Greens file court challenge over debate snub
Posted: Mar 31, 2011 4:42 PM ET
Last Updated: Mar 31, 2011 7:09 PM ETBack to accessibility links
Supporting Story Content
End of Supporting Story ContentBack to accessibility links
Beginning of Story Content
The Green Party of Canada has filed an application with the Federal Court of Appeal to challenge a broadcast consortium's exclusion of leader Elizabeth May from the election campaign's televised leaders debates.
The party is requesting a judicial review of CRTC regulations that say the consortium of Canadian broadcasters, including CBC/Radio-Canada, is not required to include all leaders of political parties in debate programs.
On Tuesday, the consortium decided to exclude May from the English and French debates, which are scheduled to be held on April 12 and April 14 in Ottawa.
In a statement, the consortium said the decision was "based on the application of journalistic principles, and the fact that the Green Party has never elected a member to Parliament."
The consortium's initial invitation to only the leaders of the Conservatives, Liberals, NDP and Bloc Québécois triggered a fierce debate on the campaign trail over whether May should be included, as well as the consortium's control over the events.
But CBC ombudsman Kirk LaPointe said he was disappointed about the consortium's decision to limit the scope of the leaders' debates.
"I accept that this decision is not CBC and Radio Canada's alone to make," LaPointe wrote in his blog Thursday. "But it is difficult to discern how the public interest is best served by exclusion or to find congruence in the decision and the public broadcaster's mandate."
LaPointe said that while the consortium correctly noted the the Green Party does not have a sitting MP, he said logic "nestles journalistic practice in behind a political custom."
"Perhaps a shelter in a storm but hardly the best long-term mooring for the craft. These debates are journalistic creations and ought to be governed only by their best practices."
LaPointe pointed out that the Green Party garnered 6.8 per cent of the general vote in the last election. He said a party that garners one million votes can play a significant role in what could be another minority government.
"There is increased relevance mathematically, politically and journalistically to include in pivotal events any party voters have supported significantly and nationally," he wrote.
LaPointe said he decided to weigh in on the issue because his office has received more than 800 complaints about May's exclusion.
Meanwhile, May got a high-profile endorsement from former prime minister Joe Clark, who called the broadcast consortium's exclusion of the Green Party leader "unjustified and undemocratic."
"There are good arguments to change the format of these debates," Clark said in a statement Thursday. "There is no justification for an arbitrary decision to shut out a significant and legitimate political party, like the Green Party."
As for her exclusion, May said the broadcasters are trying to silence a leader who will talk about climate change, First Nations issues and foreign policy.
End of Story ContentBack to accessibility links
Story Social Media
End of Story Social Media
Related News Content
Big Box Advertisement
Federal Election Results
Updated: May. 3, 2011, 3:40 AM EDT
|Party||Elected||Leading||Total||Vote Share (%)|
All results are unofficial until final ballot counts are verified by Elections Canada. CBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.
What is truth in an election campaign?
by Ira Basen Apr. 30, 2011 3:47 PM
Fail At Reality Check we take what politicians say at face value. Maybe that's a mistake.
The cost of being tough on crime
by David McKie Apr. 30, 2011 9:54 AM
Fail The Conservatives have used their so-called tough-on-crime agenda to drive a wedge between themselves and their political opponents. But the issue here is cost.
The NDP's cap-and-trade plan: Brace for sticker shock
by Reality Check Team Apr. 29, 2011 5:10 PM
Fail The NDP wants to curb GHG emissions and raise billions in revenue by imposing cap-and-trade on big polluters. But these costs will be passed along.
The NDP and price of doctors
by Meagan Fitzpatrick Apr. 29, 2011 4:08 PM
50-50 The NDP is promising to add 1,200 doctors over the next 10 years and has a thought-out plan. But is it really accounting for all the additional costs to the health-care system?
What comes next? Post-election scenarios and the Constitution
by Laura Payton Apr. 29, 2011 1:03 PM
Pass The surprising increase in NDP popularity makes this election harder than usual to predict. But there are three main scenarios that could play out after election day.
Top News Headlines
- Record number of women elected
- There will be more female faces in the House of Commons following Monday's federal election that saw 76 women elected, the highest number of women ever. more »
- Layton defends inexperienced Quebec caucus
- NDP Leader Jack Layton defends his youngest, least-experienced caucus members after Quebec voters elect three McGill University students and a pub manager who doesn't speak French or live in the francophone riding she'll represent. more »
- Ignatieff quits as Liberal leader
- Michael Ignatieff is quitting as the Liberal leader after his party took an electoral drubbing on Monday night. more »
- Harper faces cabinet gaps
- With Parliament expected to return to work at the end of May, Prime Minister Stephen Harper will have openings to fill after losing several cabinet ministers on election night. more »