Canada returns seized Phoenician artifact to Lebanon

Federal officials have returned a tiny glass image of a man's head, dating from circa 600 BC, to Lebanon almost a decade after it was seized from an antiquities dealer in Montreal. The rare Phoenician object has been in limbo as diplomats, art experts and the courts sorted out its fate.

Ancient pendant seized by customs officers in Montreal in 2006 returns home to Lebanon a decade later

A glass Phoenician pendant dating from 600 BC has been returned to Lebanon after being seized by Canadian border officers in Montreal a decade ago. (Canadian Heritage)

Canada has returned an ancient glass pendant to its home in the Middle East, a decade after it was seized from an antiquities dealer in Montreal.

The tiny Phoenician pendant, dating from circa 600 BC, was seized by Canadian border officers in 2006, and the artifact has spent 10 years in limbo while art experts, politicians, diplomats and the courts sorted out its rightful home.

A Federal Court judge finally ruled in May this year that the pendant should be returned to the government of Lebanon, its country of origin, under a 1970 UNESCO convention that requires cultural property to be repatriated if it was exported illegally.

The National Museum of Beirut will add the Phoenician pendant to its collection. (Mohamed Azakir/Reuters)

And so in a small, private ceremony in Ottawa in late July, the red-and-black glass image of a bearded man's head was turned over to the chargé d'affaires of the Lebanese Embassy.

The return of the pendant, no bigger than a fingertip and estimated to be worth about $1,000 in the antiquities trade, marks the 20th time that Canada has acted under the 45-year-old UNESCO convention.

The glass pendant was taken from Allan Anawati, owner of Medusa Ancient Art Inc. in Montreal, by border officers on Nov. 27, 2006.

Seized under Customs Act

"An expert at the Montreal Museum of Fine Arts was consulted on its origin and authenticity," says a briefing note obtained under the Access to Information Act from the Canadian Heritage Department.

"The expert indicated that it was authentic, dated to the sixth century BCE and originated from the larger Syrian Empire (which includes the modern state of Lebanon)."

On May 14, 2007, the Lebanese Ministry of Culture formally requested the pendant's return, and the Canada Border Services Agency officially seized the object under the Customs Act, and eventually referred the matter to Canadian Heritage.

The department then went to Federal Court for a judge's order. Anawati declined to challenge the application.

A stolen medieval sculpture of a parrot lady is officially returned to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in April by Prime Minister Stephen Harper. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)
"In light of the low value of the pendant, legal fees would not justify further efforts toward this dispute," Anawati said in an email to CBC News, declining further comment.

Judge Luc Martineau then issued the order in May this year, with no compensation or legal costs granted to Anawati. The handover was made July 28 at the Canadian Conservation Institute in Ottawa, the first time Canada has returned a cultural object to Lebanon under the convention.

Sami Haddad, chargé d'affaires at the Lebanese Embassy, recently took the pendant to Beirut, where it will eventually go on display in the National Museum of Beirut after an official event in a few weeks marking the return.

"This is a very important antiquity," Haddad said in an interview. "Glass wasn't known around the world and the Phoenicians invented it.… We are very appreciative of all the efforts that were done on the Canadian side."

In April this year, Prime Minister Stephen Harper returned a 12th-century sculpture of a parrot lady to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in a ceremony in the Library of Parliament, a repatriation also under the UNESCO convention. The sculpture, believed to have been stolen, turned up in Canada in 2011.

Follow @DeanBeeby on Twitter

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.