How would you finance the Big Fix?
Find a solution to the infrastructure problems facing Canada's cities
CBC News
Last Updated: November 18, 2011
Canadian governments have identified infrastructure spending as a priority. But a big gap remains between what the country needs and what the public sector can afford.
So the question is: Who pays? And how do they do it?
This tool puts you in charge of finding the answers.
The goal is to shrink the municipal infrastructure gap to zero dollars, without running a surplus.
Adjust the sliders on the left side to raise new revenues. Use the sliders on the right to defer some expenses to a later date.
Rules of the game:
- This calculator assumes governments are unable or unwilling to run up deficits for infrastructure spending.
- All figures are in current dollars.
- The "infrastructure gap" covers municipal needs over a 20-year period. Annual revenue increases are multiplied by 20 to cover this time frame.
- Calculating revenue generation is extremely complex, so we have used the best available data to make rough estimates in some cases.
Get started
Notes
The federal corporate tax rate in Canada, as of January 1, 2012, will be 15 per cent.
Each increase of one per cent in the Canadian corporate tax rate raises $1.664 billion in revenue, according to rough calculations using 2010 figures.
So each 0.25 per cent increase in the corporate tax rate would, in theory, raise $8.325 billion over the 20 years needed to fix the infrastructure gap.
Keep in mind that while raising corporate taxes may appeal to a segment of the Canadian population, some experts argue that raising corporate taxes will hurt Canada's international competitiveness and job creation.
Notes
The federal government spent $239.6 billion total in 2010/11, exclusive of debt charges. If the government were to cut one per cent of its total budget and reapply that money to infrastructure, that would be the equivalent of a $2.396-billion annual investment.
So each 0.25 per cent increase would, in theory, raise an extra $12 billion over the 20 years needed to fix the infrastructure gap.
Keep in mind that this approach would mean reshifting priorities — and likely involve cuts to other departments and/or Crown Corporations.
Provincial only
Provincial and territorial governments have some ways of increasing their infrastructure budgets, from income tax hikes to new vehicle levies. In total, they currently spend roughly two per cent of their total budgets on municipal infrastructure.
Notes
Provinces raised $90.2 billion in income-related taxes in 2010/11, according to Statistics Canada. If the provinces were to introduce tax hikes equivalent to an extra one per cent of revenue, that would theoretically generate $902 million annually. And, over the 20 years needed to fix the infrastructure deficit, each 0.25 per cent hike would raise an extra $4.51 billion over the 20 years needed to fix the infrastructure deficit.
Note: This doesn't mean a one per cent tax increase across the board. You could tax all incomes equally, or shift more of the burden to higher-income households.
Keep in mind that raising taxes on individuals could be deeply unpopular.
Notes
This country has roughly 20 million registered personal vehicles, according to Statistics Canada. If the provinces and territories were to impose a $100 levy on each vehicle when it was registered, that would raise roughly $2 billion annually.
So for every $20 raised, that would raise $8 billion over the 20 years needed to fix the infrastructure gap.
Keep in mind that vehicle registration can be politically risky. Toronto city council overturned a vehicle registration fee in late 2010.
