Swine flu: Report from a doctor in Mexico City
- April 28, 2009 3:15 PM |
- By Your Voice
Submitted by Antonio Avina

About: I am a rheumatologist, currently doing a PhD at the University of British Columbia. I am also a Research Scientist at the Mexican Institute of Social Security (IMSS) here in Mexico. I was on leave to conclude my PhD studies in Canada.
My story: I arrived in Mexico City last Friday morning at 8 a.m. from Vancouver. The previous night, Mexico's Health authorities announced that they had received confirmation from the CDC in Atlanta that a new virus, coming from swine to human contact was causing respiratory infections that might have caused at least 25 deaths at that moment. The first action they ordered was to suspend school activities at all levels in Mexico City and the State of Mexico.
On Friday I attended a meeting in a hotel with congressmen to discuss research public policy. We were about 150 people in a closed room.
That night media started to inform about the symptoms of the swine flu and recommend not to attend crowded places unless necessary and to wear a hospital mask.
On Saturday I went with a group of friends to a baptism away from Mexico City, and one of them insisted that everything was a big fake made by the government and the media (the next day, he repented). Masks were given out everywhere, especially in subways and public transport. The worry that day was what was going to happen with Sunday soccer matches. All cultural activities had already been cancelled.
The reports of more deaths and the spread to other states and possible cases in the U.S. and Canada increased awareness. Soccer matches were played "behind closed doors" with no audience. Religious services were suspended. On Sunday night health authorities widened preventive measures, stopping school activities nationwide and announced that the infected responded to an antiviral medication in the early stages.
Monday morning it was informed that all restaurants and public events are closed/cancelled and measures seemed to be being respected in Mexico City valley. The situation in the rest of the country is not clear.
What's been happening in Mexico City is a progressive build-up of fear in the community. At the beginning things were uncertain, with a lot of misinformation floating around. However, once the WHO (World Health Organization) took control of the situation, the community feels clear that there is a treatment for this problem and clear guidelines on what to do, when, and where. As this was something that was not known in the first days, things have calmed.
Currently people are asking why Mexicans are dying, but not individuals in Canada or the U.S. This of course has increased mistrust in the authority. Until today only doctors know that self-medication, which is very common in Mexico, results in a delay to seek medical attention. Initial cases arrived at the hospital when they were already very sick. The evidence until now it seems that the antivirals used in the treatment of this type of influenza are effective only if they are used within the first two days after the symptoms appear.
As of today, all cases with symptoms are being tested with a quick test (swab) and results are available within 1 hour (test is 75% sensitive). A positive screening test receives treatment immediately upon referral to hospitals, regardless of the results of confirmatory tests. Confirmatory tests are available in two days. The swab test is done here in Mexico and is a quick test, the confirmatory tests are sent to the U.S. and Canada. However, today there are two labs currently doing the tests here in Mexico (one in Mexico City and one more in Veracruz). A third lab will be set up soon.
People have stopped believing the authorities. Yesterday, authorities asked everyone not to rush out to buy groceries because stores would continue to work as usual. However, people rushed to stores this morning. This is a cultural behaviour based on a chronic lack of trust in authorities.
Today all small, local restaurants (called fondas) that sell food for people working in offices will not be allowed to sell food in their restaurants, they can only sell food to take home. In addition, all public events are cancelled including museums, movie theaters, mass, public libraries, and schools at all levels, in the whole country (initially it was only in Mexico City.) Individuals that can work from home are being allowed to do so. It is estimated that Mexico City alone is losing 728 million pesos per day ($78 million Cdn.) This may lead to a social crisis if it continues after May 5th (conditions have been set to continue until this date), especially if individuals loss their jobs, since this crisis is building on top of the financial crisis.
Cases are being referred to specific hospitals, mainly those that have respirology departments or infectious disease departments or secondary or tertiary hospitals if available. People have started visiting hospitals if they think they have the disease, because they know they cannot buy medication at the pharmacy (especially antivirals). Last night there was a report that the number of cases are decreasing, as well as the mortality rate, if this trend continues then there is hope for a quicker recovery. We will see.
In Mexico City yesterday 12,000 patients attended as an outpatient visits. From these, 6000 were as respiratory diseases, from these 29 were referred to hospitals under the suspect of swine influenza. This is the most recent evidence that individuals are finally following the instructions to seek medical attention prior to receive self-medication.
I do not know what is happening in the rural areas, since access to information and medical care have bigger gaps like in any country. Events in the next few days will determine social behavior, something that any sociologist will be very interested for future research.
I am not attending any patients, since I am following the recommendation of not travelling within the city if I don't have to. However, I am receiving many phone calls from family members, friends, friends from my friends asking for advise and specially asking about what do I think?
For announcements, Spanish speakers can view the official site of the Mexican Ministry of Health.
