Veteran alleges another privacy breach at department
CBC News
Posted: Nov 4, 2011 6:02 PM ET
Last Updated: Nov 4, 2011 7:24 PM ET
Medically discharged Corporal Dennis Manuge holds his head as he listens to then-veterans ombudsman Col. (ret.) Patrick B. Stogran speak in Ottawa last August. Manuge says staff at Veterans Affairs Canada and at the minister's office accessed his confidential files unnecessarily. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)
Another veterans' advocate says government officials breached his privacy by unnecessarily going into his medical record hundreds of times, one year after Sean Bruyea settled a similar complaint.
In an interview with Evan Solomon, host of CBC Radio's The House, Dennis Manuge said he decided to look into his own file when he heard Bruyea's complaints. Manuge often appears alongside Bruyea to demand changes to how the government treats veterans, and is leading a class action lawsuit against the government over a claw-back on disability benefits.
Bruyea went public after discovering through requests under federal access to information laws that Veterans Affairs Canada staff had gone into his personal files and put confidential medical information into briefing notes to ministers under both the Liberal and Conservative governments.
Privacy Commissioner Jennifer Stoddart said she found it alarming that officials shared Bruyea's information with seemingly no controls.
Manuge says records show his file was accessed between 900 and 1,000 times from 2002 to 2010. The records end before Bruyea settled his complaint.
"They literally have your entire life on paper. All your medical records, everything that there is, that you’ve disclosed in applications to receive psychological, physical services and benefits from Veterans Affairs Canada," he said.
Many of the people who accessed Manuge's file appear to have done so legitimately, with job titles like client service officer or payment officer, benefits processing.
Manuge says he's looked into between 40 to 100 of the names on the list of people who accessed his file, and wonders why people in Victoria, B.C., Mississauga, Ont., and Winnipeg, were looking at it. Manuge lives in Nova Scotia.
"I have never lived in British Columbia since I've been a client of Veterans Affairs Canada... [There were] hits from members of the Veterans Review and Appeal Board when I had no outstanding appeals," he said.
"People from the minister's office – ministerial inquiries unit [also looked at it]. The title is senior writer. What does a senior writer at the minister’s office have to do looking at my personal medical, psychological, you know, financial information?"
Manuge says he worked out an agreement with a top official at Veterans Affairs and avoided going to the media or filing a lawsuit. He says he had a deal worked out, including a non-disclosure clause.
"A day later my lawyers called me and said, 'no, it went to the Justice Department lawyers and there's no deal. They're essentially, telling us to prove your case before they’ll even consider it'," Manuge said.
"I think four or five months to handle something as serious as this is more than enough."
New privacy measures in place
Sean Casey, the Liberal Party's critic for veterans affairs, said many veterans "suffer great personal tragedy" in the course of their service and should be treated with greater consideration.
Veterans Affairs Canada "has a responsibility to ensure these records are accessed and shared in a manner which is respectful of veterans and their families," Casey said. "If this is brought into question, the onus is on the minister to reassure us all."
Veterans Affairs Minister Steven Blaney said the department has implemented new privacy measures since news of Bruyea's case broke last year.
"Only the person processing the files are in fact in contact with an individual file for purposes that are related to the file, and in that order, we've implemented a new strategy ... although we want to streamline our process, we want to make sure that privacy is of utmost importance for our veterans and that ... confidentiality is the highest priority," Blaney told Solomon.
Blaney says the department has worked with the privacy commissioner on the issue.
"I'm no doctor. I don't need to have, I would say, any diagnosis on any veterans," he said.
Blaney said the only reason he would need access to a veteran's file is if veterans are asking him questions about their case.
Share Tools
House of Commons Liveblog: The CP Rail back-to-work bill (#C39) by Kady O'Malley May. 29, 2012 2:46 PM Debate kicks off this afternoon at 3pm and expected to last past midnight.
Top News Headlines
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- The airplane that had its engine shut down and was forced into an emergency landing Monday in Toronto has had two previous documented cases of mechanical damage since it started flying five years ago, according to Transport Canada. more »
- Montreal streets flooded after flash storm
- Flash flooding and popped manhole covers were reported across Montreal as heavy rain blew through the city. more »
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- New census data shows Canada now has a higher proportion of seniors than ever before -- a development that has crept up on society with far-reaching implications for health, finance, policy and everyday family relationships. more »
- B.C. shipwreck survivor recalls 10 days lost at sea
- A Haida fisherman, one of three stranded on a B.C. island for 10 days in May, is now talking about the shipwreck and how he and his friends survived in a driftwood shelter eating little more than seaweed and sea urchins. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Fisheries Act changes questioned by former ministers
- Four former federal fisheries ministers are questioning the government's motives behind the inclusion of environmental protection changes to the Fisheries Act in the Budget Implementation Act. more »
- Robocalls may need regulating, elections chief tells MPs
- Elections Canada may recommend regulating robocalls following 1,100 complaints from the last election, the Chief Electoral Officer told MPs today. He also said the agency is reviewing voter registration rules after results in a Toronto riding were thrown out. more »
- F-35 committee probe stalled, shutting down soon?
- Opposition MPs on the public accounts committee are accusing the government of having something to hide, based on a secret Conservative motion to stop hearing witnesses on the controversial F-35 fighter jet procurement. more »
- Social media websites ignoring privacy laws, watchdog says
- Canada's privacy commissioner said today she is concerned some social media companies are disregarding privacy laws, and called for the federal government to impose stronger penalties when they are breached. more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 28, 2012 3:37 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Possible human foot sent to Conservative Party HQ
- Richard Branson suggests naked kitesurfing to premier
- 'Engine shutdown' forced Air Canada jet to land
- Evolution skeptics will soon be silenced by science: Richard Leakey
- Severe thunderstorms rock eastern Ontario
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- Newly discovered malware most lethal cyberweapon to date
- Alberta couple, child found dead in Saskatchewan ditch

