Premenstrual mood symptoms questioned
'This puzzlingly widespread belief needs challenging'
Posted: Oct 18, 2012 5:41 PM ET
Last Updated: Oct 18, 2012 10:51 PM ET
Women who feel grouchy before getting their periods shouldn't blame it on their hormones directly, according to researchers at the University of Toronto.
Women's menstrual cycles are mythologized as a time of the month of low mood and irrationality.
But when researchers at the University of Toronto looked at published medical research on the topic, the methods used were so varied that they couldn't do a proper analysis.The researchers did not discount that women may experience physical symptoms, such as bloating and cramps, during the pre-menstrual phase of the cycle. (iStock)
"Taken together, these studies failed to provide clear evidence in support of the existence of a specific premenstrual negative mood syndrome in the general population," Gillian Einstein, a professor in the psychology department at the University of Toronto and her co-authors concluded in the journal Gender Medicine.
"This puzzlingly widespread belief needs challenging, as it perpetuates negative concepts linking female reproduction with negative emotionality."
Einstein's team also did their own study, measuring hormone levels in the urine of 14 women aged 18 to 40 in the Greater Toronto Area who weren't seeking medical attention for menstrual symptoms.
The women also used a smartphone to log their daily moods, both positive and negative, over 1½ menstrual cycles.
"Our major finding is that, with a few exceptions, neither absolute hormone levels nor menstrual cycle phase as determined by hormone levels played a significant role in daily mood of this group of women," the researchers concluded.
"Rather, perceived stress and physical health were the strongest contributors to statistical models of daily positive and negative mood."
Factors like stress, lack of social support, money worries and physical ailments also can impact a woman's mood, Einstein said.
Other studies using different methods also found inconsistent, minimal or non-existent influences of the hormones estrogen and progestagens on daily mood in healthy women, they said.
Dr. Jerilynn Prior is a professor of endocrinology and metabolism at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver who studies menstrual cycles.
Prior followed 62 women over a year, and couldn't find a PMS pattern, either, in younger women.
"It's great to see this confirmation that there isn't any such thing as this psychiatric illness that all women get in the few days before their flow, but that it is a real thing for perimenopausal women," Prior said.
Extreme cases rare
The researchers did not look at premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD), a clinical mood disorder linked with the menstrual cycle that is characterized by severe physical and behavioural symptoms in the second half of the menstrual cycle.
Psychiatrist Dr. Diane Meschino, director of a reproductive mental health at Women's College Hospital in Toronto, said that by and large, she agrees with the findings. But in her practice, she does see women with premenstrual disorder that include extreme moodiness.
Such moodiness and depression are rare, Meschino said, but they do exist and are documented in diaries her patients keep of their symptoms. Pre-menstrual exacerbation of chronic depression is also rare. It's all a reflection of how enormously complex mood is, she said.
The researchers also did not discount that women may experience physical symptoms, such as bloating and cramps, during the pre-menstrual phase of the cycle.
Abby Lippman, professor emerita in the department of epidemiology, biostatics and occupational health at McGill University in Montreal, said the U of T team researched a difficult topic given that PMS is rife with preconceived notions.
"Challenging assumptions is essential in exploring the givens associated too easily by too many with regard to women's health and the U of T folks show one way of doing this," Lippman said.
In downtown Toronto, news of the findings was greeted with skepticism.
"Any woman would know that there is PMS," said one woman, pointing to women feeling upset and annoyed before their period.
Another woman said she appreciates how pain could affect women psychologically.With files from CBC's Kelly Crowe
Top News Headlines
- Will Rob Ford's supporters leave Ford Nation?
- The growing controversy over a purported video alleging to show Toronto Mayor Rob Ford smoking crack cocaine may be testing the faith of even his most die-hard supporters. But experts say Ford's policies may trump whatever personal issues he's facing, and that his supporters may rally behind him. more »
- Royal Bank pledges not to outsource jobs for cash savings
- Royal Bank has promised it will never outsource a Canadian job to a foreign worker solely to save money. more »
- Neil Macdonald: How serious is Obama about curbing the drone surge?
- In a key speech this week, the U.S. president set out a host of supposed new safeguards for America's controversial practice of remote-controlled rough justice. But as Neil Macdonald writes, the underlying rationale for drone use has not fundamentally changed. more »
- Making The Mandela Tapes
- Producer Robin Benger describes how he obtained broadcast access to interviews Nelson Mandela recorded in the 1990s. A CBC Radio Ideas program on the Mandela tapes airs May 28. more »
- Washington police blame bridge collapse on Alberta trucker
- Washington State police say an Alberta trucker was responsible for hitting a steel beam precipitating a bridge collapse on one of the busiest routes in the American northwest. more »
Latest Health News Headlines
- WHO to help Saudi Arabia's coronavirus investigation before hajj
- The World Health Organization plans to help Saudi Arabia dig deeper into deadly outbreaks of a new coronavirus to draw up advice ahead of the annual hajj pilgrimage, which attracts millions of Muslims. more »
- Coroner's jury recommends pool safety changes
- The jury of a coroner's inquest into the drowning of a Chinese student in Saint John is calling for province-wide safety standards at all public pools and increased minimum training for paramedics. more »
- New blood restrictions still discriminate against gay men, advocates say
- Health Canada has loosened decades-old restrictions on gay men giving blood — but it's still not nearly enough, Hamilton advocates say. more »
- MS liberation therapy fund should end, Parrott says
- Independent MLA and retired surgeon Jim Parrott is calling on the provincial government to stop spending taxpayers' money on a controversial treatment for multiple sclerosis. more »
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford denies using crack cocaine
- Washington police blame bridge collapse on Alberta trucker
- Canada ranks 3rd last in paid vacations
- Dog snared on baited hooks near Grouse Grind trail
- Man accused of killing child in patio crash granted bail
- Amanda Bynes charged for allegedly tossing bong out window
- UBC student took 'nose dive into water' after bridge collapse
- Motorists warned to avoid Washington bridge collapse area
- London attack victim's widow speaks of 'our future together'