Windsor pathologist sued over diagnostic errors
Last Updated: Monday, July 26, 2010 | 6:45 PM ET
CBC News
The estate of a Windsor, Ont., woman is suing a local pathologist, alleging she made diagnostic errors and seeking damages of $30 million on behalf of herself and other people hurt by the doctor's mistakes.
The lawsuit, which seeks class action status, was prompted by the case of the late Margaret Musgrave. Musgrave, who was 80 at the time, was rushed to the Hôtel-Dieu Grace Hospital in Windsor with a ruptured appendix in early 2007.
Dr. Olive Williams was given three slides of Musgrave's appendix tissue to examine. She only looked at two and declared there was no cancer present.
A year later, Musgrave was diagnosed with cancer that appeared to have started in her appendix. She died in May 2008.
A subsequent investigation by the Ontario College of Physicians and Surgeons led to an admission from Williams that she had overlooked the third slide.
"I am at a loss to explain how it is that I did not examine the third slide," she wrote to the investigator.
The college later issued her a written caution for her mistake.
Williams subsequently had her privileges at Hôtel-Dieu suspended in January after the discovery of several other serious mistakes in her work.
An internal report by the Erie St. Clair local health integration unit found that the hospital uncovered five mistakes attributed to Williams, one of which led at an unnecessary colostomy from a wrong cancer diagnosis.
A sixth case — which led to an unnecessary lumpectomy — later came to light.
15,000 cases under review
Williams worked on 15,000 cases between 2003 and 2010. In addition to working at Hôtel-Dieu, she provided pathology services to Windsor Regional Hospital and Leamington District Memorial Hospital.
An internal report obtained by the Ontario Conservative Party says the hospital suggests that Williams's cataracts, which can seriously impair vision, may have played a role in her diagnostic errors.
Investigators looking into pathology tests in the Windsor area are expected to deliver their findings to the Ontario Minister of Health at the end of the week.
After that, the report will be publicly released. That could happen next week.
With files from the CBC's Pat JeflynShare Tools
Latest Windsor News Headlines
- Health-care advocates slam Drummond report
- A public health advocacy group is accusing the Ontario government of manufacturing a crisis to justify billions of dollars in health-care cuts expected in the highly anticipated Drummond report. more »
- MP turns to international law to stop Windsor hum
- The NDP's Brian Masse is scouring international law in search of a way to put a stop to the mysterious rumbles and hums that have plagued Windsor, Ont. for more than a year. more »
- Allergy alert issued for Sweets From The Earth
- People with milk allergies are being warned not to consume certain Sweets From The Earth products because they contain milk which isn't declared on the labels. more »
- Fraudster uses Ont. van crash to dupe senior
- Windsor Police say an alleged fraudster used the tragic Ontario van crash that killed 11 people to fool a senior citizen into sending him nearly $3,000 in cash. more »
Top News Headlines
- Quebec man charged with killing mother, 2 nieces
- A 35-year-old man has been charged with three counts of first-degree murder in connection with the deaths of his mother and two young nieces in Quebec's Eastern Townships. more »
- Manitoba trailer fire kills 4
- Four people are dead after an early-morning fire quickly engulfed a residential trailer in Selkirk, Man. more »
- Harper's China visit ends with panda pact

- Prime Minister Stephen Harper wrapped up a visit to China aimed seeking new investments by officially announcing that Beijing will loan two of the country's prized giant pandas to Canadian zoos. more »
- Attawapiskat sites not ready for modular homes
- The first two of 22 modular homes promised by the federal government to Attawapiskat are on their way to the remote northern Ontario community, but the minister handling the Aboriginal Affairs portfolio is expressing concern over the "readiness" of the lots. more »
- MP turns to international law to stop Windsor hum
- Ontario PCs give Hudak a 2nd chance
- Hockey at Windsor Arena quickly coming to end
- Health-care advocates slam Drummond report
- CAW questions Caterpillar takeover of Electro-Motive
- Big-city crime? Murder rates are higher in rural Canada
- Justin Bieber's grandparents in car accident
- Allergy alert issued for Sweets From The Earth
- Massive pileup near Sarnia, Ont., kills 2

