Hot air
Posted in Reality Check Posted on October 2, 2008 11:51 PM | PermalinkBy Mark Gollom
In Wednesday night's French debate, Conservative Leader Stephen Harper claimed that the Tories "hard targets" of reducing Canada's greenhouse gas emissions (to 20 per cent of 2006 levels by 2020) is recognized by world leaders as one of the most aggressive plans in the world.
When asked by the Reality Check team which leaders he was referring to, the Conservative war room e-mailed quotes from German Chancellor Angela Merkel and José Barroso, the president of the European Commission. The comments were made at the June 2007 G8 summit in Berlin.
In an interview with CBC's The National,Merkel said: "Canada says it also sees the necessity to put in place long-term goals for reduction. By the middle of the century, Canada wants to reduce emissions significantly. I can say I am encouraged that we agree that, long-term, we need to reduce emissions significantly."
But Merkel's quote included the line: "Of course we are not happy at this point that Canada has abandoned Kyoto's goals." That was not in the e-mail sent to us.
As for Barroso's endorsement of Canada, he didn't specifically single out Canada for praise, saying only that "(Canada and Europe) agree on the need "to act swiftly on climate change."
Barroso added that the European Union and Canada "underlined the need for reducing global greenhouse gas emissions by at least half by 2050" and "are committed to work actively and constructively together."
Hardly a strong endorsement from either leader.
About the Authors
Ira Basen joined CBC Radio in 1984 and was senior producer at Sunday Morning and Quirks and Quarks. He was involved in the creation of three network programs The Inside Track (1985), This Morning (1997) and Workology (2001), and produced the award- winning radio documentary series Spin Cycles (2007). He has also written for Saturday Night, the Globe and Mail and the Walrus. He taught at the University of Toronto, the University of Western Ontario, and Ryerson. He is a co-author of the Canadian edition of The Book of Lists (Knopf, 2005).
John Gray has worked for a number of Canadian newspapers, including most recently more than 20 years with the Globe and Mail, where he served as Ottawa bureau chief, national editor, foreign editor, foreign correspondent and national correspondent
Mark Gollom has been a news writer for CBCNews.ca since 2003. He's worked as a reporter at the National Post, the Ottawa Citizen and the Toronto Sun. Mark has a degree in political science from the University of Western Ontario and a diploma in journalism from Centennial College in Toronto.
Related:
Party platforms: Ira Basen on the campaign pledges that made a difference
Ira Basen: 'There oughta be a law'
The National: Reg Sherren reports on economic fundamentals
The National: Terry Milewski on carbon offsets
The National: Terry Milewski investigates the GST controversy
Recent Post
Archives
- October 2008 (8)
- September 2008 (29)


