Government wanted quick Afghan detainee transfers
Afghan officials refused to take detainees between July and October
Last Updated: Thursday, December 3, 2009 | 10:09 PM ET
CBC News
Related
In depth: Afghan detainees
Features
- Who's who: Officials named in Colvin's testimony
- Timeline: Afghan prisoner transfers
- Background: Afghan detainees
- Blog coverage: Inside Politics
- Background: The history of law surrounding torture
- Audio interview: Helen Colvin on her son's experience (8:33)
Analysis
Key developments
Political prisoners are kept in a special wing at Sarposa prison in Kandahar, Afghanistan. (Dene Moore/Canadian Press) Canada's top two commanders in Afghanistan in spring 2006 told investigators the government pressured them to transfer detainees to Afghan authorities faster than they felt was appropriate, CBC News has learned.
Investigators for the military police complaints commission interviewed Brig.-Gen. David Fraser and Lt.-Col. Tom Putt, who both described the government as being obsessed with speed when it came to the transfer of Afghan detainees, according to transcripts of those interviews obtained by CBC News.
Commanders in Canada wanted detainees handed over within 12 hours — faster, in most cases, than soldiers in the field could process them.
The first three Afghan detainees captured by Canadian troops in Kandahar province were taken April 6, 2006. After being on the receiving end of a Canadian attack, they needed medical care and, according to military orders, to be questioned and eventually transferred to Afghan authorities.
All of this usually happened within 96 hours — too slow for the government, according to Fraser's and Putt's accounts to investigators examining allegations of abuse of Afghan detainees.
The moment a detainee was captured, Fraser said, he had to notify his boss in Ottawa, Lt.-Gen. Michel Gauthier.
"As soon as I got a detainee, I would phone him," Fraser said, adding the question he got back was: "How fast could we get them to hand over to the Afghan authorities?"
Fraser, who was in charge of Canadian troops in Afghanistan in 2006, said the question puzzled him because he didn't understand the need for speed.
Neither did Putt, who was Fraser's deputy and the commander responsible for the handling of detainees. He said the government's unofficial goal for transfer was 12 hours.
But it was difficult to get the prisoners back to base in Kandahar and they often required medical treatment, all of which took time.
Putt said he resisted Ottawa's calls for speed, sometimes because it was difficult to find an Afghan authority for the transfer.
"We took a bit of heat on that from Ottawa," Putt told investigators. "' Move, move, move,' [but] we can't. … There's no one to hand them off to in the police station, you know?"
Both Putt and Fraser said the military's interest in detainees ended as soon as the prisoners were transferred. The military didn't monitor their condition — that was not its jurisdiction, Fraser said.
And the government's position was that monitoring detainees was an Afghan problem.
"It's their country, it's their elected government, it's their security forces, and if we can't, you know, hand [detainees] off to them, then you know, why are we here?" Putt said.
Richard Colvin, a former senior diplomat with Canada's mission in Afghanistan, testifies at a parliamentary committee in Ottawa in November. (Chris Wattie/Reuters) It wasn't until a full year after Canada started transferring detainees that the government started monitoring their treatment. In the meantime, it has been alleged that many had been abused — possibly even tortured.
Richard Colvin, a former senior diplomat with Canada's mission in Afghanistan, told a parliamentary committee last month that all detainees transferred by Canadians to Afghan prisons were likely tortured by Afghan officials.
He also said his concerns were ignored by top government officials and that the government may have tried to cover up the issue.
The government denies the allegations, saying the majority of them are baseless and made by the Taliban.
Putt's testimony also suggests Canadian troops frequently weren't capturing high-value Taliban targets — an assertion Colvin first raised two weeks ago.
"I mean, we were basically capturing a local yokel, " Putt said. "Detaining the local yokels and handing them off."
Meanwhile, for at least a few weeks this past summer, the Afghan Intelligence Service refused to accept any detainees transferred by Canadian Forces in Afghanistan.
