Warnings to medically unfit drivers may limit crashes
Risk reduction from doctor warnings 'immediate, substantial, and sustained'
By Amina Zafar, CBC News
Posted: Sep 26, 2012 5:21 PM ET
Last Updated: Sep 26, 2012 6:41 PM ET
Fewer people ended up in emergency rooms due to car crashes in Ontario after doctors were paid to report patients who shouldn't drive for medical reasons, a new study finds.
In Wednesday's online issue of the New England Journal of Medicine, researchers looked at the emergency visits for road crashes before and after doctors warned patients considered unfit to get the behind the wheel.Many jurisdictions require medical screening of all older drivers. (Brian Ray/The Gazette/Associated Press)
Since 2006, Ontario has paid doctors $36.25 to provide warnings to patients who are potentially unfit to drive. The program resulted in the suspension of a driving licence in about 10 to 30 per cent of cases, Dr. Donald Redelmeier, the study's lead investigator and a senior scientist at the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences in Toronto and his co-authors said.
Other patients received a stiff warning letter from the transportation ministry.
"These findings suggest that medical warnings to patients who are potentially unfit to drive can be both lifesaving for individuals and cost saving to society but require clinical judgment and should not be carried to excess," Redelmeier said.
"The reduction in risk was immediate, substantial, and sustained."
For the study, researchers analyzed data for 100,075 patients who received medical warnings from 2006 to 2010. In the three years before the warning program change, there were 1,430 collisions in which the patient was a driver and went to emergency, compared with 273 crashes in the year afterwards, which the researchers said represents a 45 per cent reduction in the annual rate of crashes per 1,000 patients.
The decrease was largest among elderly women with high socio-economic status, living in rural areas.
Compromising doctor-patient relationship
Patients with a combination of diagnoses, such as heart failure and diabetes, were at greatest risk. Alcoholism topped the list of underlying conditions that were associated with crashes before a patient received a warning, Redelmeier said.
"For the conditions that they highlight, alcoholism, epilepsy, dementia, there's little debate that these conditions specifically can affect your ability to drive so I think it's important to do this" reporting, said Dr. Shawn Marshall, a specialist in physical medicine and rehabilitation and an associate professor at the University of Ottawa who was not involved in the study.
The decrease was associated with worsening depression in some patients and a decrease in visits to the responsible physician in some cases, which compromises the doctor-patient relationship without reducing the patient's risk to that of the general population, the study's authors said.
The findings emphasize the importance of exercising judgment and showing compassion when delivering the bad news to patients, Redelmeier added.
The researchers did not have access to data on related factors such as driving records, distance travelled, use of medications, driver testing and past suspensions.
They also did not know how severe a patient's medical condition is, which is important when doctors are assessing someone's ability to drive, Marshall said. Someone with a mild stroke could be able to compensate for weakness on one side of the body while another patient with more severe disability or less driving skill might not.
Patients may have decided to restrict their driving on their own, such as travelling shorter distances or driving with greater care. Warnings from family members could also contribute, the researchers said.
Other explanations for changing driver behaviour include mechanical problems with a vehicle and changes in symptoms.
A commentary in this week's issue of the British Medical Journal warned that medical ageism may fuel the belief that older drivers pose a disproportionate risk to other road users.
"We should focus on evidence based innovations, such as restricted licensing and rehabilitation, for people with age-related illness,” said Dr. Desmond O'Neill, a consultant physician in geriatric and stroke medicine at Trinity College in Dublin.
"This is the best approach to protect the safe mobility, and avoid further unhelpful stigmatization, of a group whose ranks most will join in due course."
The study was supported by the Canada Research Chair in Medical Decision Sciences, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the Comprehensive Research Experience for Medical Students of the University of Toronto Faculty of Medicine.
Top News Headlines
- Harper to address Tory caucus amid Senate scandal
- Conservatives gathered Monday night to mourn the passing of a key architect in their rise to power — and to brace for the toughest test Prime Minister Stephen Harper's government has faced since taking office on a promise to clean up politics in the national capital. more »
- Keith Boag: Have you heard about the murderous abortion doctor?
- The gruesome trial and murder conviction of Philadelphia abortion provider Dr. Kermit Gosnell is unlikely to change American abortion law, Keith Boag writes. But it has U.S. journalists questioning their priorities and how they cover such a sensitive issue. more »
- Fearful Oklahoma families search for children
- The parents and guardians stood in the muddy grass outside a suburban Oklahoma City church, listening intently as someone with a bullhorn called out the names of children who were being dropped off — survivors of Monday's deadly tornado. more »
- Baseball fuels dreams, desperation in Dominican Republic
- The Toronto Blue Jays have a number of stars from the Dominican Republic, but in the shadow of these successful players is an equally important story about hope and poverty, and a country desperately struggling to balance the two. more »
Latest Health News Headlines
- Sleeping with parents always risky for infants, study suggests
- Sharing a bed with their parents increased the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) in babies under three months old by at least a factor of five, even without any other risk factors, the largest ever analysis of individual cases suggests. more »
- Flu shot for health workers urged by Ont. medical officer
- Ontario's chief medical officer of health is renewing her push for health-care workers, particularly those in long-term care, to get their shots. more »
- Saudi coronavirus work stymied at Canadian lab
- The National Microbiology Laboratory in Winnipeg is working with a sample of the new coronavirus that's causing clusters of infections abroad - but can't share the material with other researchers across the country despite the public health urgency. more »
- Should genetic testing for cancer be available to all Canadians?
- The revelation that Hollywood celebrity Angelina Jolie had a double mastectomy as a preventative measure against cancer stoked heated discussion this past week, but one prominent cancer researcher says it demonstrates the need to make genetic testing available to all Canadians. more »
- Oklahoma tornado rescue crews work through night
- 51 dead after tornado levels Oklahoma suburbs
- Edmonton driver, 62, charged in boy's patio death
- Unknown remains found on Dellen Millard's farm
- Will alleged Rob Ford video overshadow Toronto casino debate?
- Netflix and the rise of binge TV watching
- Ray Manzarek of The Doors dies at 74
- B.C. man feared kidnapped in Mexico
- Canadian on EI shut out amid foreign worker influx