With the government threatening to invoke closure on a bill to legislate
an arbitrator-imposed end to the standoff at Canada Post, is the
Commons Chamber fated to play host to the world's most partisan
pyjama party on Thursday night?
Not necessarily.
Earlier today, the government gave notice that it intends to use the one remaining let's-get-on-with-it tool at its disposal: a motion of closure, or, in this case, a motion to bring closure on a de facto closure motion -- a near palindromic procedural trick that would instantly limit further debate on the motion -- which, of course, would impose a one-day deadline on the back to work legislation. (Why not just move closure on the bill, and skip the middle motion? Because one can only move closure on a matter on which debate has been adjourned at least once, that's why.)
Once moved, the standing orders prescribe just 30 minutes to debate such a motion, during which members "may put brief questions to the Minister responsible for the item subject to the motion of closure or to the Minister acting on his or her behalf." Factor in another 30 minutes for the bells, and the back-to-work bill could be ready for its second reading close-up by noon.
At that point, the battle will effectively be over, as the motion -- the original motion to limit debate, just to be clear* -- stipulates that all votes required to dispose of the matter be held before the House adjourns for the day -- and, in this instance, for the summer.
The opposition parties can, of course, keep the debate alive for as many hours as they can muster up members to speak on the bill -- through the night, and into the following day, even. Except that in this case, the following day is June 24 -- Saint-Jean-Baptiste Day, AKA La Fête nationale du Québec, and one of the few statutory holidays that a Quebec politician -- especially a newly elected MP -- would be ill advised not to celebrate publicly.
In any case, given the timing, it seems more likely that the NDP will put up just enough of a fight to assuage its collective conscience, while still ensuring that the 60-odd members of its Quebec caucus make it back to La Belle Province to partake in their respective local festivities.
*(Yes, "closure", not "cloture". No, I don't know why we went with the phonetic spelling. I'm a process wonk, not a parliamentary etymologist.)
Not necessarily.
Earlier today, the government gave notice that it intends to use the one remaining let's-get-on-with-it tool at its disposal: a motion of closure, or, in this case, a motion to bring closure on a de facto closure motion -- a near palindromic procedural trick that would instantly limit further debate on the motion -- which, of course, would impose a one-day deadline on the back to work legislation. (Why not just move closure on the bill, and skip the middle motion? Because one can only move closure on a matter on which debate has been adjourned at least once, that's why.)
Once moved, the standing orders prescribe just 30 minutes to debate such a motion, during which members "may put brief questions to the Minister responsible for the item subject to the motion of closure or to the Minister acting on his or her behalf." Factor in another 30 minutes for the bells, and the back-to-work bill could be ready for its second reading close-up by noon.
At that point, the battle will effectively be over, as the motion -- the original motion to limit debate, just to be clear* -- stipulates that all votes required to dispose of the matter be held before the House adjourns for the day -- and, in this instance, for the summer.
The opposition parties can, of course, keep the debate alive for as many hours as they can muster up members to speak on the bill -- through the night, and into the following day, even. Except that in this case, the following day is June 24 -- Saint-Jean-Baptiste Day, AKA La Fête nationale du Québec, and one of the few statutory holidays that a Quebec politician -- especially a newly elected MP -- would be ill advised not to celebrate publicly.
That is, of course, assuming that the government waits until Thursday to trigger the closure process. If they really want to ensure that the House rises for its summer break without any risk of setting the NDP off on a possible flight-delaying filibuster, they could simply push off the final opposition day to Thursday, and wrap up the back-to-work legislation tomorrow.
In any case, given the timing, it seems more likely that the NDP will put up just enough of a fight to assuage its collective conscience, while still ensuring that the 60-odd members of its Quebec caucus make it back to La Belle Province to partake in their respective local festivities.
*(Yes, "closure", not "cloture". No, I don't know why we went with the phonetic spelling. I'm a process wonk, not a parliamentary etymologist.)
More Stories under Politics
- How was the Mike Duffy report 'whitewashed?' May 23, 2013 2:11 PM ET — Liberals in the Senate and the House of Commons are pushing the government to explain who was behind the decision to edit an original Senate… 2:11 PM ET
- Duffy letters show correspondence with Senate over expenses May 23, 2013 1:50 PM ET — Letters between Senator Mike Duffy and Senator David Tkachuk, head of the committee looking into his expenses, reveal that Duffy was at time… 1:50 PM ET
-
Neil Macdonald: Harper no Obama when it comes to dealing with scandals May 23, 2013 7:39 AM ET — Beset by three so-called scandals at the moment, Barack Obama has been meeting his accusers and the press head on, Neil Macdonald writes. Th…
7:39 AM ET
About the Author
Other Inside Politics Entries
- Elections Commissioner won't investigate US political consultant for hitting the 2011 campaign hustings with two Conservative candidates
- Orders of the Day - Back to you, Supreme Court of Canada! (On copyright, not Etobicoke Centre, that is.)
- Storify'd: Tony Clement wades into the Great Cuba vs. China Communism Debate
- NDP Ad Watch: Is this the voice of a deputy opposition leader?
- Orders of the Day - Grind faster, wheels of (Supreme Court of Canada) justice!
