Police files, historical documents show link between Catholic hierarchy and residential schools

The Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops has claimed in recent weeks, in defence of a statement that Pope Francis could not "personally respond" to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's request for an apology for residential schools, that the Catholic Church itself could not be blamed for the abuses committed at the institutions.

Memo written in Latin seized by OPP was addressed to Catholic order's headquarters in Rome

This is the cover page of a letter sent to a senior Indian Affairs official in 1935 at the request of the Cardinal Archbishop of Quebec asking for a split of the department's education branch into Catholic and non-Catholic. (Library and Archives Canada)

When the Ontario Provincial Police raided the Oblates of Mary Immaculate offices in Ottawa in 1995, they seized a number of documents including a file containing a memo written in Latin and addressed to the order's leadership in Rome.

The memo concerned a member of the order who was associated with St. Anne's residential school in Fort Albany, Ont.

The Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops has claimed in recent weeks, in defence of a statement that Pope Francis could not "personally respond" to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's request for an apology for residential schools, that the Catholic Church itself could not be blamed for the abuses committed at the institutions.

The conference says the schools were run by 16 dioceses and about 36 orders independent of the direction or responsibility of Catholic Church, represented by the Pope in the Vatican.

Yet, the OPP records along with historical files reveal that the Catholic hierarchy in Canada, from the cardinal level down to the bishop, were deeply involved with residential schools and their fingerprints are even found in the Indian Act.

The raid by the OPP was part of a sprawling, six-year investigation into abuse at St. Anne's that included searches of the Oblates and Sisters of Charity offices in Ottawa. The investigation led to five convictions.

The Latin memo is among a list of documents seized by the OPP following their search of the Oblates' office that was filed with a justice of the peace and obtained by CBC News.

It related to one of several religiously-affiliated individuals OPP investigators were seeking information on when they applied for the search warrant, according to OPP files. Police investigators were also seeking information on a bishop, a priest, and several nuns and order brothers.

Pope Francis appears before delivering his Easter message in the Urbi et Orbi (to the city and the world) address from the balcony overlooking St. Peter's Square at the Vatican on April 1. (Stefano Rellandini/Reuters)

Correspondence connected to residential schools

The Oblates brother mentioned in the Latin memo was a boatman who sailed between Moosonee and St. Anne's delivering supplies and transporting children from community of Winisk to the school, according to St. Anne's survivor Edmund Metatawabin.

Metatawabin said he doesn't know why investigators were looking for information about the man.

The OPP files, which are redacted, do not reveal why they were interested in the Oblate brother or what the memo said. But its existence, and the fact it was addressed to the Curia Generalizia, reveals there was communication with the upper echelons of the order about an individual connected to the operations of a residential school.

The Curia Generalizia, or the headquarters, of the Oblates is based in Rome. Most Catholic orders have a Curia Generalizia. These are overseen by the Vatican through a dicastery, which is like a government ministry that ensures all the orders are following Catholic law, according to Joe Gunn, who worked for the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops for 11 years.

"They would be regulated under canon law and they would be under that department or ministry of the Vatican," said Gunn.

"Most of them report every so often. That is kind of the chain of command."

'Taxed' schools

Some of the orders "taxed" the federally-funded schools they operated to feed the coffers of their central offices in Canada, according to research by Jim Miller, a professor emeritus of history at the University of Saskatchewan.

"The Ottawa bureaucrat referred regretfully to such a practice as 'bleeding the children to feed the mother-house,'" wrote Miller, in his 1996 book Shingwauk's Vision: A History of Native Residential Schools.

"The Oblates similarly 'taxed' their many schools for support of a central administrative office in Ottawa, an exaction that federal grants accommodated officially only in the more affluent days in the later 1950s."

Children in a classroom at St. Anne's residential school in Fort Albany, Ont., in the 1940s. (Algoma University/Edmund Metatabwin collection)

The historical record also shows the Catholic hierarchy in Canada was directly involved in trying to influence federal policy on residential schools.

In one case, the Catholic hierarchy was concerned Ottawa did not take their views seriously on dealing with tuberculosis epidemics.

These concerns led the Cardinal and Archbishop of Quebec Jean-Marie-Rodrigue Villeneuve to direct a letter be sent to Harold W. McGill, the deputy superintendent of Indian Affairs at the time, demanding the Indian Affairs residential schools branch be split into Catholic and non-Catholic, according to historical records unearthed by researcher Edward Sadowski and provided to CBC News.

"It would eliminate all friction and put an end to all conflicting discussions which incessantly occur," said the 1935 letter. 

The friction primarily stemmed from the belief among the Catholic hierarchy that Ottawa had an anti-Catholic bias. At one point, Rev. J.O. Plourde, the general superintendent of the Oblate Catholic Indian Missions, wrote to McGill, who was then-director of Indian Affairs, saying Ottawa's bias was "akin to persecution."

"Even Adolf Hitler has not gone as far as that in his treatment of Catholic children," wrote Plourde in 1939.

He was upset Ottawa was not sending students sick with tuberculosis to sanatoriums of the same religious affiliation as their residential school.

The general superintendent of the Oblate Catholic Indian Missions, wrote to the director of Indian Affairs in 1939 saying Ottawa sending Catholic residential school students to non-Catholic sanatoriums was 'akin to persecution.' (Library and Archives Canada)

Saint Boniface Archbishop Emile Yelle, from Manitoba, also weighed in against Ottawa's decision to consider cost, instead of religious affiliation, when deciding where to send children who became ill with TB at residential schools.

"The main reason given was financial," wrote Yelle, in a 1940 letter to Thomas Crerar, the minister of mines and natural resources who was responsible for Indian Affairs.

"Evidently, that is not fair….Asking only what is just and reasonable."

The Indian Act section

The Catholic Church had some leverage to make these demands partly as a result of an earlier victory by religious leaders who managed to convince federal politicians to include a now deleted section in the Indian Act legislating Catholic children be sent to Catholic residential schools while Protestants be sent to Protestant schools.

Section 10 from the 1927 Indian Act

Sadowski, who unearthed the documents as part of research aimed at supporting a failed court case to have the Fort William Sanatorium included as a residential school under the Indian Residential Schools Settlement Agreement, said it's clear the Catholic Church and other religious denominations had a hand in inserting that section into the Indian Act.

"The politicians in Ottawa did not do it in a vacuum. How could they?" said Sadowski.

"The myth out there that the Catholic church was not involved is just a lie... You have all these letters, back and forth correspondence between archbishops from across Canada and the department of Indian Affairs.... The Catholic hierarchy has to be responsible for all these policies."

About the Author

Jorge Barrera

Reporter

Jorge Barrera is a Caracas-born, award-winning journalist who has worked across the country and internationally. He is currently working for the CBC Indigenous unit based out of Ottawa.