Why are some Hamilton resident doctors working 24 hour hospital shifts?
Posted: Oct 11, 2012 12:16 PM ET
Last Updated: Oct 11, 2012 12:39 PM ET
Pilots aren't allowed to do it. Truck drivers can't either. But it seems medical residents, at least in Ontario, are permitted, and even sometimes required to work twenty-four hours in a row.
A resident in Quebec took his schedule to the courts, arguing that working that long violated his charter rights. He won. Now other provinces are re-examining their policies.
Dr. Jonathan DellaVedova is a 4th pediatrics resident at McMaster University. He is also president of PAIRO, the Professional Association of Internes and Residents of Ontario.
He spoke about that gruelling schedule with CBC Ottawa's Robyn Bresnahan. Here's a transcript of the interview. You can also listen to the interview on this page.
Robyn Bresnahan: I understand you're actually about to start a 24 hour shift. How do you feel about that?
JD: We do know from the medical literature that the 24 hour shift is a challenge for residents and can risk patient safety in some ways. Certainly, I’m in pediatrics and my eight-year-old patients can tell you that a 24-hour shift defies common sense and that a performance towards the end of a 24-hour shift probably isn’t optimal. We know that diagnostic errors, medication errors, needle stick injuries and car accidents on the way home are all more common with 24-hour shifts.
RB: You’re about to go work this 24-hour shift. I assume it’s not the first time you’ve done this?
JD: No, it’s been several years of residency that I’ve been doing 24-hour shifts but on the bright side there are dozens of residency programs in Ontario, including my own, that are experimenting with ways to eliminate the 24-hour shift altogether. Some call it Night Float and some call it Role Call because you don’t see daylight for weeks at a time. But there have been quite a few pockets of success which we think are great for residents, greats for the hospitals and ultimately beneficial to patients.
RB: When you work a 24-hour shift, you go into it…you’ve had how much sleep?
JD: We try to be as well rested as we can before the start of a 24-hour shift.
RB: How many hours did you get before you’re starting this shift?
JD: Six or seven, which is pretty good in the residency world.
RB: How do you feel at the start of the shift compared to how you feel at the end of it?
JD: The start of the shift is no problem. I personally start to feel a dip in the evening around 7:00 or 8:00, right after dinner and then you just have to draw on all your resources, grab some caffeine or a Red Bull and keep going. Some shifts aren’t as busy and we can steal an hour of sleep here or there but some shifts are just busy all the way through.
RB: This just sounds wrong, right from the start. You’re saying you grab a Red Bull. You’re a doctor, they’ve done studies and that stuff is terrible for you.
JD: Unfortunately, in the residency universe, we’re a little challenged at taking care of ourselves sometimes. We’re eager to learn and serve the public but we want to do so in a way that’s safe for patients and safe for ourselves.
RB: Are you doing any kind of major surgeries at all during your shifts?
JD: There are no surgeries, per say, in pediatrics but many of my colleagues are performing operations overnight. Regardless of what specialty we’re in, we’re making critical life and death decisions, we’re prescribing medications all throughout the shift.
RB: Once you become a doctor, do doctors have to perform 24-hour shifts?
JD: Yes, it’s very common for independently licensed physicians to also be working 24-hour shifts.
RB: What do you think of that?
JD: In Ontario the approach we’ve taken is to look at this issue more broadly because it’s very complex. We’re looking at the issue as fatigue management. We’ll never be able to eliminate the need for healthcare at night. We like to think of the topic more broadly and include our senior colleagues when we talk about duty hours.
RB: What would you propose as a solution instead of working 24-hour shifts?
JD: In Ontario we haven’t come out advocating for a hard cap on hours like they have recently in Quebec. We’ve been looking at these pockets of success where residents and programs have some up with solutions on their own to eliminate the 24-hours shift. We want to get these models out there so that people can benefit from sharing best practices and perhaps apply them a little bit more broadly.
RB: What would be the ideal working situation for a medical resident, in your view?
JD: There’s no unifying solution that comes to us from the literature. What we need to do is look at situations that have been working. This discussion has been going on for many years and the rest of the world is way ahead of us with strict duty hour limits in the U.K. , Europe, Australia and New Zealand. Obviously 24-hour shifts defy logic but, depending on where you are in Ontario, the solution might be different. We’re in favour of allowing individual programs to have all of the information they need around the pitfalls of 24-hour shifts and come up with their own solutions.
RB: Doctor, thank you very much.
JD: Thanks for having me, Robyn.
Dr. Jonathan DellaVedova is president of PAIRO, the Professional Association of Internes and Residents of Ontario and a 4th pediatrics resident at McMaster University.
Top News Headlines
- 2 men jailed in Dominican wedding fight return to Canada
- Two Canadian men who were detained in the Dominican Republic for nearly three weeks after a post-wedding fight broke out at a resort have returned to Toronto, the latest step in a drama that the wife of one of the men said was "like a scene from the movies." more »
- Senators call for 'zero tolerance' on harassment in RCMP
- The RCMP should amend its code of conduct to explicitly define and prohibit harassment, a Senate committee is recommending in a newly tabled report. more »
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- As electronic or e-cigarettes grow in popularity, some health advocates want them to be regulated. more »
- Most groups don't want return of Trudeau speaking fees
- Most of the 17 charitable and other organizations that have paid speaking fees to Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau during his time as an MP say they aren't interested in having their fees returned, despite Trudeau's offer on the weekend to reimburse any organization unhappy with his services. more »
Latest Health News Headlines
- Sexually transmitted oral cancers screened with early blood test
- Antibodies to a high-risk type of a virus that causes mouth and throat cancers when transmitted via oral sex can be detected in blood tests many years before onset of the disease, according to a World Health Organization-led team of researchers. more »
- Parents in dark about teens tanning, study suggests
- New research into the use of indoor tanning salons by Alberta teenagers suggests their parents are clueless about it. more »
- Celiacs, diabetics face hard food bank choices
- Life on a limited income is an extra challenge for people living with diabetes or celiac disease, a poverty survey by Women's Network PEI is finding. more »
- Mental illness afflicts most of Calgary's homeless, study finds
- A study has found there is an "overwhelmingly high" rate of undiagnosed and untreated psychiatric illness among Calgary's homeless population. more »
- Canadians in Dominican wedding fight freed from jail
- Huge ancient city at Angkor Wat revealed by lasers
- Montreal mayor resigns amid corruption charges
- TV chef Nigella Lawson's husband cautioned by police for assault
- Disabled woman's care before dying on bus still a mystery
- Student with bullied past, 'The Doorman,' graduates
- Parents of son 'brutally beaten' playing hockey want charges
- 'Standing man' inspires new, silent protests in Turkey
- G8 leaders agree to 7-point plan on Syria as summit wraps