The decision was made between July and October and affected the transfer of every prisoner captured by a Canadian soldier anywhere in Afghanistan, no matter the crime.
Late Thursday, the Canadian Forces confirmed to CBC News that transfers were suspended because of Afghan complaints about the quality of evidence provided by Canadian troops and the inability of Afghan prosecutors to use that evidence in judicial proceedings.
The complaints apparently found their way to Amruallh Saleh, head of the National Directorate of Security in Kabul, who issued the order to refuse any more Canadian-transferred detainees.
"They asked us to pause," said Lt.-Col. Chris LeMay, a spokesman for the Canadian Expeditionary Force Command in Ottawa. "It was related to evidence issues. The pause lasted a few weeks."
William Crosbie, Canada's ambassador to Afghanistan, met with Saleh in September and was able to have the Afghan decision reversed, but not before weeks of frustration among Canadian troops on the ground in Kandahar.
With files from James Cudmore, CBCShare Tools
Liveblog: Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks to the National Fish and Wildlife Conservation Congress by Kady O'Malley May. 30, 2012 6:10 PM Event sponsored by Canadian and American conservation groups
Top News Headlines
- Troubled Air Canada plane dumped tonnes of fuel
- An Air Canada passenger jet that was forced to make an emergency landing in Toronto likely dumped many tonnes of fuel over Lake Ontario before the aircraft touched down safely, according to an aviation expert. more »
- Photos show where abducted Winnipeg kids were kept
- CBC News has obtained photos showing the inside of the home where Abby and Dominic Maryk were held in Guadalajara, Mexico, after they went missing nearly four years ago. more »
- 'Gay-straight alliance' name forces debate in Ontario

- Ontario politicians are debating legislation on bullying in schools, while the province's Catholic bishops object to using the name "gay-straight alliance." more »
- RCMP kill double-homicide suspect in B.C.
- The suspect in a Metro Vancouver manhunt has died in hospital after being shot in a standoff with police in Maple Ridge. more »
Latest Politics News Headlines
- 'Oilsands fever' seen as Canada's Dutch Disease
- On the eve of NDP Leader Tom Mulcair's visit to Alberta's oilsands, two new reports offer competing evidence about his claim that Canada's economy suffers from a high dollar driven by the resource sector. more »
- Canadian wine may flow more freely if MPs get their way
- A proposal by a B.C. backbencher to allow Canadians to buy wine outside their province is being rushed through the House after a squabble over which party most supports local wineries. The bill could become law as early as this summer. more »
- Calgary MP Lee Richardson quits for a job with Redford
- Conservative MP Lee Richardson announced Wednesday that he's stepping down as the representative for Calgary Centre and taking a job with Alberta's premier Alison Redford. more »
- Wednesdays with @Kady replay: Mulcair and 'oilsands fever'
- On Wednesdays, CBCNews.ca's Politics blogger convenes a "people's caucus" to discuss and debate the issues of the week. Today: Mulcair heads to the oilsands, plus your thoughts on that severed foot mailed to Tory headquarters more »
The National
The House
- Qc students open the door to compromise May. 30, 2012 4:18 PM This week on The House, Evan Solomon explores the ongoing student protests in Quebec. The conflict that began as a disagreement between certain student associations and the provincial government over tuition hikes seems to have morphed into something larger. Evan talks to Leo Bureau-Blouin, the president of Quebec's College Student Federation, about the ongoing dispute. Then, Quebec's Finance Minister Raymond Bachand talks about what it will take to resolve the conflict, and if an election is the only solution.
- Body parts suspect may have filmed killing
- Donald Trump insists Obama was born in Kenya
- Police find 2nd body part after foot mailed to Tory HQ
- RCMP kill double-homicide suspect in Maple Ridge, B.C.
- B.C. seniors devastated as homes face bulldozer
- Alberta couple, child found dead in Saskatchewan ditch
- Troubled Air Canada plane dumped tonnes of fuel
- Photos show where abducted Winnipeg kids were kept
- 'Gay-straight alliance' name forces debate in Ontario

