The federal government says its proposed prostitution legislation will crack down on pimps and johns, but advocates for sex-trade workers say it will criminalize prostitution and land sex workers in jail.
Bill C-36, dubbed the protection of communities and exploited persons act, would make it illegal to sell sexual services in public spaces where persons under the age of 18 could be present. Offenders could face a maximum of five years in prison.
"Today our government is making prostitution illegal for the first time," Justice Minister Peter MacKay said in a written statement on Wednesday.
- ON MOBILE? Read the bill here
- STORIFY: Your Twitter reaction to the prostitution bill
- Prostitution survey finds support for making selling sex legal
- Supreme Court strikes down Canada's prostitution laws
"We are criminalizing the purchase of sexual services and in very specific instances the sale … in areas where young people under the age of 18 could be present," MacKay said during a news conference after the bill was tabled in the House of Commons.
The justice minister said the bill would target johns and the pimps who sell and profit from prostitution, rather than the prostitutes themselves.
"The bill recognizes that the vast majority of those who sell sexual services do not do so by choice. We view the vast majority of those involved in selling sexual services as victims," MacKay said.
While MacKay said the aim of the bill is not to target prostitutes, he said they could face prosecution if found to be selling their services in public spaces where minors could be present.
"They would face fines in most instances," MacKay said.
The bill, which MacKay has described as a "made-in-Canada" model, would also:
- Criminalize the advertising of sexual services in print or online, with offenders facing a maximum prison term of five years.
- Increase the penalties related to child prostitution.
- Provide $20 million to fund programs to help sex workers get out of prostitution.
Sex workers' safety should be priority, NDP says
The new bill comes just two days after the Justice Department released the results of an online consultation that showed two-thirds of the more than 31,000 respondents said selling sex should not be an offence.
The proposed legislation is the government's response to a Supreme Court of Canada ruling in December, which found the country's prostitution laws unconstitutional.
The top court struck down key provisions including laws prohibiting brothels, living on the avails of prostitution and communicating in public with clients, saying the laws were too broad and "grossly disproportionate."
The Supreme Court gave the federal government one year to come up with new legislation.
Katrina Pacey, a lawyer for Pivot Legal Society, an intervener in the case to reform the country's anti-prostitution laws, has concerns about the proposed legislation.
"This is in fact full criminalization of prostitution ... which is going to result in sex workers going to jail."
"The minister has found various ways to limit all of the safe ways for sex-trade work," Pacey said.
Robyn Maynard, an outreach worker for Stella — a group in favour of decriminalizing prostitution — said the proposed legislation was "very alarming."
In an interview CBC News Network's Power & Politics, Maynard said "what this actually does is it really seems to put sex workers in the same dangers that they've been facing for decades."
MacKay said, "No model that involves full decriminalization or legalization will ever make prostitution a safe endeavour.”
NDP justice critic Françoise Boivin said she had reservations about the bill and whether it would ensure the safety of sex workers.
"That should be our No. 1 priority," Boivin said adding that "I'm not sure this piece of legislation does that."
Boivin said she would study the bill and consult with legal experts and sex workers before commenting further.
Liberal MP Carolyn Bennett worried the new bill would not stand up to constitutional scrutiny.
Appearing on a panel on CBC News Network's Power & Politics, Bennett said, "We're very concerned that it may not meet the test that the Supreme Court put forward in terms of the health and safety of women."
The Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police commended MacKay for seeking public input and for providing new funding.
"Members agree that preventing victimization and exploitation of those selling sex, and allocating funding for support programs to assist vulnerable individuals, as well as preventing community harm, are key priorities," the chiefs of police said in a written statement.
You can read the text of the bill below.