Archives »
- 2012 (380)
-
July (19)
- Elections Commissioner won't investigate US political consultant for hitting the 2011 campaign hustings with two Conservative candidates
- Orders of the Day - Back to you, Supreme Court of Canada! (On copyright, not Etobicoke Centre, that is.)
- Storify'd: Tony Clement wades into the Great Cuba vs. China Communism Debate
- NDP Ad Watch: Is this the voice of a deputy opposition leader?
- Orders of the Day - Grind faster, wheels of (Supreme Court of Canada) justice!
- UPDATED - Scientists hold Parliament Hill rally to mourn the "Death of Evidence"
- Orders of the Day - Let the Battle for Etobicoke Centre be joined!
- Follow politics live on our Hill tickers
- Deputy Minister Shuffle Watch: Mandarins on the Move!
- UPDATE - NDP nixes Libs' bid to call Del Mastro to ethics committee
-
June (66)
- Canada Day vs. Dominion Day - What do you call the July 1 holiday?
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Orders of the Day - Happy Day Before Canada/Dominion Day Eve, Everyone!
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Info Commissioner unveils strategy to investigate national security exemption claims
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- 'If we want an effective inquiry...'
- Orders of the Day - Another round of job cuts, a final round of Royal Assent prep and Afghan detainees...
- UPDATED - Is that a (theoretical) constitutional (meta) crisis I see before me?
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
-
May (73)
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Committee Liveblog: Ethics Commissioner Mary Dawson at Procedure and House Affairs
- Committee Liveblog: Ethics Commissioner Mary Dawson at Procedure and House Affairs
- Orders of the Day - Whither the F-35 inquiry at Public Accounts?
- Liveblog: Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks to the National Fish and Wildlife Conservation Congress
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- House of Commons Liveblog: The CP Rail back-to-work bill (#C39)
- UPDATED | OotD - No Sleep Till ... 3rd Reading of the CP Back To Work Bill!
- Omnibudget Liveblog: C-38 goes to committee -- and subcommittee, too!
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
-
April (57)
- HouseWatch: When it comes to Commons debate, silence isn't always golden
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Orders of the Day - Let a new new era of parliamentary civility begin!
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Storify'd: PM's off the cuff slam against NDP sparks #HarperHistory lesson
- Orders of the Day - Climb aboard the Canada-EU trade love train, hard-working [Insert Provincial Demonym here]!
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- House of Commons Liveblog: The Great "Legal Definition of Human Being" Debate
- Committee Liveblog: Auditor General Michael Ferguson talks F-35 procurement at Public Accounts ... again.
- Orders of the Day - Let the conversation(s) begin!
-
March (47)
- Event liveblog: Justin Trudeau vs. Patrick Brazeau
- Farewell, Angelo Persichilli: PMO loses its sixth director of communications in six years
- Orders of the Day - Fix teleprompters, ministers! There's an Economic Action! Plan to tout!
- Committee Recap: Elections Canada looking into 800 complaints covering 200 ridings: Chief Electoral Officer
- Orders of the Day - Happy Budget/Chief Electoral Officer Speaks Out On Robocalls Day!
- UPDATED - NDP MP launches privilege complaint over government's non-answer on the Office of Religious Freedom
- Robocalls Watch: 5 questions for Chief Electoral Officer Marc Mayrand (that he can actually answer at committee)
- UPDATED - Vikileaks30 Watch: Re-pack your bags, Adam Carroll, you've been re-invited to committee!
- Orders of the Day - One more sleep until the next next phase of Canada's Economic Action! Plan is revealed!
- Committee Recap: Anonymous vs .... Parliamentary Democracy itself? So says Vic Toews.
-
February (50)
- Orders of the Day - If those caucus room walls could talk ...
- Order Paper Watch: NDP wants info on government money going to RackNine, RMG and Campaign Research
- Vikileaks Watch: Pack your bags, Adam Carroll, you're going to (the wrong) committee!
- Orders of the Day - Pay no attention to the Vikileaking former Liberal staffer behind the curtain
- UPDATED - Vikileaks30 Watch: (Now former) Liberal staffer revealed as creator of formerly anonymous twitter account
- UPDATED - Robocalls Watch: Conservative Party linked to calls directing voters to different polling stations
- Orders of the Day - Just another manic Monday. (Thanks, robocall story!)
- Liveblog: NDP Leadership Debate (Winnipeg, Manitoba)
- Election Robocall Data Dump - 12 Conservative candidates on the 2011 RackNine client list
- Orders of the Day - Bad Robot!
-
January (68)
- UPDATED - Fate of NDP motion to investigate creeping in camera-itis at committee unknown
- Committee Liveblog: Former Liberal MP turned Lobbyist Joe Jordan talks Lobbying Act at Ethics
- UPDATED - Orders of the Day: Second day back and it feels like they never left.
- In Camera Watch: 'Wallace Manoeuvre' Back On The Agenda At Government Operations?
- Orders of the Day - Let the doors be opened!
- Liveblog: NDP Leadership Debate #2 - "Giving Families A Break" (Halifax)
- UPDATED - PMO InfoAlerteBot After Dark: "Foreign radicals threaten further delays"
- Question of the Day
- PMO InfoAlerte Watch: So, about that Old Age Security "media speculation"...
- Orders of the Day - See you Monday, 41st parliamentarians!
-
