Ottawa anticipated Afghan torture allegations: memo
Last Updated: Monday, March 8, 2010 | 11:50 PM ET
By Gil Shochat, CBC News
Afghan police guard a prison in Kabul in 2004. A Foreign Affairs memo obtained by CBC News confirms the Canadian government had a plan to deal with accusations that prisoners in Afghan custody were being tortured months before such allegations were made publicly. (Musadeq Sadeq/Associated Press)An internal government memo obtained by CBC confirms that Canadian authorities began formulating a plan for dealing with accusations of torture of prisoners in Afghanistan as early as March 2007 — months before such allegations first came up in the media.
The memo, drafted by officials at the Department of Foreign Affairs, instructs staff to inform the Afghan Independent Human Rights Commission and the Red Cross if "NGOs, relatives, media or otherwise make credible allegations that detainees transferred by CF [Canadian Forces] to Afghan authorities have been potentially abused following their transfer."
Officials must also "follow up separately to address potential concerns with the conditions of detention," the memo says.
First drafts of the document were written in March 2007, months before the Globe and Mail reported that 30 prisoners handed over to Afghan authorities by the Canadian military were "beaten, whipped, starved, frozen, choked and subjected to electric shocks during interrogations."
The timing of the memo shows the government was concerned about the possibility that detainees were being abused while in Afghan custody long before revelations about actual cases of abuse became public.
The existence of a plan to deal with allegations of abuse came to light in November 2009 during hearings held by the parliamentary committee examining Canada's mission in Afghanistan and the issue of detainee transfer.
The plan was mentioned in the Nov. 26, 2009, testimony of David Mulroney, the former associate deputy minister of foreign affairs who was responsible for co-ordinating intergovernmental efforts in Afghanistan from 2007 to 2009.
"In mid-March [2007], we began detailed work to create a contingency plan — a standard operating procedure — in the event of well-founded allegations of mistreatment," Mulroney, who is now Canada's ambassador to China, told the committee.
"We did this not because of confirmed instances of real and substantial risk of torture or mistreatment of Canadian-transferred detainees but because it was clear that what we had in place at the time could and should be further reinforced. We needed to be far more engaged in terms of monitoring, training, and providing infrastructure and equipment."
Canada changed its detainee policy
Canadian officials did not start monitoring detainees in Afghan custody until May 2007, when a new memorandum of understanding (MOU) was signed with the Afghan government allowing Canadian officials to visit prisons and track detainees who had been transferred there.
Critics suggest that even though the government changed its policy on detainees, little changed on the ground in Afghanistan.
In his own testimony before the Afghanistan committee, Richard Colvin, a senior diplomat with Canada's Afghan mission, suggested that monitoring remained inadequate even after the new agreement with Afghan authorities.
"The first five months of our new detainee regime, monitoring was done by a succession of officers, some of whom were in the field on short visits of only a couple of weeks," Colvin testified in November 2009. "Despite the new MOU … some of our detainees continued to be tortured after they were transferred."
It was Colvin who reinvigorated the debate over Canada's role in the torture of prisoners in Afghanistan with his testimony before the House of Commons committee. The former diplomat told the committee that all detainees transferred by Canadians to Afghan prisons were likely tortured by Afghan officials and that many of the prisoners were innocent.
Share Tools
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question by Evan Solomon May. 31, 2012 4:51 PM Do the oilsands help or hurt the Canadian economy?
Top News Headlines
- Body parts suspect focus of global manhunt
- Police say intense international media attention on Luka Rocco Magnotta, the suspect in Montreal's grisly suitcase slaying, will make it difficult for him to stay on the lam. more »
- Owner defends 'gore' site connected to Luka Magnotta
- The owner of a website that showcases grisly videos says that his site should be praised for helping identify Luka Rocco Magnotta, who is alleged to be in a video believed to be depicting the stabbing and dismemberment of a man. more »
- Ontario calls joint inquest in aboriginal student deaths
- Ontario's chief coroner will hold a joint inquest into the deaths of seven First Nations teenagers from remote reserves who were living in Thunder Bay to attend high school. more »
- CP trains could be running by Friday
- Striking Canadian Pacific Railway workers could be back at their jobs by Friday afternoon, after legislation to force them back passed the Senate and received royal assent. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- Oda says only appropriate travel costs covered
- International Co-operation Minister Bev Oda said Thursday that only appropriate costs for her travel have been paid for by the government but she didn't explain why some claims have been amended from their original amounts. more »
- Budget cuts threaten access to information, watchdog says
- Information Commissioner Suzanne Legault said in a new report released today that the federal government's handling of access to information requests is improving but she still has many concerns, especially in light of budget cutbacks. more »
- NDP MP calls Liberal a 'dishonourable crybaby'
- A closed-door discussion over whether to end the study into Canada's F-35 purchase has led to a verbal battle between the committee's NDP chairman and the sole Liberal member over the rules. more »
- Biden thanks Harper for Afghan funding
- U.S. Vice President Joe Biden called Prime Minister Stephen Harper on Thursday to thank him for Canada's recent commitment to contribute funds to Afghan security forces, the vice-president's office said. more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 30, 2012 4:18 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Edmonton teacher suspended for giving 0s
- Body parts suspect focus of global manhunt
- Owner defends 'gore' site connected to Luka Magnotta
- 5 movie trailers that raise the bar
- Bear pulls corpse from car near Kamloops
- Charest 'disappointed' as Quebec student talks hit impasse
- B.C. double homicide suspect had wealthy upbringing
- Garbage truck lands on Saturn
- Toronto police deny ignoring body parts case tip


