Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Capt. Robert Semrau was accused of killing a severely wounded insurgent in Afghanistan's Helmand province in October 2008. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)Capt. Robert Semrau, a Canadian soldier convicted of disgraceful conduct for shooting a wounded Afghan insurgent in 2008, has been dismissed from the military but will not go to jail.
As part of the punishment handed down Tuesday in Gatineau, Que., Semrau's rank will also be reduced to second lieutenant.
Semrau was accused of firing two rounds from his rifle into a dying Taliban fighter in Helmand province of Afghanistan in October 2008.
A military panel acquitted Semrau on July 19 of murder and attempted murder, over what some have called a mercy killing on the battlefield.
Semrau held a spotless military record until the battlefield incident. The case has raised difficult questions for the military about the conduct of its soldiers and the fog of war.
Lt.-Col. Jean-Guy Perron, the judge who handed down the sentence, chastised Semrau for his actions.
"Shooting a wounded and unarmed person is disgraceful because it is so fundamentally contrary to our values and training that it is shockingly unacceptable," Perron said, adding that "every Canadian soldier is an ambassador of Canadian values."
"Your actions may have been motivated by a sense that you were doing the right thing. Nonetheless you committed a serious breach of discipline," the judge said.
"How can we expect our soldiers to follow the rules of war if their officers do not?" Perron said.
The judge said he could not find a precedent-setting case of a battlefield shooting involving the military of Canada, Australia or the United Kingdom.
Semrau thanks public for support
While Semrau was convicted of disgraceful conduct, the judge ruled that he would not be dismissed in disgrace. That means Semrau can apply to rejoin the Canadian Forces.
Semrau grew up in Moose Jaw, Sask., and was based at CFB Petawawa in Ontario. He is married and has two young children.He was flanked by his wife and other family members as he left the hearing Tuesday without speaking to reporters.
Semrau's defence lawyer, Capt. David Hodson, said his client was very disappointed.
"He's a warrior," said Hodson. "He should be, and would love to be, serving the Canadian Forces and serving his country, but he thanks you all. He thanks the Canadian public for all the support that he has been given throughout the process.
"We still have troops overseas in harm's way. He only asks that you direct your support to those troops who are in harm's way throughout the world," Hodson said.
Lt.-Col. Bruce MacGregor, the director of military justice policy, said the judge sent a message that discipline is the heart of the leadership in the Canadian Forces.
"A leader cannot have those types of actions, which is disgraceful conduct," MacGregor said. "If you are committing a disgraceful conduct, you cannot maintain that rank of leadership, which is the rank of captain."
For his conviction on disgraceful conduct, Semrau had faced a maximum of five years in prison and a dishonourable discharge.
Prosecutors sought a prison sentence of two years less a day and dismissal with disgrace from the Canadian Forces, while Semrau's lawyer had argued for a reduction in rank and a severe reprimand.
Semrau's family and supporters argued it was unfair that he faced prosecution in a courtroom for decisions made on the battlefield.
Share Tools
Orders of the Day - Whither the F-35 inquiry at Public Accounts? by Kady O'Malley May. 31, 2012 9:11 AM Public Accounts committee meets behind closed doors to debate fate of procurement investigation
Top News Headlines
- Oda's staff silent on travel expense changes
- International Cooperation Minister Bev Oda's office is refusing to explain why travel expenses required to be posted on her website have been amended from their original amounts or to answer whether she's paid taxpayers back for any inappropriate expenses. more »
- Quebec students want 'clear' answer to latest offer
- Leaders of Quebec's student associations say they've handed the government a new offer to end the province's months-long crisis over higher education and hope to hear a 'clear' answer on Thursday. more »
- Creating undetectable computer virus 'surprisingly simple'
- Since the Flame computer virus was discovered earlier this week, much attention has been focused on its sophistication. But online security experts say the fact that it went unnoticed for two to five years highlights another problem: the poor state of virus detection. more »
- RIM has make-or-break summer ahead, analysts say
- Canadian technology giant Research In Motion faces a crucial test in the months ahead, telecom and industry observers say, as the company works to bring new devices to market while weathering a slowdown in sales. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Oda's staff silent on travel expense changes
- International Cooperation Minister Bev Oda's office is refusing to explain why travel expenses required to be posted on her website have been amended from their original amounts or to answer whether she's paid taxpayers back for any inappropriate expenses. more »
- NDP Leader Tom Mulcair to visit Alberta oilsands
- Federal NDP Leader Tom Mulcair is getting his first look at the Alberta oilsands on Thursday. more »
- Dogs out-fetch high-tech tools in prison war on drugs
- The Conservative government has spent millions of dollars on sophisticated technology to enforce its "zero tolerance" policy on drugs in federal prisons, but new tools have detected only a small fraction of the narcotics, pills and alcohol seized behind bars, records show. more »
- Mexico wants to increase temporary workers in Canada
- Mexico wants to increase its foreign workforce in Canada, despite the Conservative government's new employment insurance rules that aim to fill vacant jobs with unemployed Canadians instead. more »
- Harper announces hunting and angling panel
- Speaking at the inaugural National Fish and Wildlife Conservation Congress in Ottawa, Prime Minister Stephen Harper announces creation of a hunting and angling advisory panel. more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 30, 2012 4:18 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Body parts suspect the focus of international manhunt
- Body parts suspect may have filmed killing
- Who is Luka Rocco Magnotta?
- How an 11-year-old survived Houla massacre
- Oda's staff silent on travel expense changes
- Donald Trump insists Obama was born in Kenya
- Photos show where abducted Winnipeg kids were kept
- RCMP kill double-homicide suspect in B.C.
- Troubled Air Canada plane dumped tonnes of fuel


