Boys who start playing tackle football before their 12th birthday may be at sharply increased risk of behavioural and mood problems later in life compared with peers who hit the gridiron later, according to a recent U.S. study.
Among former professional, college and high school football players, those with earlier exposure to the game were more than twice as likely to report impairments in regulating their behaviour, while they had triple the risk of depression symptoms, Dr. Robert Stern of Boston University and his colleagues found.
"The findings suggest that being hit in the head repeatedly during what might be a critical window of neurodevelopmental vulnerability may increase risk for later-life emotional, behavioural and executive dysfunction," Stern told Reuters Health in a telephone interview.
- Study shows children take longer to recover from concussion
- 'Win at all costs' sport violence causing concussions, public health concerns
Repetitive head impacts, even when they do not lead to a full-fledged concussion, are associated with cognitive,
behavioural and mood problems in ex-football players, Stern's team writes in Translational Psychiatry. Repeated blows to the head are also associated with chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a degenerative brain condition that can only be diagnosed after death.
Not everyone exposed to repetitive head impacts develops CTE, the authors stress, so other factors — including age at first exposure to play — may make a person more or less vulnerable to lasting brain damage.
The researchers had 214 former football players complete a battery of tests of behaviour, mood and cognition by telephone. Those who began playing before age 12 — just under half of the group — had more depressive symptoms and more apathy than those who started playing later.
Repeated head impacts
"The brain undergoes dramatic maturation and growth throughout childhood and adolescence, but there are several brain structures and the functioning of certain areas of the brain that reach peak development during the years between ages 10 and 12 in males," he added.
That includes formation of a protective myelin covering on brain cell axons, he noted, and peak growth of critical structures in parts of the brain known as the limbic system. Myelination allows nerves to transmit impulses effectively, while the limbic system is important in emotional regulation.
"Right now there's a lot of discussion about whether youth football is indeed a safe thing for children to be doing," Stern said. "Maybe we should rethink how healthy and safe it is to expose children to repeated blows to the head through youth football."
The findings don't mean it's safe to start playing football after age 12, he said. "At least putting off tackle football until a later age may be beneficial, but not necessarily overall risk free. Anything we do to reduce the overall number of repetitive hits to the head would in my mind be a step forward."
The study is "important work," said Dr. Joel Stitzel of Wake Forest School of Medicine in Winston-Salem, N.C., but he noted that the study participants — whose average age was about 51 — were playing before the risks of head injury in football were well-recognized.
Stitzel and his colleagues, who were not involved in the study, are currently conducting National Institutes of Health-funded research on head impact exposures in youth football players.
"There are a lot of changes to youth organizations and youth leagues around the country that have taken place over the past several years," he said, such as eliminating kickoffs and limiting tackle football to older players. "Those are the things that are going to make the game safer going forward."