of them didn't live in the riding the month before the election.
While Opitz is appealing the lower court's decision, Wrzesnewskyj is appealing some of the findings — that people can vote in the wrong polling division as long as they vote in the right riding, and the decision to allow a set of ballots that Wrzesnewskyj says are from people who voted twice.
3. Ruling could lead to byelection
If the court finds in favour of Opitz and overturns the lower court’s ruling, that would keep the result of the 2011 ballot in Etobicoke Centre. Opitz would remain the MP.
If the Supreme Court agrees with the lower court, Opitz will no longer be the MP for Etobicoke Centre. If the court upholds the Ontario court’s decision, voters will face a byelection, one of three coming up to fill the seats left by departing Conservatives. Calgary Centre MP Lee Richardson and Durham, Ont., MP Bev Oda are both retiring from the House of Commons.
4. A byelection could be 6 months away
If the Supreme Court upholds the Ontario Superior Court decision, the seat will be declared vacant. Prime Minister Stephen Harper has six months from then to announce a date for the byelection. Opitz and Wrzesnewskyj both intend to run to reclaim it.
Mobile users, follow the liveblog here.
With files from Leslie MacKinnonShare Tools
For The Record: Federal Court ruling on robocalls and electoral fraud by Kady O'Malley May. 23, 2013 9:16 PM Read the full decision here.
Top News Headlines
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford fires chief of staff
- A week after bombshell allegations that Toronto Mayor Rob ford was videotaped smoking crack, the mayor's chief of staff was fired and Ford is continuing to stonewall reporters. more »
- Federal Court won't remove MPs over robocall allegations
- The Federal Court says it won't throw six MPs out of their seats over allegations of widespread vote suppression through automated robocalls in the 2011 federal election. more »
- Alleged Ford crack video seller not responding to calls
- The journalist who broke the story alleging Toronto Mayor Rob Ford was recorded on video smoking crack cocaine says he may never be able to get his hands on the evidence. more »
- Bridge collapse on Washington interstate drops cars into water
- The Washington State Patrol says the Interstate 5 bridge over the Skagit River at Mount Vernon has collapsed, dumping vehicles and people into the water. more »
Must Watch
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Duffy says he wants to give Canadians 'the whole story'
- Senator Mike Duffy says he wants a "full and open" inquiry so Canadians can get all the facts about the scandal that has rocked the Senate and the Prime Minister's Office and that he has no plans to resign. more »
- PMO denies Senate appointments on hold pending reform
- A Conservative MP said Thursday the prime minister will not appoint new senators until there is "substantial reform" to the Senate — but a spokesman for Stephen Harper swiftly contradicted the claim. more »
- Duffy expense claims reveal more about campaign travel
- Election spending records show additional days Senator Mike Duffy spent on the campaign trail in the 2011 election, including days he told the Senate he was on business, and days on which Deloitte auditors couldn't track him. more »
- 'Mistaken' Duffy asked Senate committee how much he owed
- Letters between Senator Mike Duffy and Senator David Tkachuk, head of the committee looking into his expenses, reveal that Duffy was at times an active participant in the committee's investigation. more »
The National
The House
- Questions mount for Harper and chief of staff Nigel Wright in Senate scandal May. 18, 2013 1:15 PM This week on The House, with Senators Wallin and Duffy now out of the Conservative caucus, we get reaction from NDP Ethics critic Charlie Angus. We also hear directly from Senator Patrick Brazeau who says the Conservatives have thrown him under the bus. Plus we speak with B.C. Premier Christy Clark after her stunning victory.
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford fires chief of staff
- 2nd suspect in Tim Bosma murder case to plead not guilty
- 2 more arrests linked to hacking death of British soldier
- Duffy says he wants to give Canadians 'the whole story'
- Vancouver man abandons Porsche on B.C. ferry
- Chained-teen's mom wants man who pleaded guilty 'to suffer'
- Montreal lifts boil-water advisory
- B.C. teen saves pet dog in 'terrifying' cougar attack
- Neil Macdonald: Harper no Obama when it comes to dealing with scandals


