EMAIL
| PRINT
| REPORT TYPO
| SEND YOUR FEEDBACK
|
ProrogueWatch: The Aftermath - So, what are the boys (and girls) saying?
- January 4, 2010 12:01 PM |
- By Kady O'Malley
Buried near the end of this recent Canadian Press story
on the PM's decision to prorogue Parliament was this tantalizing read
of the public reaction so far, courtesy of Harris Decima pollster Doug
Anderson:
In the meantime, here are a few interesting tidbits from the hypothetical questioning, which comes with a margin of error of 3.1 percent:
The upshot? Although a plurality of respondents greeted the possibility with indifference, those who did not were more likely to be disgruntled than delighted by the move, which was, I should point out again, at that point purely speculative. You have to wonder whether this isn't a potentially dangerous metric for the prime minister, at least in the short term, since it seems reasonable to assume that those who hold strong views -- or any view at all beyond benign apathy -- over whether the House should or shouldn't take a two month break are more likely to take their opinions to the ballot box. After all, it suggests at least a modest degree of engagement with the political process, which would seem to make one more likely to vote.
It will also be fascinating to see whether the anti-prorogation agitation currently underway -- most of which, at the moment, appears to be virtual, and of the Facebook group/e-petition variety -- does manage to turns into real world protests, complete with rallies and even the possibility of a gathering of the "parliament of the willing," as NDP MP Bruce Hyer described it to the Globe and Mail's Gloria Galloway. (Cue the explosion of comments about the lurking menace of Coalition v1.5 under the leadership of Ignatieff-usurper Bob Rae. Just a note, y'all: they wouldn't actually be able to do anything other than pose for the cameras and ask pointed questions in the direction of Langevin Block, so no need to stock up on canned goods just yet.)
His feeling is echoed privately by Tory MPs, and by a poll showing that 46 per cent of Canadians just don't care whether Parliament starts sitting in January or takes a break and comes back after the Olympics in March.
"There's a high level of indifference," said pollster Doug Anderson with Harris Decima.
Predictably, your humble blogger immediately perked up. A poll? On
prorogation? Ooh! More details, please! Alas, the survey in question did
not appear to be posted on the Harris Decima site, but one pleading
email to Anderson later, I had a copy of my very own - and the results,
it turned out, were far more interesting than the offhand reference in
the CP story would suggest.
The poll (pdf) itself, it's worth noting -- actually, it's worth putting in
bold italics, possibly underlined, and maybe even breaking out the blink
-- was taken between December 17th and 20th, well before the prime
minister -- or rather, his press secretary -- confirmed that he would,
indeed, be asking the governor general to prorogue parliament until
March 3, which means that at the time, respondents were reacting to the
theory that he might do so, rather than the fact that he had.
Would the numbers be any different now that the deed is done? I guess
we'll have to wait for the next batch of polls to find out.
In the meantime, here are a few interesting tidbits from the hypothetical questioning, which comes with a margin of error of 3.1 percent:
- Amongst the 49 percent of respondents who held an opinion other
than "meh" on the prospect of prorogation, the percentage of those who
told the pollster that they would be "unhappy" is more than twice that
who said they would be "happy" to see the backs of parliamentarians
until after the Olympics: 34 percent to 15 percent.
- Not surprisingly, opposition party supporters were more likely to
say they would be unhappy, but their lack of enthusiasm was shared by 25
percent of Conservative supporters, which is three points higher than
the percentage who gave the idea a putative thumbs up, and just two
points lower than the number of Bloc Quebecois supporters who were
against it. (Which makes sense, really, since Bloc Quebecois voters are
unlikely to hold particularly warm and fuzzy feelings towards anything
connected to the federal government.)
- Finally, when cross-checked against responses on the decision to prorogue Parliament in 2008, only half of those who agreed that he made the right call last time around said they would be happy if he did so again, with 25 percent predicting that they would be unhappy -- coincidentally, the same percentage of Conservative supporters who feel the same way.
The upshot? Although a plurality of respondents greeted the possibility with indifference, those who did not were more likely to be disgruntled than delighted by the move, which was, I should point out again, at that point purely speculative. You have to wonder whether this isn't a potentially dangerous metric for the prime minister, at least in the short term, since it seems reasonable to assume that those who hold strong views -- or any view at all beyond benign apathy -- over whether the House should or shouldn't take a two month break are more likely to take their opinions to the ballot box. After all, it suggests at least a modest degree of engagement with the political process, which would seem to make one more likely to vote.
It will also be fascinating to see whether the anti-prorogation agitation currently underway -- most of which, at the moment, appears to be virtual, and of the Facebook group/e-petition variety -- does manage to turns into real world protests, complete with rallies and even the possibility of a gathering of the "parliament of the willing," as NDP MP Bruce Hyer described it to the Globe and Mail's Gloria Galloway. (Cue the explosion of comments about the lurking menace of Coalition v1.5 under the leadership of Ignatieff-usurper Bob Rae. Just a note, y'all: they wouldn't actually be able to do anything other than pose for the cameras and ask pointed questions in the direction of Langevin Block, so no need to stock up on canned goods just yet.)
So, can anyone else extract more enlightenment from the Harris Decima-provided entrails? Share and enjoy!
Tags: blackberry jungle, harris-decima, poll spelunking, proroguewatch
Categories
Inside Politics
Most Commented
<
Recent Entries
- Liveblog: AG Nominee Michael Ferguson at Public Accounts
- Check back at 3:30 pm for full coverage! Continue reading this post
- Liberal renewal: looking for an outside fix?
- In the lead up to the Liberals' January policy convention, members can go online and vote on the issues they want to discuss. The most popular resolutions so far have nothing to do with policy or party renewal. Continue reading this post
- OotD Update: Putative Auditor General In Waiting Michael Ferguson to go before Senate Committee of the Whole
- Senate Liberals also want to query top PCO officials Continue reading this post
All News blogs
Most Commented