analysisWeston: Taxpayers' AECL losses won't end with sale
By Greg Weston, CBC News
Posted: Jun 29, 2011 12:19 AM ET
Last Updated: Jun 29, 2011 12:28 AM ET
While the federal government is apparently set to sell off its money-losing nuclear reactor business to a Quebec company, Canadian taxpayers will be stuck with the fiscal fallout for years to come.
The government-owned Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. (AECL) is expected to announce this week that it has finally reached a tentative deal to sell its commercial reactor division to engineering giant SNC-Lavalin.
While details of the deal are being kept under tight wraps, the fact the Montreal-based company was the only suitor in the world left at the negotiating table sums up the situation.
Atomic Energy may be world famous for its CANDU reactors, but it hasn’t sold one in 15 years, and now generates mainly massive amounts of red ink, the Crown corporation having cost Canadian taxpayers over $800 million last year alone.
AECL’s refurbishment of the Point Lepreau reactor in New Brunswick is so behind schedule and over budget that the provincial government is now demanding more than $2 billion in compensation.
Under the circumstances, the government believes a good deal to sell AECL doesn’t have to produce a windfall — just stopping the annual bleed would save taxpayers potentially billions of dollars in future.
In the words of Atomic Energy’s president, Hugh MacDiarmid, earlier this year: "It is, in some cases, a bit of a leap of faith that somebody needs to take that we are going to be a company in the future that will enjoy growth, profitability and operational effectiveness."
Taxpayer support
If SNC-Lavalin is taking a leap of faith in buying AECL, it likely won’t be a huge one.
Last year’s losses in AECL’s reactor division alone would have been enough to wipe out the Montreal engineering conglomerate’s global profits several times over.
All of which means that whatever the deal with SNC-Lavalin, Canadian taxpayers are going to remain unwilling partners in the nuclear biz.
For instance, it is all but certain the federal government will have to assume responsibility for settling the multibillion-dollar Point Lepreau refurbishment fiasco.
Then there are all the research and development costs.
AECL says the future of its global business is in the next-generation ACR-1000 reactor, which doesn’t yet exist.
According to AECL’s latest annual report, taxpayers have poured more than $225 million into development of the ACR-1000 just in the past two years.
Will SNC-Lavalin assume sole responsibility (and liability) for completing, testing and bringing the new reactor to market?
Ottawa will guarantee new reactors
And when the first order rolls in for one of those new multibillion-dollar reactors, does anyone believe the sale would or even could be completed without financial guarantees from the Canadian government?
Perhaps the biggest ongoing cost to taxpayers is what’s being left out of the AECL deal —namely, the Chalk River research division that produces isotopes for medical scans and treatments.
The deal splits off Chalk River from AECL’s reactor division that SNC-Lavalin is buying.
Over the past two years, the government has given AECL over $170 million in special funding for the Chalk River research reactor and other facilities that produce nuclear isotopes for medical scans.
Most of that time, the entire operation was shut down for repairs to the isotope reactor, now 54 years old and due to be mothballed barely five years from now.
Even when the Chalk River reactor is running smoothly, supplying half the world’s medical isotopes, AECL still manages to lose about $25 million a year on the operation.
Most of the isotopes produced there are shipped to U.S. medical facilities to treat Americans.
Meanwhile, AECL has spent years and hundreds of millions of dollars at Chalk River building two new isotope reactors that don’t work and likely never will.
Just decommissioning those reactors will now cost taxpayers millions more.
Making matters worse, AECL’s commercial partner in that snafu, MDS Nordion, is now suing the federal agency for $1.6 billion in damages.
Finally, there is the small matter of six decades of nuclear waste at Chalk River, a mess the federal government has now started to clean up.
That shouldn’t cost taxpayers more than an estimated $3 billion.
Share Tools
House of Commons Liveblog: The CP Rail back-to-work bill (#C39) by Kady O'Malley May. 29, 2012 2:46 PM Debate kicks off this afternoon at 3pm and expected to last past midnight.
Top News Headlines
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- The airplane that had its engine shut down and was forced into an emergency landing Monday in Toronto has had two previous documented cases of mechanical damage since it started flying five years ago, according to Transport Canada. more »
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- New census data shows Canada now has a higher proportion of seniors than ever before -- a development that has crept up on society with far-reaching implications for health, finance, policy and everyday family relationships. more »
- RIM shares drop on warning of operating loss
- Shares in Research in Motion Inc. fell eight per cent in after hours trading Tuesday after it announced it would report an operating loss at its next earnings report on June 28. more »
- Alberta couple, child found dead in Saskatchewan ditch
- A married couple and a 2-year-old boy from Airdrie, Alta., have been found dead in a ditch near St. Walburg, Sask. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Fisheries Act changes questioned by former ministers
- Four former federal fisheries ministers are questioning the government's motives behind the inclusion of environmental protection changes to the Fisheries Act in the Budget Implementation Act. more »
- Robocalls may need regulating, elections chief tells MPs
- Elections Canada may recommend regulating robocalls following 1,100 complaints from the last election, the Chief Electoral Officer told MPs today. He also said the agency is reviewing voter registration rules after results in a Toronto riding were thrown out. more »
- F-35 committee probe stalled, shutting down soon?
- Opposition MPs on the public accounts committee are accusing the government of having something to hide, based on a secret Conservative motion to stop hearing witnesses on the controversial F-35 fighter jet procurement. more »
- Social media websites ignoring privacy laws, watchdog says
- Canada's privacy commissioner said today she is concerned some social media companies are disregarding privacy laws, and called for the federal government to impose stronger penalties when they are breached. more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 28, 2012 3:37 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Possible human foot sent to Conservative Party HQ
- Richard Branson suggests naked kitesurfing to premier
- 'Engine shutdown' forced Air Canada jet to land
- Evolution skeptics will soon be silenced by science: Richard Leakey
- Severe thunderstorms rock eastern Ontario
- Air Canada jet with falling debris had previous mishaps
- Canada has higher proportion of seniors than ever before
- Newly discovered malware most lethal cyberweapon to date
- Alberta couple, child found dead in Saskatchewan ditch

