Concussion may hurt school performance after kids recover
Results reinforce that symptoms should be the guide in return to learn programs
Kids and teens who suffer a concussion worry about their academic skills in the weeks afterward, and older kids and those with more severe symptoms seems to worry the most, according to a new study.
Studies in the last five years have focused largely on the athletic side of the equation — "taking them off the field, not putting them back on the field with symptoms, but this is really looking at the student side of the equation," said senior author Gerard A. Gioia of Children's National Health System in Rockville, Maryland.
- Student concussion program sheds light on recovery
- Sports concussions in kids preventable by game changes, doctors say
A toolkit called HEADS UP to Schools, from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, already advises school professionals that after a concussion, kids may need to spend fewer hours at school, take more time for tests or assignments, or may feel frustrated at being unable to keep up with schoolwork.
Students should be seen by a health care professional, who can make decisions about school readiness based on symptoms.
The new results "support what we thought was happening," Gioia told Reuters Health by phone.
He and his coauthors surveyed 239 pairs of kids and their parents, plus another 110 kids' parents, after the kids were treated at an outpatient concussion clinic within 28 days of the injury, after they had returned to school. The youngsters ranged in age from 5 to 18.
Kids and parents reported post-injury academic experiences and concerns.
Based on neurocognitive tests at the clinic, only 109 of the 349 students, or 31 per cent, were recovered from their concussion and no longer had symptoms.
Almost 60 per cent of kids with symptoms, and 64 per cent of their parents, said they were moderately or very concerned about the concussion affecting school learning and performance, compared to 16 per cent of recovered kids and 30 per cent of their parents.
More high schoolers than middle school or elementary school students said they were concerned about their schoolwork, the researchers reported in Pediatrics.
More symptomatic kids reported having headaches interfere with school, problems paying attention or feeling too tired than kids without symptoms.
More than half of symptomatic kids said they were now spending more time on homework, compared to one-fifth of those without symptoms. They also reported more difficulty studying and taking class notes.
Recovery and high school test timelines
"The persistence of symptoms clearly is the most significant factor in academic impact," said Susan Saliba, a physical therapist, athletic trainer and associate professor at the Curry School of Education at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville.
The results reinforce that symptoms should be the guide in return to learn programs, Saliba, who was not involved in the new study, told Reuters Health by email.
"Anxiety, sleeplessness and moodiness are symptoms of concussion, but are strongly associated with adolescent behaviour and any external stress," she said. Having a plan in place helps alleviate stress, she said.
"The academic impact does differ depending on the kind of demand that a student experiences," Gioia said. "High schools students were reporting significantly greater concern, and a higher number of problems in school relative to middle school and younger students."
High school tests and timelines have implications for graduation and college, which could be a source of concern, he said.
"Concussions vary widely, generally speaking we want kids to get back into school as soon as they can tolerate it," Gioia said.
He said school systems need to be prepared to accept and support kids heading back into classroom before full recovery, which requires collaboration between medical professionals and school staff.