Heroin treatment more cost-effective than methadone
CMAJ study compared heroin to methadone in preventing addiction relapses
Posted: Mar 12, 2012 12:42 PM ET
Last Updated: Mar 12, 2012 11:16 PM ET
Prescribing heroin instead of methadone is more effective and less costly in treating street drug addiction relapses, a new analysis suggests.
It was a collaboration with UBC, the University of Montreal and the Northern Ontario School of Medicine.
"We gave them option of trying methadone or diacetylmorphine [heroin] under medically supervised conditions, and we found people who were getting diacetylmorphine were retained in treatment much, much longer, so they had a much better outcome," said study head Dr. Aslam Anis, director of the Centre for Health Evaluation and Outcome Sciences at St. Paul’s Hospital in Vancouver.Chronic addicts who were prescribed heroin stayed in treatment better than those prescribed methadone, researchers found. (CBC)
Most of the savings in the mathematical model were attributed to how those prescribed heroin stayed in treatment longer and spent less time in relapse than those randomly assigned to receive methadone.
By staying in treatment, health-care costs were lower when the cost of the drugs, counselling and social supports were added up.
"Our model indicated that diacetylmorphine would decrease societal costs, largely by reducing costs associated with crime, and would increase both the duration and quality of life of treatment recipients," the study's authors concluded.
While the clinical trial was based on a year’s worth of data, the researchers considered different timeframes — such as one year, five years and over a lifetime— in their analysis.
They estimated the societal cost of $1.14 million over the lifetime of a person receiving methadone, compared with $1.10 million for someone on diacetylmorphine injections.
Methadone is taken orally, usually mixed with juice. It works by blocking opioid receptors in the brain to take away cravings and prevent withdrawal symptoms.
In 2009, the researchers reported in the New England Journal of Medicine that diacetylmorphine is more cost-effective than methadone among the same group of addicts in Vancouver and Montreal, in terms of staying in treatment or quitting heroin altogether and reducing use of illegal drugs.
The cost-effectiveness study, published in Monday's issue of the Canadian Medical Association Journal, focused on more than 250 people addicted to opioid drugs who had tried methadone replacement therapy at least twice and were unable to stay drug-free.
Dutch studies came to similar conclusions for people in methadone maintenance programs. The North American trial, called NAOMI, looked at those who have been out of treatment for at least six months.
In the latest Canadian study, drawbacks include a lack of data on opioid users reaching a state of abstinence and on the long-term patterns, the authors acknowledged.
The findings do not apply to people who haven't tried methadone replacement therapy.
Dr. Meldon Kahan, who treats opioid dependency as part of his Toronto practice, suggested addicts who received methadone in the trial were given sub-optimal doses of the drug, leading to a higher drop-out rate than among those prescribed heroin.
The researchers also developed a web-based tool for policymakers to calculate the estimated costs and savings of using this approach depending on the age and sex of addicts in their population.With files from CBC's Greg Rasmussen and The Canadian Press
Top News Headlines
- Toronto mayor fired chief of staff for telling him to 'go away and get help'
- CBC News has learned the details of what precipitated the firing of Mark Towhey as Toronto Mayor Rob Ford's chief of staff — and it was advice from Towhey that Ford needs to 'get help.' more »
- Federal Court won't remove MPs over robocall allegations
- The Federal Court says it won't throw six MPs out of their seats over allegations of widespread vote suppression through automated robocalls in the 2011 federal election. But Judge Richard Mosley did find that fraud occurred in the election. more »
- Alleged Ford crack video seller not responding to calls
- The journalist who broke the story alleging Toronto Mayor Rob Ford was recorded on video smoking crack cocaine says he may never be able to get his hands on the evidence. more »
- Bridge collapse on Washington interstate drops cars into water
- The Washington State Patrol says the Interstate 5 bridge over the Skagit River at Mount Vernon has collapsed, dumping vehicles and people into the water. more »
Latest Health News Headlines
- 3-D printing of airway tube helps save U.S. baby
- In a medical first, doctors used plastic particles and a 3-D laser printer to create an airway splint to save the life of a baby boy who used to stop breathing nearly every day. more »
- Wait time and primary care reforms stalled
- Shortening wait times for hip and knee replacements, increasing electronic health records and starting a national pharmacare strategy are stalled, according to a new progress report. more »
- Needed: New approaches to defuse 'suicide contagion' among teens
- Mental health experts say we need to find new ways to refer to and discuss suicide, particularly now that a large medical study has confirmed that teens are more susceptible to the idea if they know a schoolmate who died that way. more »
- Fever medicine for infants, children under recall
- Quality concerns with a Chinese producer of acetaminophen have prompted a recall of four fever medications meant for infants and children. more »
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford fires chief of staff
- 2nd suspect in Tim Bosma murder case to plead not guilty
- 2 more arrests linked to hacking death of British soldier
- Duffy says he wants to give Canadians 'the whole story'
- Vancouver man abandons Porsche on B.C. ferry
- Chained-teen's mom wants man who pleaded guilty 'to suffer'
- Montreal lifts boil-water advisory
- B.C. teen saves pet dog in 'terrifying' cougar attack
- Neil Macdonald: Harper no Obama when it comes to dealing with scandals