Are you or someone you know affected by swine flu? Share your stories.
Categories
All News blogs
Most Commented
Most Recommended
Citizen Bytes
Most Commented
Most Recommended
Recent Entries
- G20: Protesters, police, and civil rights
- Riot police surround G20 protesters in Toronto. (Carolyn Kaster/Associated Press)Submitted by Paul ManlyBio: Paul Manly is a filmmaker and community organizer based in Nanaimo, B.C. My story: I started my trip to Toronto at the Peoples Summit, which brought together... Continue reading this post
- G20: A voice from Malawi
- Dorothy Ngoma at Oxfam's Gender Justice Summit. (Allan Lissner/Oxfam Canada)Submitted by Dorothy NgomaDorothy Ngoma is the Executive Director of the National Organisation of Nurses and Midwives of Malawi and a member of the W8, a parallel organization to the... Continue reading this post
- Bangkok protests: A Canadian shares her story
- Thai police walk the streets to clear any remaining anti-government protesters on in Bangkok, Thailand. (Wally Santana/Associated Press) Submitted by Elaine SaulnierBio: Orignally from Montreal, Elaine Saulnier now lives and works in Bangkok, Thailand.My story: I've been here in... Continue reading this post
Comments (19)
Stay safe... If that is a reasonable option. Hope you can make it home to Canada soon and that this epidemic passes with less fatalities than what is feared.
Hi Barrie:
I will take care. You guys do not panic. This is the best scenario that could happen. A pandemia with possibility of treatment. Soon eveything will be under control.
There is a lot of fear and paranoia wrapped up in all this. I lived in Asia during the SARS situation. People were so scared of SARS, yet would drive or ride in the dangerous traffic, where MANY more injuries and fatalities were occurring on a regular basis. Now there was a real threat staring at everyone in the face, yet the fear of the unknown took precedence.
Thanks so much for the information! Your article helped to answer all the questions I had that I couldn't seem to find answers to in the headline articles. I was really quite fearful, having a daughter with asthma, but your story has helped me a great deal. Take care and stay safe!
Marc, I too was in Asia during SARS. 298 people died of SARS in Hong Kong over a few months vs 81 people who died last year in vehicle accidents of which 67 were pedestrians. The SARS threat was very real and the traffic threat minimal if you are not a total muppet who can't cross a road. How do you expect people to get to work?
Thanks to this doctor who has FINALLY made it clear to stop this panic!! Having lived in Central America for a number of years, I know how most people here tend to adopt the "wait & see" attitude, and fail to get medical attention before it's too late. One reason is lack of money, and another is poor education. Then too is the "home remedy" concept. Drink some tea from some crushed-up leaves, and you'll be fine. I hope that this situation will soon be controlled, and everybody can stop panicing over a simple flu bug. Have a great day.
Thank you for this, Dr. Avina. I lived in Mexico for a few years so I was not surprised to hear that this flu was more serious there. The people are used to treating themselves with homeopathic remedies or with antibiotics which can be bought over the counter instead of going to a medical doctor. It is too expensive and often inaccessible. Maybe more doctors will see patients for free in this state of emergency?
I wonder why if it only takes 2 days to confirm if the 159 people who died, did of Swine flu, it is taking so long for it to be resolved, since the testing is done in US and Canada. Numbers are critical to consider the type of serousness of the situation.
Good day Dr. Avina and we hope that things are improving in Mexico City. The news agencies here seemto have toned down the 'urgency' in thier reporting today so we are assuming that the number of infections and related mortality will soon show signs of a decline. There is a report of an infant fatality in Texas that was a child who came from Mexico but details are sketchy. We hope for your well being and that you are soon able to resume your studies/work.
I found it interesting that it was the Canadian National Microbiology Laboratory in Winnepeg that discovered the Mexican outbreak by using using genetic sequence data posted on an internet-based databank!
Is there any socio- economic relations to fatalities? Hi, I'm a mexican- canadian, and I've listened to alot of news from various sources. To me there seems to be a lack of investigation by mexican health authorities. For example, one big question that should be asked is whether the fatalities had any socio-economic relations. I know that in mexico there are big economic divides that may limit access to medicine and other aspects of health care. I have also spoken to friends in mexico, who have informed me that over the past few years many labourers have been trying to stop privatization of health care in mexico, and now blame current mediocre investigations by mexican health authorities on corrupt leaders trying to justify the move towards a private health care system. Although this is not clear, there is still much confusion about the numbers suspected of swine flu and the actual number of people that have it.
Hello to all again:
Just few lines to let you know that things continue estable, authorities are doing a proper job. Today the started with more than 50 mobil units in strategic places, this allow a quick screening test for swine influenza.
