Notifications

U.S. no-fly list could be why some Canadian kids deemed high risk travellers

Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale says in a letter to affected families that some Canadian children are blocked from air travel due to 'many reasons' including having their names appear on foreign security lists.

Having same name as barred passenger on foreign list could disrupt travel plans even within Canada

Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale says there are 'many reasons' people might experience delays or be prohibited from boarding a flight. (CBC)

The U.S. no-fly list, not Canada's secret air security roster, might be what has been ensnaring Canadian youngsters, Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale is telling several families experiencing travel headaches.

In a letter to a representative of dozens of families whose children have trouble boarding airplanes, Goodale said delays can occur for passengers who have the same name as a person on Canada's list, or "another security-related list such as the U.S. no-fly list."

The reply to Khadija Cajee, whose six-year-old son, Adam, has been repeatedly delayed at the airport, underscores the complex — and often hidden — web of security measures intended to keep North American skies safe.

Goodale promised to investigate after Adam's father, Sulemaan Ahmed, tweeted a photo from Toronto's international airport that appeared to show the boy's name with a "deemed high profile" label and instructions on how to proceed before allowing the youngster to check in.

Delays may occur for passengers who have the same name as a person listed under the [Passenger Protect Program], or another security-related list such as the U.S. no-fly list.- Ralph Goodale, public safety minister

They were trying to board an Air Canada flight on Dec. 31, 2015, to Boston to see the NHL Winter Classic.

Soon after, Goodale said his officials had reminded airlines they don't need to screen children against Canada's no-fly list, officially known as the Passenger Protect Program.

Goodale's department is also exploring possible changes to the Secure Air Travel Regulations that would help identify those who have similar or the same names as people on the no-fly list, but are not the intended targets.

In addition, Goodale indicated the Passenger Protect Program would be examined during broad public consultations on Canada's overall security framework.

Foreign lists, domestic delays

People with similar stories of airport snags began contacting Cajee, of Markham, Ont. She then put questions to Goodale on behalf of 21 families with Canadian-born children ranging in age from six months to 17 years. Several others who spoke with Cajee were wary of attaching their names to the letter.

'I still have not received an answer to a very basic question: Who creates and maintains the DHP list?' says Khadija Cajee after receiving a letter from the public safety minister. (CBC)
In his reply, Goodale said there are "many reasons" people might experience delays or be prohibited from boarding a flight.

"For example, other countries, as well as airlines, maintain various security-related lists with different criteria and thresholds, which may result in delays for individuals travelling to, from, or even within Canada," Goodale wrote.

"Delays may occur for passengers who have the same name as a person listed under the [Passenger Protect Program], or another security-related list such as the U.S. no-fly list."

Goodale suggested that these travellers might want to contact the airline's customer service representative to explain their situation and to see what steps can be taken before arriving at the airport. "Furthermore, if you suspect you are on another country's list, it is recommended that you explore their specific recourse mechanisms."

Who controls DHP list?

Cajee said she is pursuing the U.S. government's redress process on behalf of Adam.

And while she appreciates the minister's response, Cajee said there should be a better Canadian recourse system. The existing one applies only to those explicitly forbidden from getting on a plane due to the Passenger Protect Program.

"Currently, as a Canadian, I have access to a U.S.-based redress process, but as a Canadian, I do not have access to a Canadian redress process unless I have been denied boarding," she said.

"Our children have never been denied boarding because they are, well, children and obviously innocent. It boggles the mind that a potentially guilty person who is denied boarding can access a Canadian redress process but a six-year-old child cannot."

Cajee also took issue with the assertion the problem might be a foreign-security issue.

"I still have not received an answer to a very basic question: Who creates and maintains the DHP list? It is a fairly straightforward question."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.