WHO's H1N1 review panel sees 2 resign
Last Updated: Wednesday, June 23, 2010 | 10:26 AM ET
The Canadian Press
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Two members of a panel set up to appraise the World Health Organization's handling of the H1N1 pandemic have stepped down because they were involved in the response the review committee is assessing.
A statement released by the Geneva-based agency suggested they felt that involvement could be seen as a conflict, given that the review is meant to be an independent evaluation.
The review committee chair said Tuesday the men — Australian virologist John MacKenzie and Dr. Tony Evans, head of aviation medicine at the International Civil Aviation Organization — will make themselves available to the panel as expert witnesses if and when needed.
"Both have been closely engaged in deliberations at WHO which our committee is charged to review," said Dr. Harvey Fineberg, who is also president of the U.S. Institute of Medicine.
"They each concluded it would be better to avoid the position as reviewer of their own earlier actions."
MacKenzie is also chair of the so-called Emergency Committee of experts that has been advising WHO Director General Margaret Chan on the pandemic.
The identities of other members of that committee have not been made public, a fact that has fuelled criticism of the WHO's handling of the outbreak. Chan has said those names are being kept secret to protect members from external pressure. She has promised to make their names known once the pandemic is declared over.
MacKenzie also played a pivotal role in the WHO's response to SARS. He headed a scientific committee struck to piece together, in real time, key information about the new disease.
The review panel will present a final report next year.
With files from The Associated PressShare Tools
Top News Headlines
- Israel's Netanyahu to raise Iran during visit with Harper
- Iran's nuclear program and security in the Middle East are expected to dominate the agenda when Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu meets with Prime Minister Stephen Harper in Ottawa on Friday. more »
- Why the West won't take on Syria
- The West may talk tough about the Assad regime's crackdown on its own citizens but is unlikely to intervene militaril because Syria is so central to the stability of almost the entire Middle East, Sasa Petricic says. more »
- Nature journal criticizes Canadian 'muzzling'
- One of the world's leading scientific journals is accusing the Harper government of limiting its scientists from speaking publicly about their research. more »
- Putin confident Russians will make him president again
- Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin has voiced confidence that he will win Sunday's presidential election, while bluntly dismissing opposition demands and maintaining strong criticism of the United States. more »
Latest Health News Headlines
- Oxycontin officially replaced by new drug

- Drug company Purdue Pharma has replaced Oxycontin with a harder alternative called OxyNeo, which is harder to crush or inject. more »
- Aging improves shut-eye time
- Getting older is unlikely to hurt our quality of sleep, in fact it could improve it, according to a new report. more »
- Doctors operate on wrong leg of Manitoba man
- A Manitoba man who went for surgery on his Achilles tendon woke up in hospital to find doctors cut into the wrong leg. more »
- 5 reasons why flu season is M.I.A. this year
- The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has reported the lowest influenza infection rate in 30 years of tracking flu activity, as well as the slowest recorded start to the flu season. more »
FEATURED HEALTH
- Election call tapes being reviewed by Conservatives
- Misleading B.C. election call traced to Conservative Party
- Alberta family euthanizes husky that killed newborn
- B.C. Mountie's daughter faces drug charges
- B.C. teachers to start 3-day strike Monday
- Google Chrome hacking contest offers $1M in prizes
- Ex-student union president charged with bank robbery
- Missing Toronto girl's mom contacted after remains found
- Incidents suggest Israel-Iran 'cold war' intensifying

