Analysis

Hillary Clinton dominates Republican convention, now time for her own show: Michael Enright

There is an amazing twist of high irony in this: the most dominating, ubiquitous political presence at a Republican National Convention was the Democratic presidential nominee. Hillary Clinton was everywhere. And nowhere. Now she prepares for her own convention, which Democrats hope will be a stark contrast from the Republicans' chaos in Cleveland.

Democrats look to put on a smooth convention in Philadelphia to contrast with the chaos in Cleveland

A delegate wearing a mask of Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton, as well as handcuffs and a prison jumpsuit, appears on the convention floor before the start of the final day of the Republican National Convention in Cleveland. (Reuters)

There is an amazing and unprecedented twist of high irony in this: the most dominating, ubiquitous political presence at a Republican National Convention was the Democratic presidential nominee.

Hillary Clinton was everywhere. And nowhere.

No corporeal presence, but heated discussions of her character, her personality and her personal and public history wafted in the air of the Quicken Loans Arena in Cleveland like machine-made fog.

Speaker after speaker focused their venom entirely on the former first lady, former senator and former secretary of state.

In a 10-minute speech, one orator used Trump's name twice and Clinton's 24 times.

And at most mentions and allusions to Clinton, the red meat Republican delegates in the funny hats chanted: "Lock Her Up! Lock Her Up!"

'Guilty or not guilty?'

New Jersey Governor Chris Christie, a former prosecutor, actually called his speech an indictment and urged the jury of delegates to render a verdict.

"Guilty or not guilty?" he intoned after each charge.

"Guilty!" the delegates screamed in response.

The crowd was almost biblical in its wrath, with the governor relishing his role as Pontius Pilate.
New Jersey governor speaks at Republican convention 1:47

It is a rare thing in modern American politics to have the faithful of one party accuse the next leader of the rival party of everything from perjury to criminal negligence to high treason.

A New Hampshire delegate and Trump adviser called for Clinton's death by firing squad, which prompted some Secret Service attention.

Name-calling in American politics is an old and honoured tradition. Politicians have called each other idiots, wing nuts, lunatics. The right wing uses "liberal" as a slur.

A Texas Republican once described Governor Rick Perry as "George Bush without the brains."

It's one thing to call an opponent a moron. It's quite another to call a former secretary of state a promoter of al-Qaeda.
Hillary Clinton was the top topic at the Republican National Convention in Cleveland. (Reuters)

This was a convention short on detailed policies. It almost seems that absent the unrelenting attacks on Clinton, the Republicans in the Q wouldn't have had much to talk about.

Most of the speeches were creaking, rehashed Republican boilerplate: law and order, respect for the cops, bloated government, tougher immigration laws, lower taxes, fear of terrorists on Main Street.

Quadrennial presidential conventions have several missions.

The first, of course, is to nominate a presidential ticket to fight an election.

They are also meant to showcase the nominee to the great audience beyond the arena.
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump delivered a very long speech on Thursday night. (John Moore/Getty Images)

For the presidential nominee, the mission is to energize the party's base and project to the wider world of independent voters a sense of steadfastness and serious purpose.

In the late evening Thursday, Donald Trump tried to do just that in one of the longest acceptance speeches in convention history.

It would be torturing reason to suggest Mr. Trump sounded presidential in the traditional sense, but he did seem more measured and coherent given the context of such a chaotic convention.
Donald Trump proclaims 'things have to change and things are going to change right now.' 1:05

True, his picture of the United States as a wildly violent, dark and fallen empire was over-the-top, but then most of Donald Trump's life is lived over-the-top.

Divisions remain

Despite what his handlers and the leaders of the Republican Party say, the GOP leaves Cleveland a deeply divided party.

Many delegates suggested they had come to the convention because that's what party loyalists do; not, they said pointedly, because of any overwhelming love of Donald Trump.

One young delegate from Utah I spoke to said she has grave reservations about Trump, especially about some things he has said about gender and race.

She had hoped this week would solidify her thoughts about her party's nominee. She came to Cleveland seeking clarity and left as confused as ever. She said she'll decide how to vote in November.

On Monday, the Democrats open their convention in Philadelphia. On Thursday, Hillary Rodham Clinton will accept her party's nomination, the first time in American history a woman will run for president as the leader of a major party.

'Dumpster fires'

She will join Donald Trump as the two least popular presidential candidates in anybody's memory.

As Tea Party Senator Ben Sasse of Nebraska puts it: "I have dumpster fires in my town more popular than these 'leaders.'"

Clinton's vanquished rival, Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders, actually has a positive rating. 

What delegates and media will look for in Philadelphia is a well-organized, well-run convention to contrast with the chaos of Cleveland. Also of major interest is what Sanders will tell his loyalists in prime time on Monday night.

And they can look forward to one other thing.

Donald Trump has promised a major rally in Philadelphia on Friday.

About the Author

Michael Enright

Host, The Sunday Edition

Michael Enright is the host of The Sunday Edition and Rewind on CBC Radio One. During his long career as a journalist, he has hosted other CBC Radio flagship shows, including This Country in the Morning, As It Happens and This Morning. He is the recipient of two honorary doctorates and the Order of Canada.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.