Cyclists should be forced to wear helmets: study
Last Updated: Tuesday, August 10, 2010 | 1:32 PM ET
The Canadian Press
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Cyclists are more likely to wear helmets and avoid injuries if they live in a province with a mandatory helmet law, according to a new study. (CBC)A new study is calling on provincial governments to pass laws that force cyclists to wear helmets.
The study, published in the August edition of the journal Injury Prevention and conducted by researchers at the University of Manitoba and the University of Ottawa, suggests cyclists are much more likely to wear helmets and avoid injuries if they live in a province with a mandatory helmet law.
There is little consistency across Canada in terms of helmet use legislation.
British Columbia, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island and New Brunswick all have mandatory helmet legislation for people of all ages.
A handful of other provinces have adopted bicycle helmet laws that apply only to those under the age of 18.
'It's atrocious that in 2010, every province does not have some sort of helmet legislation.'—Ryan Zarychanski, study co-leader
Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Quebec have no bicycle helmet laws.
Manitoba Liberals have been pushing for a helmet law for years but the NDP government has refused. The province's medical association has also called for a helmet law.
Manitoba has instead opted to keep helmet use optional, and has tried to encourage helmet use through promotional campaigns and by offering subsidized helmets that cost as little as $10.
"I mean, it's atrocious that in 2010, every province does not have some sort of helmet legislation," said Ryan Zarychanski, an assistant professor of medicine at the University of Manitoba, who co-led the study with Jessica Dennis, a graduate student at the University of Ottawa.
"Clearly, helmet legislation works and clearly it reduces serious head injuries and facial lacerations."
The researchers used data collected from the Canadian Community Health Survey, which relies on information collected from the long-form census.
They compared 2005 helmet use figures involving more than 4,600 respondents in three provinces with very different rules for cyclists.
Helmets were worn by 73.2 per cent of respondents in Nova Scotia, where helmet use is mandatory for everyone. The rate was just 40.6 per cent in Ontario, where helmets are mandatory for young people only, and a mere 26.9 in Saskatchewan.
Critics of helmet laws have argued that making helmets mandatory might discourage people from cycling. But the study found bicycle use remained constant in Alberta and Prince Edward Island after those provinces adopted helmet laws in 2002 and 2003 respectively.
"Contrary to popular belief, provincial helmet legislation does not cause people to cycle less, but it does result in increased helmet use, which has been shown to prevent serious head injuries," Zarychanski said.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- RCMP shooting suspect's parents urge him to surrender
- The parents of the suspect in the shooting of two RCMP officers near Killam, Alta., have asked the fugitive to turn himself in — with his father urging him to "swallow your hurt" and come home. more »
- Shipwrecked Canadians call rescue 'incredible'
- One of the three Canadians picked up by a giant container ship at sea overnight after a storm damaged their Hawaii-bound sailboat is calling their dramatic rescue a "gauntlet of happiness." more »
- Ont. van crash responder appalled by gawkers
- One of the first people on the scene of the crash that killed 11 people in Hampstead, Ont., on Monday says he is appalled by passersby who gathered at the scene only to record the carnage on their phones. more »
- Firing warning shots OK in some cases, minister says
- Justice Minister Rob Nicholson came under fire in question period after telling a House committee it's reasonable under some circumstances to fire warning shots. more »
Latest Health News Headlines
- Deadly ovarian cancer starts outside of ovaries
- Years of research and screening for ovarian cancer have been focused in the wrong area, according to new findings from a McGill doctor. more »
- Doctors may paint overly rosy prognosis
- Some doctors aren't always completely honest with their patients, a new survey suggests. more »
- Global health innovators rewarded for bold ideas
- Canadians have won grants worth $1.5 million to develop innovative ways to tackle pressing health problems in developing countries, such as cheap filters to remove arsenic from drinking water. more »
- Smoking-cessation drug ads raise concerns
- Ads that subtly promote the smoking cessation drug Champix are popping up in downtown Montreal, but the campaign is raising concerns after a recent study linked the drug to heart problems. more »
FEATURED HEALTH
- Shipwrecked Canadians call rescue 'incredible'
- RCMP shooting suspect's parents urge him to surrender
- 5 places where babies have been banned
- RCMP shooting suspect a 'quiet' photographer
- Toronto mayor slams 'irrelevant' council after transit loss
- Lottery winners spend big before getting $50M prize
- Canada and China next steps could include free trade deal
- Kelowna cyclist dies after plunge through ice
- Gadhafi Mexico plot riles SNC-Lavalin, insiders say