Be alert and do not panic you will start seeing more cases in Canada in the next few days. Hopefully, no deaths. Quick access to a doctor is the key action. All Canadians know about flu, anyone knows the symptoms. As soon as you have symptoms of this (just remember we are not talking about seasonal allergies, that are common in Canada now) go to your family doctor or hospital (but call before, so they are prepared) mainly because at this time of the year is quite unusual to have influenza.
I will give you an update in the next day or two. Also do not panic with the Alert 5 level that has been just implemented. Is alert 5, not ALARM 5. Basically is just to let people to be prepared to see new cases in different places, and that probably we will see a pandemic scenario (cases in different parts of the world), so is an alert to be prepared. In fact, the world is currently doing this (informing, alerting community, prepare lab tests, prepare to make quick diagnosis etc).
So, do not panic. Canada will do very well, since UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE is a luxury that we al should value and trust.
Dr Avina,
You are absolutely right - when people know that the treatment for this is regular anti-viral medication - then the fear index drops. People can then focus on preventative behaviours.
Thanks for the article and update.
It is very important to know how the body responds to a brand new virus. Learn what a Cytokine Storm is. Protect yourself.
Mexican'
To me there is more behind.
Political, socio economic issue.
playing with health is too bad
Hello All:
Sorry for the delay in updating you all. I have been gathering information on how things are currently here and also following what is going on in Canada, especially in BC where my family is.
Currently until today May 1st at 9 PM the numbers are the following:
1) The number of samples that have been tested are 908, from these 397 have been positive (43.7 %).
2) Among the positives only 16 have died and 381 are alive.
Currently antiviral therapy are available in pharmacies and only with prescription is dispensed. There is limited number of tests that can be done per day.
Situation is still the same, schools closed, public events are cancelled, restaurants, bars, and all entertainment is closed.
Something that is a concern to everyone is not all those cases who died have been confirmed. It seems that there are no sample to be tested.
I have started to see the same type of panic that we had at the onset of the outbrake and this will continue when the number of cases continues to grow. Please do not go as we did, Canada has more information now, specially that there is cure, early treatment is the key action, and mainly and outstanding universal health care. It is expected a vaccine this summer, this will give us a total control very soon.
This endemic problem is a call to continue supporting research science and technology. This has been the main limitation in Mexico. I hope that this NEW OPPORTUNITY wakes up our goverment to create a real public policy to support investment in science and technology. Canada should be proud of what they have accomplished, but is not enough. We may not be so lucky next time (response to treatment). We have to be prepared to respond faster and more efficient, regardless of the origin of first case.
In summary, things seems to get under control number of cases are going down. Once again, be alert about symptoms: high fever, severe headache, do not take drugs to control headache/fever until you talk to your help line or family doctor. Follow instructions and trust your health care system. If any system has proved that can handle severe problems is Canada. The SARS experience let you be the best.
I am still healthy and I will be back home soon. If anyone wants to know something post your question and I will update you. Regards to all.
Hi Dr. Avina,
Thank you for all of your posts, everything here was very informative.
I wonder, I am a bit of a hypochondriac and have been sick for 16 days. I have avoided seeing a doctor, as I don't have a family doctor, and I am probably fine.
I have cold related symptoms, like a headache, muscle aches, nasal congestion, and a cough.
But, with my normal paranoia and this whole swine flu hype, I am starting to worry that maybe I don't have a simple cold.
My nose has cleared up today, but I still have aches and pains. Maybe it is finally going away anyhow.
Do you think there is any real need for me to sit in a waiting room for hours? To my knowledge, I have not been in contact with anyone from Mexico. I do take public transit a few times a week, however.
Hi Kathy:
I am sorry for the delay in responding to your concerns. If you have been sick for 18 days now, instead of being afraid for the final outcome, you should still be fearful but take action.
It is normal to be afraid in this time, but let me insist you should take some action, since denial will not help. Furthermore, you should care for people around you. Remember, there is treatment for this.
I can not make an diagnosis or treatment other that encourage you to take action. Remember in health issues, early intervention are almost always associated with better outcomes.
Kathy, you need to relax. These are seasonal symptoms associated with the onset of summer. You probably feel this way every year between March and June.
This is a result of pollens, new tree and plant growths and last winter's dust, salt and other chemicals (on roads and driveways) being spun up into the air your breathe.
Industrial pig, cow, poultry and all food production is in fact increasing the risk of development and transmission of disease epidemics. Why are our governments refusing to acknowledge that huge agri-business is the source of many sicknesses. avian flu, sars, mad cow disease, swine flu, e-coli in spinach and salad greens, listerosis in prepared meats and countless other situations of bad bacteria in foods causing sickness and death.The media needs to dig into WHAT is causing weak immune systems in people? DIRTY AIR, DIRTY FOOD, DIRTY WATER resulting from deadly pollutants from INDUSTRIES.