CBC releases some records to House committee
By Laura Payton, CBC News
Posted: Nov 14, 2011 12:53 PM ET
Last Updated: Nov 14, 2011 7:07 PM ET
CBC President Hubert Lacroix appears as a witness at a committee in Ottawa on Oct. 25, 2011 to discuss the CBC/Radio-Canada five-year strategic plan. Lacroix said Monday the broadcaster turned over some documents to the House Ethics committee examining its refusal to release some records to a competitor under federal access to information laws. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)
Related
Related Links
- INSIDE POLITICS: Kady O'Malley liveblog of speech by CBC's Lacroix
- INSIDE POLITICS: Law Clerk Rob Walsh's legal opinion
- INSIDE POLITICS: Ethics goes on hiatus
- Tory bid for CBC documents likely unlawful, lawyer says
- INSIDE POLITICS: Ethics committee passes redacted version of Del Mastro order
- Opposition boycotts committee over Tory CBC motion
External Links
(Note:CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external links.)
The CBC has released some of the records requested by MPs looking into its refusal to hand over documents to Canada's information commissioner.
The broadcaster made the move, which it said in a statement is done under protest, as the NDP called on House of Commons Speaker Andrew Scheer to force the committee looking into the battle to halt its study.
The House ethics, privacy and access to information committee passed a motion ordering the CBC to hand over records that are currently the subject of a Federal Court of Appeal battle between the broadcaster and Information Commissioner Suzanne Legault.
On Monday, the CBC provided the committee with two sets of documents, one of them sealed, along with a legal opinion provided to the corporation that concluded it has strong grounds on which to challenge the legitimacy of the committee's request.
CBC president and CEO Hubert Lacroix, in a speech to the National Press Club in Ottawa on Monday, said the CBC sent the documents to the committee after "serious consideration," but decided to seal some of them. Lacroix said a letter sent to the committee clerk sets out the corporation's concerns over "constitutional questions and boundaries," and asks the MPs to read the legal opinion.
Earlier Monday, NDP Justice Department critic Joe Comartin argued the committee is overstepping its boundaries in demanding the CBC release documents while it is fighting a case before the Federal Court of Appeal.
'Overriding legal principle'
A motion by Dean Del Mastro, parliamentary secretary to the prime minister, sparked a study into the broadcaster's unwillingness to release records covered under federal access to information laws to competitor Quebecor, among other requestors.
The information commissioner is fighting in court for the ability to review the documents and determine whether the journalistic and programming exemptions cited are legitimate.
Del Mastro said Monday he's "satisfied that CBC's complied. That's great. Great for Parliament. Great for Canadians."
A legal opinion by parliamentary law clerk Rob Walsh, released over the weekend, explained that MPs have a tradition of avoiding talking about matters before the court so they don't seem to be interfering in cases.
The principle of separation of powers between the judicial and legislative branches of government is important, Walsh wrote.
"In my view, respect for the constitutional framework of our parliamentary system of government is part of the rule of law which is the overriding legal principle that makes a democratic system of government such as ours workable and credible," Walsh wrote.
Basing much of his argument on Walsh's letter, Comartin said he's asking Scheer to direct the committee to end its study or suspend the study until the courts have ruled on the issue. It's possible the case could go to the Supreme Court, meaning no resolution for months or even years.
Committee meetings cancelled
Committee Chair Jean Crowder, an NDP MP, cancelled all meetings until Scheer rules.
"The chair has cancelled the meeting scheduled for [Tuesday] and intends on convening a meeting only after the Speaker has ruled on the point of order raised this morning," Crowder wrote in a memo to committee members.
Lacroix is due to appear at the committee later this month.
Comartin's point of order asking the Speaker to halt the committee's study started a brief debate about the issue.
Accused by Liberal MP Kevin Lamoureux of harbouring a secret agenda against the CBC, Conservative whip Gordon O'Connor said that isn't the case.
"We don't have any secret agenda for the CBC. I watch it quite often. I watch the hockey games and other people watch the hockey games too. So we have no hidden agenda, as suggested by a member of the third party," O'Connor said.
Scheer says it's a longstanding practice that the Speaker doesn't rule until a report is in front of the House, which happens once a committee is finished its study. But he says he will respond to the House "in due course."
This would be Scheer's first major ruling as Speaker. The Conservative MP from Regina was elected June 2 to replace Peter Milliken, who was the longest-serving Speaker in Canadian history.
Canadian Heritage Minister James Moore, whose portfolio includes the CBC, says Del Mastro is looking out for taxpayers.
"The CBC receives a lot of money from taxpayers and our government believes that the CBC, the Wheat Board and other organizations have to be accountable for the money they receive from taxpayers," Moore said.
Share Tools
House of Commons Liveblog: The CP Rail back-to-work bill (#C39) by Kady O'Malley May. 29, 2012 2:46 PM Debate kicks off this afternoon at 3pm and expected to last past midnight.
Top News Headlines
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- The airplane that had its engine shut down and was forced into an emergency landing Monday in Toronto has had two previous documented cases of mechanical damage since it started flying five years ago, according to Transport Canada. more »
- Montreal streets flooded after flash storm
- Flash flooding and popped manhole covers were reported across Montreal as heavy rain blew through the city. more »
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- New census data shows Canada now has a higher proportion of seniors than ever before -- a development that has crept up on society with far-reaching implications for health, finance, policy and everyday family relationships. more »
- B.C. shipwreck survivor recalls 10 days lost at sea
- A Haida fisherman, one of three stranded on a B.C. island for 10 days in May, is now talking about the shipwreck and how he and his friends survived in a driftwood shelter eating little more than seaweed and sea urchins. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Fisheries Act changes questioned by former ministers
- Four former federal fisheries ministers are questioning the government's motives behind the inclusion of environmental protection changes to the Fisheries Act in the Budget Implementation Act. more »
- Robocalls may need regulating, elections chief tells MPs
- Elections Canada may recommend regulating robocalls following 1,100 complaints from the last election, the Chief Electoral Officer told MPs today. He also said the agency is reviewing voter registration rules after results in a Toronto riding were thrown out. more »
- F-35 committee probe stalled, shutting down soon?
- Opposition MPs on the public accounts committee are accusing the government of having something to hide, based on a secret Conservative motion to stop hearing witnesses on the controversial F-35 fighter jet procurement. more »
- Social media websites ignoring privacy laws, watchdog says
- Canada's privacy commissioner said today she is concerned some social media companies are disregarding privacy laws, and called for the federal government to impose stronger penalties when they are breached. more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 28, 2012 3:37 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Possible human foot sent to Conservative Party HQ
- Richard Branson suggests naked kitesurfing to premier
- 'Engine shutdown' forced Air Canada jet to land
- Evolution skeptics will soon be silenced by science: Richard Leakey
- Severe thunderstorms rock eastern Ontario
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- Newly discovered malware most lethal cyberweapon to date
- Alberta couple, child found dead in Saskatchewan ditch

