ANALYSIS: Horwath, Hudak hold their own in Ontario debate
CBC News
Posted: Sep 28, 2011 6:27 AM ET
Last Updated: Sep 28, 2011 10:08 AM ET
Related
FULL ELECTION COVERAGE
- Ontario Votes 2011
- Latest election-related news and analysis
- CHARTS: Breaking down the Ontario election results
- Ontario school students vote for NDP minority
- Ontario school students vote for NDP minority
- LIVE BLOG: Election campaign
- Tweets and up-to-the minute news from CBC reporters on the campaign trail
- Election promise calculator
- Try your hand at reworking Ontario's finances
They came. They saw. They did not conquer. But then again, no one watching the leaders' debate should have expected that.
There was no knockdown, no 'moment' in the 90-minute debate. Dalton McGuinty, Tim Hudak and Andrea Horwath did land some glancing blows — blows that are unlikely, however, to change many minds.
But it is also true that if you were tuning into the debate and didn't know that Hudak and Horwath were rookies — first timers in that kind of pressure cooker — you wouldn't have known it. Horwath in particular surprised many, even in her own party, with a strong performance that was much improved from the northern issues debate in Thunder Bay last week.
Both opposition leaders had to survive the debate — get into and out of it without a faux pas. If nothing else, they accomplished that, while more importantly introducing themselves to an electorate that is not entirely engaged, shall we say, in this election campaign.
From Hudak there was less of the message track — his forte since becoming leader. He appeared less robotic and seemed to enjoy the experience.
There didn't appear to be one defining moment in Tuesday night's debate. (Frank Gunn/Canadian Press) Horwath clearly won the Miss Congeniality award, which is not a bad thing. But at one point many might have been left wondering: would she relate a story about everyone she's met during this campaign?
McGuinty looked uncomfortable
McGuinty was in his fourth debate as Liberal leader. And while he has clearly improved from 1999, 2003 and 2007, he still looks uncomfortable.
His smirks seem to come in all the wrong places. What's so funny, for example, about bragging about building 18 new hospitals?
And his hand-waving was so pronounced at times they may have actually helped cool down the sweltering makeshift studio in the CBC atrium.
But McGuinty held his own. Not an easy thing to do when under attack from both the other leaders.
There was a risk for the three party leaders in agreeing to a debate this late in the campaign. Especially considering — if the polls are to be believed — this election is still a toss-up. A mistake by any one of the three could have been fatal.
But, having survived, it's now back to the campaign buses for the final push leading up to October 6th.
Each of the three will take something from the debate and use it for the remaining days. Psychologically, that may work to Hudak's and Horwath's favour, since for the first time in this election they appeared as equals to the guy looking for his third majority.
There is little doubt, however, that the smiles on the faces of senior Liberal campaign staff after the debate and on the Liberal bus are an indication they believe the worst is over. That they believe they are heading in the right direction with the right leader.
Then again, if you listen to the spin from the Tories and New Democrats that's exactly what they believe too. Stay tuned.
Share Tools
House of Commons Liveblog: The CP Rail back-to-work bill (#C39) by Kady O'Malley May. 29, 2012 2:46 PM Debate kicks off this afternoon at 3pm and expected to last past midnight.
Top News Headlines
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- The airplane that had its engine shut down and was forced into an emergency landing Monday in Toronto has had two previous documented cases of mechanical damage since it started flying five years ago, according to Transport Canada. more »
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- New census data shows Canada now has a higher proportion of seniors than ever before -- a development that has crept up on society with far-reaching implications for health, finance, policy and everyday family relationships. more »
- RIM shares drop on warning of operating loss
- Shares in Research in Motion Inc. fell eight per cent in after hours trading Tuesday after it announced it would report an operating loss at its next earnings report on June 28. more »
- Alberta couple, child found dead in Saskatchewan ditch
- A married couple and a 2-year-old boy from Airdrie, Alta., have been found dead in a ditch near St. Walburg, Sask. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Fisheries Act changes questioned by former ministers
- Four former federal fisheries ministers are questioning the government's motives behind the inclusion of environmental protection changes to the Fisheries Act in the Budget Implementation Act. more »
- Robocalls may need regulating, elections chief tells MPs
- Elections Canada may recommend regulating robocalls following 1,100 complaints from the last election, the Chief Electoral Officer told MPs today. He also said the agency is reviewing voter registration rules after results in a Toronto riding were thrown out. more »
- F-35 committee probe stalled, shutting down soon?
- Opposition MPs on the public accounts committee are accusing the government of having something to hide, based on a secret Conservative motion to stop hearing witnesses on the controversial F-35 fighter jet procurement. more »
- Social media websites ignoring privacy laws, watchdog says
- Canada's privacy commissioner said today she is concerned some social media companies are disregarding privacy laws, and called for the federal government to impose stronger penalties when they are breached. more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 28, 2012 3:37 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Possible human foot sent to Conservative Party HQ
- Richard Branson suggests naked kitesurfing to premier
- 'Engine shutdown' forced Air Canada jet to land
- Evolution skeptics will soon be silenced by science: Richard Leakey
- Severe thunderstorms rock eastern Ontario
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- Newly discovered malware most lethal cyberweapon to date
- Alberta couple, child found dead in Saskatchewan ditch

