Thousands of lives at risk in next major pandemic unless WHO reforms: UN report

The World Health Organization's emergency response capability is "lacking" and will put thousands of lives at risk if it is not reformed now, according to a high-level UN report on health crises.

World's preparedness and capacity to respond called woefully insufficient

A series of reviews by global health experts have been sharply critical of WHO's response to the devastating Ebola epidemic in West Africa. (Ahmed Jallanzo/EPA)
The World Health Organization's emergency response capability is "lacking" and will put thousands of lives at risk if it is not reformed now, according to a high-level UN report on health crises.

"This may be the last opportunity to ensure the WHO is empowered" to build an effective emergency response capacity, warned an advance, unedited copy of the UN panel's report, made available online over the weekend in a link on the United Nations' daily Journal website.

"The high risk of major health crises is widely underestimated and … the world's preparedness and capacity to 
respond is woefully insufficient," the panel, convened in the wake of the Ebola crisis, said in its report.

"If the WHO does not successfully reform, the next major pandemic will cause thousands of otherwise preventable deaths."

The UN report, entitled "Protecting Humanity from Future Health Crises", is the latest in a series of reviews by global health experts which have been sharply critical of the WHO's response to the devastating Ebola epidemic in West Africa.

With all eyes now focused on the response to the mosquito-borne Zika virus, which has been reported in 33 countries and is linked to birth defects, the agency is under even more scrutiny. WHO chiefs have previously promised to act swiftly on reforming the agency's emergency responses.

It was not immediately clear when the final report will be published.

The Ebola outbreak, which began in Guinea and spread from there to infect thousands across Liberia and Sierra Leone, 
killed more than 11,300 people.

No substitute for single global health leader

The UN panel's key recommendation was for the WHO to build a new Centre for Emergency Preparedness and Response, which "must have real command and control capability, access to specialised human and operational resources to execute a health response."

It also said all countries must meet the full obligations of international health regulations which, among other things, set 
rules on how and when to report disease outbreaks.

Jeremy Farrar, director of the Wellcome Trust global health charity, agreed with the panel's recommendation for the creation of a new centre, which he said must be "strong and independent."

"Epidemic and pandemic diseases are among the greatest of all threats to human health and security, against which we have for too long done too little to prepare," he said.

"After four inquiries into the preventable tragedy of Ebola, there is now a strong consensus about what must be done.

The WHO's leadership and member states must make 2016 the year of decision and act now."

The UN panel said it was "convinced that there is no substitute for having a single global health leader" and that 
"the World Health Organization should become this leader."

But failure by the Geneva-based WHO to reform, it said, "may necessitate consideration of alternate UN institutional response mechanisms."

It added that too often, "global panic about epidemics has been followed by complacency and inaction". It cited as example a review of global preparedness drawn up after the 2009 H1N1 fu pandemic, whose recommendations were mostly not addressed.

"Had they been implemented, thousands of lives could have been saved in West Africa," it said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.