Related
Sandra Finley, seen here in a file photo from 2007, said she's also concerned that Statistics Canada used the services of a U.S. military contractor, Lockheed Martin Canada. (CBC)A Saskatoon woman who refused to fill out a long-form census has been found guilty of violating Canada's census law.
A provincial court judge ruled Thursday that community activist Sandra Finley's privacy rights were not violated by the requirement to fill out the long form in 2006.
It's the same form, containing detailed questions about households that the Conservative federal government now says should not be mandatory.
Finley was charged before the government made that decision.
During her trial, Finley argued the law violated her charter right to personal privacy.
"Some of the questions are like, what is the name of your employer?" she said outside court Thursday. "That's not their business. There's questions ... that have to do with sexual orientation. There's a lot of questions regarding your ethnic background."
Finley also objected to Statistics Canada buying software from U.S. defence manufacturer Lockheed Martin, saying it was "part of the American military industrial complex and that is in the business of making war and illegal war."
Kept confidential
The prosecution argued that census information is kept confidential and that the information is needed to plan services.
Judge Sheila Whelan focused on whether the requirement to fill out the census breaches the section of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms that guarantees freedom from unreasonable search and seizure. She concluded it didn't.
"The evidence before this court was strongly supportive of the conclusion that an appropriate balance has been struck between the societal interest of the individual's dignity, integrity and autonomy and the goal of effective information gathering for statistical purposes," Whelan wrote in a 38-page decision. "I concluded there has not been a breach of Section 8 of the Charter."
Whelan noted that while the court case was going on, Industry Minister Tony Clement said the government "does not believe it is appropriate to force Canadians to divulge detailed personal information under threat of prosecution" — but that didn't dissuade her.
The webpage of Statistics Canada. During her trial, Sandra Finley argued that the mandatory long-form census questions violated her charter right to personal privacy.
(Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press) Finley said she was stunned by the decision.
"Especially when the census long form is no longer mandatory," she said. "Given the actual law as I understand it, I'm just stunned that I'm found guilty. I don't know what the sentence is going to be yet."
Finley is to be sentenced Jan. 20. The maximum sentence for violating the Statistics Act could be three months in jail with a $500 fine.
Finley said she has spent about $10,000 fighting the case, but her fight may not be over yet. She and her lawyer plan to study the written decision before making a decision about what to do next.
Share Tools
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question by Evan Solomon May. 31, 2012 4:51 PM Do the oilsands help or hurt the Canadian economy?
Top News Headlines
- Body parts suspect focus of global manhunt
- Police say intense international media attention on Luka Rocco Magnotta, the suspect in Montreal's grisly suitcase slaying, will make it difficult for him to stay on the lam. more »
- Owner defends 'gore' site connected to Luka Magnotta
- The owner of a website that showcases grisly videos says that his site should be praised for helping identify Luka Rocco Magnotta, who is alleged to be in a video believed to be depicting the stabbing and dismemberment of a man. more »
- Ontario calls joint inquest in aboriginal student deaths
- Ontario's chief coroner will hold a joint inquest into the deaths of seven First Nations teenagers from remote reserves who were living in Thunder Bay to attend high school. more »
- CP trains could be running by Friday
- Striking Canadian Pacific Railway workers could be back at their jobs by Friday afternoon, after legislation to force them back passed the Senate and received royal assent. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Oda says only appropriate travel costs covered
- International Co-operation Minister Bev Oda said Thursday that only appropriate costs for her travel have been paid for by the government but she didn't explain why some claims have been amended from their original amounts. more »
- Budget cuts threaten access to information, watchdog says
- Information Commissioner Suzanne Legault said in a new report released today that the federal government's handling of access to information requests is improving but she still has many concerns, especially in light of budget cutbacks. more »
- NDP MP calls Liberal a 'dishonourable crybaby'
- A closed-door discussion over whether to end the study into Canada's F-35 purchase has led to a verbal battle between the committee's NDP chairman and the sole Liberal member over the rules. more »
- Biden thanks Harper for Afghan funding
- U.S. Vice President Joe Biden called Prime Minister Stephen Harper on Thursday to thank him for Canada's recent commitment to contribute funds to Afghan security forces, the vice-president's office said. more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 30, 2012 4:18 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Edmonton teacher suspended for giving 0s
- Body parts suspect focus of global manhunt
- Owner defends 'gore' site connected to Luka Magnotta
- 5 movie trailers that raise the bar
- Bear pulls corpse from car near Kamloops
- Charest 'disappointed' as Quebec student talks hit impasse
- B.C. double homicide suspect had wealthy upbringing
- Garbage truck lands on Saturn
- Toronto police deny ignoring body parts case tip


